What is Googles responsibility to its searchers? In a Thursday panel at the Aspen Ideas Festival, Jonathan Zittrain*,a professor of Internet law at Harvard law school, offered a hypothetical that captured why that question is so difficult to answer.

Before getting to that hypothetical, lets assume that Google commitswhether formally or informallyto the notion that it has some responsibility to look out for its users. For example, if someone searches for the best way to drive from Los Angeles to Salt Lake City, it will direct them to the fastest or safest route, not the route that takes them past an out-of-the-way fast food chain that paid off the search engine.

Thats an easy case: The best interests of the searcher is clear.

In contrast, Zittrains hypothetical raised larger questions about what it means to act in a searchers best interests. Suppose Google is a fiduciary to us, they and Bing decide that they're going to look out for us. And I happen to believe that vaccines are probably bad, he began. And I Google should I vaccinate my child?

If Google is looking out for me, he continued, should they interpret that in the best way as, you've got to shake this person by the lapels, the way that I presume a doctor would?

Or should a benevolent Googles approach be, We're looking out for you, we know what kinds of articles you're looking for, let us speed you to your destination?


Generally, he said, he has no ready answer. But I think the reason we turn to experts, why they have power over us and why we want them to be fiduciaries, is to get the benefits of that expertise, he added. In that instance, wed probably want to be told that the best state of medicine now is that you probably want to have that vaccine.

So when should a search engine act like an expert? When should it direct searchers as neutrally as possible to the Web pages that theyre seeking? And to what degree should it consider the interests of people other than the person searching?

Here are some other hypothetical search terms:

  • Are humans causing climate change?
  • Is it okay to cheat on my spouse?
  • How to make a bomb with pressure cooker and nails;
  • Most painful way to spank child;
  • Is Google evil?
  • Leaked sex tape of [insert unwilling celebrity]
  • Most painless suicide method
  • What do I tell my incoming freshman daughter about campus rape?

As yet, I cant think of a single method Id want a search engine to apply to all of those search terms.

Can you?

*Correction: An earlier version of this article misattributed these remarks to another speaker on the same panel.

It has come to my attention that Google's search engine results are a lie, Bing as well. Try to look up somethingcontroversial, and see what it tells you are the search results.

Then, try duckduckgo.com , and see the REAL results.

Your search engine is lying to you. -Elisa Altschuler