╌>

Have We Been Blaming Putin Due To US Media Censorship ---- But Should Be Blaming Yeltsin Instead ?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  chloe  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Have We Been Blaming Putin Due To US Media Censorship ---- But Should Be Blaming Yeltsin Instead ?

Stop the pointless demonization of Putin

" ...

Well-informed opinions, in the West and in Russia, differ considerably as to the pluses and minuses of Putins leadership over the years my own evaluation is somewhere in the middle but there is no evidence that any of these allegations against him are true, or at least entirely true. Most seem to have originated with Putins personal enemies, particularly Yeltsin-era oligarchs who found themselves in foreign exile as a result of his policies or, in the case of Mikhail Khodorkovsky, in prison. Nonetheless, U.S. media, with little investigation of their own, have woven the allegations into a near-consensus narrative of Putins Russia.

Even the epithet commonly applied to Putin is incorrect. The dictionary and political science definition of autocrat is a ruler with absolute power, and Putin has hardly been that. There are many examples of his need to mediate, sometimes unsuccessfully, among powerful groups in the ruling political establishment and of his policies being thwarted by Moscow and regional bureaucracies. Moreover, if Putin really were a cold-blooded, ruthless autocrat, tens of thousands of protesters would not have appeared in Moscow streets, not far from the Kremlin, following the December presidential election. Nor would they have been officially sanctioned as were the thousands who gathered yesterday before a small group breached the sanctioned lines and violence ensued or shown on state television.

But consider the largest, and historically most damning, accusation against Putin. Russian democratization began in Soviet Russia, under Mikhail Gorbachev, in 1989-91. De-democratization, as it is often called, began not under Putin but under Yeltsin, in the period from 1993 to 1996, when the first Russian president used armed force to destroy a popularly elected parliament; enacted a super-presidential constitution; privatized the former Soviet states richest assets on behalf of a small group of rapacious insiders; turned the national media over to that emerging financial oligarchy; launched a murderous war in the breakaway province of Chechnya; and rigged his own re-election. (On February 20, outgoing president Dmitri Medvedev shocked a small group of visitors by finally admitting that Yeltsin had not actually won that election against the Communist leader Gennadi Zyuganov.) Putin may have only moderated those fateful policies, but he certainly did not initiate them.

The catastrophic Yeltsin 1990s, which have been largely deleted from the U.S. media narrative, also put other anti-Putin allegations in a different perspective. The corruption rampant in Russia today, from seizures of major private investments to bribes demanded by officials, is a direct outgrowth of the violent and other illicit measures that accompanied privatization under Yeltsin. It was then that the swindlers and thieves denounced by todays opposition actually emerged... "

http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/05/07/stop-the-pointless-demonization-of-putin/

From over a year ago and the emphasis is mine, but I think this author makes some very insightful and relevant points about a leader that is being prejudiced as a "KGB Thug" and "Autocrat," erroneously... as exemplified in granting the right to protest, among others. He is obviously being measured in alignment with previous Russian dictators - and perhaps shouldn't be, once the truth is known.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Good point, John. I agree that author-bias is very important to be aware of - personally, I'll review nearly any source - be it left or right-leaning; but it's the Journalist that I generally note for credibility/validation/factual information, unless it's an opinion piece, that will determine if I read them again. I'm not familiar with this author.

This is a Blog, so is opinion of course, mixed in with facts; do you dispute any 'facts' that he stated?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

I do remember reading this from the Fiscal Times, not knowing how trustworthy the info was from that site, during the period of my reading about Snowden's plight. I remember them stating this:

" He is asking for asylum in a country that continues to openly squash dissent, often using violent tactics..."

I did wonder if what they meant by that is similar to what happens here - say with some of those OWS protests that were disruptive and/or violent, causing the police or swat teams to use tear gas and make arrests.

I'm not suggesting that I would want to be under a Communist regime - not at all [not that you thought that--just sayin']; I seeded this article only to point out the suggestion of media bias and censorship, possibly intentional, to discredit Russia and Putin in the minds of Americans... I don't know who to believe.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

To show more of what the Fiscal Times had to say about Putin in a bad view:

PUTINS HEAVY HAND

Putin, a former KGB agent, used blunt force to rise to power after former President Boris Yeltsin left office. He created powerful networks of former spies and installed them in the Russian government and in Gazprom, the state-controlled energy giant that bankrolled Putins rise to the top.

Rivals who challenged Putin were jailed. Mikhail Khodorkovsky and Platon Lebedev, chiefs of Yukos, a Gazprom rival, were jailed in 2005 on trumped up charges, and remain locked up today.

Others like former KGB agent Alexander Litvinenko and robber baron Boris Berezovsky fled the country, but both met untimely ends. Litvinenko was poisoned with radioactive polonium and died in the United Kingdom in 2006. His widow accused the FSB of staging a hit. Berezovsky was also found dead at his home in the UK earlier this year. Authorities said he committed suicide.

Russian journalists are also under constant threat; according to the Committee to Protect Journalists, 56 have been killed since 1992. Last week, a reporter who criticized the government was killed in Dagestan. There were numerous attempts on the life of Anna Politkovskaya, a prominent journalist who often clashed with the president. The assassins finally succeeded in 2006, when she was gunned down in the elevator of her Moscow apartment. Her murder remains unsolved.

- See more at:

___

I'm not interested in case by case assessment either, and I don't see Putin as a leader of a free world either. I just want to know, if possible [not as opinion] if we can believe any of the media sources re Russia.

 
 

Who is online




122 visitors