╌>

Neighborhood News and Views – Syria Questions and Answers

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  19 comments

Neighborhood News and Views – Syria Questions and Answers

The gang got together for a Labor Day weekend barbeque and as it usually does after dinner conversation turned politics and current events. The main topic of conversation was Syria what should be done, when it should be done and by whom it should be done.

We came up with some basic questions and answers (our view on the answers obviously).

Is the use of chemical warfare wrong?

Absolutely!

Should Assad be removed from office?

Again, absolutely but not in a U.S. orchestrated regime change but rather by the Syrian people as this is a civil war which as yet has not spread into a neighboring nation. The results of U.S. interventions into civil wars and in orchestrating regime changes has not been so good in recent decades Iran, Viet Nam, Iraq, Libya, Egypt are examples that came up in our conversation.

Does the president have the authority to commit military force against an imminent threat to the U.S.?

Of course he does, but the imminent threat to the U.S. is not totally clear to us.

What will the Congress do with the Presidents proposed resolution to intervene?

The consensus of the group was that there would be four factions, which believe that

1) the presidents proposed actions should be supported without question

2) the presidents proposed actions go too far

3) the presidents proposed actions do not go far enough

4) the presidents proposed actions should be opposed without wavering

Ultimately, the president will receive support for some level of intervention, but the vote of confidence will be split without unanimous party support or opposition to the plans.

Should the U.S. be the worlds policeman?

No! (Unanimous)

Should the U.S. act alone, or only as part of a U.N. led coalition?

As part of a U.N./multinational coalition of nations is the only way we should become involved in the conflict in Syria.

What happens if our intervention (missile strikes) result in a Syrian attack on Israel, Israel's rapid and extensive retaliatory strikes and the subsequent spread of hostilities in the region?

We had no answer to this question, but we agreed that no good would result from a multinational, regional war in the middle east.

Well nothing really startling, but I wanted to share our thoughts on the issue.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Syria poses more questions than there are easy answers but here is how we saw it on the back porch this weekend

I do not assume that any or all of these conclusion/answers are absolutely correct and am interested to hear what others think the answers are to these seemingly simple questions.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Mike

Appreciate the perspective

Just some country guys talking on the porch, all veterans by the way who have and would fight for this country if necessary, but want sending our children into a conflict that could rapidly escalate to be well thought out and justified process.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I don't think we can adequately answer all of these questions based upon the information we now have available. However the President is going to give an updated, in-depth briefing to members of Congress (I believe its today?) and that should help clarify a lot of things.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Should the U.S. act alone, or only as part of a U.N. led coalition?

As part of a U.N./multinational coalition of nations is the only way we should become involved in the conflict in Syria.

I definitely think the President should discuss this with Congress before acting.

But the UN? (Remember how they handled Rwanda?). To cite but one horrific example.

Only in concert with a coalition? Why? Do you think our military is to weak to act alone? Or do you think U.S. policy should not be determined by our elected official, but rather partly by foreign countries? (Perhaps other countries should have a vote on issues like Obamacare-- or even our policies with Russia? On treaties we may sign with Britain?).

Well, since we shouldn't be allowed to formulate our own countrie's policies ourselves, how many countries should have veto power over US decisions? How big should a coalition be before we are allowed to act? A majority of the world's countries? Major powers: Britain, France,Russia, China?) Or, maybe, just some U.S.. allies-- maybe Turkey + France + Israel + the UAE?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

Thanks for the perspective

As to your questions

Did you notice that your group was discussing policing a sovereign nation?

Yes, we live n the country but are all well educated and realized that point early in the discussion.

if the US should be sanctioned as it intends to sanction Syria, for the USA's various crimes against humanity?

Not one of the questions that came up, so we did not discuss but I would think that if we are going to enforce international laws and regulations on others that we should abide by those same rules.

Would you be comfortable with some other world government deciding that enough is enough andproceeding tolobbombsat us in an effort to teach us that violence doesn't pay?

I am sure that other world governments have contemplated that option time to time and decided that the consequences of such an action would not be in their best interests. I think the U.S. demonstrated the consequences of attacking this country after Pearl Harbor and I doubt that it will occur again; terrorist attacks are a different matter that we continue to deal with as they occur.

What gives you and your BBQ buddies or any group of people here in the States the right to decide what happens in Syria?

Well it looks like you were too busy pontificating to read the article which clearly shows that we do not support the U.S. acing alone in deciding what should be done (if anything) in Syria or carrying out any military action.

So, I guess at heart the short answer to your primary question is that we do not think that the U.S. should be the world's policeman and should not unilaterally involve itself in the affairs of other nations.

You really should read the article whoch will enable you t understand the conclusions that we reached in our discussions

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Mike in Ga

Exactly what we concluded but you said it in a clear and direct manner

THanks

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

BadFish

Your perspective is always interesting so I will look forward to it

Hope you enjoyed your bbq

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Krishna

Perhaps you are correct

We did not disbelieve what Pres Obama or Secy Kerry had to say about the use of the chemical weapons and as I stated above we all agreed that it needed to be stopped.

More information is not likely to sway our opinion (and many Americans opinions in my view) that the U.S. should not be acting unilaterally in Syria or anywhere else.

Thanks for the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Krishna

If the UN is ineffective and useless it should be disbanded but if we continue to herald it as the international forum it is supposed to be then we should be acting as part of and in support a IN decision and force and not unilaterally.

Only in concert with a coalition? Why? Do you think our military is to weak to act alone?

That is absurd, it is not a question of whether we can act alone it a question of whether we should.

Perhaps other countries should have a vote on issues like Obamacare-- or even our policies with Russia? On treaties we may sign with Britain?).

Okay well that is absurd that you see in your rearview mirror now. What you argue against other nations doing for the U.S. is exactly what we will be doing if we unilaterally attack and orchestrate a regime change in Syria -- tampering with the internal affairs of another country.

If the U.S. is to act alone, let the President and the Congress come together with a declaration of war on Syria and then we can go in and affect the regime change that many want and most deem necessary.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

I think there is a level of disingenuousness in your comment, but I am going to answer it as you are making a serious point.

We support action to stop the use of chemical weapons in Syria, we simply do not support unilateral action by the U.S.

If the right thing to do is for the U.S. to unilaterally attack Syria, then the president and the congress should come together with a declaration of war on Syria.

I personally do not give a damn what social media says, I merely offered our views on the matter.

If the UN (the international community of the 98% of the world's nations that President Obama talks about) decides to take action, we should support that action. If we want to attack Syria on our own, we should declare war on Syria.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

There is substance to your points but this is not a philosophical discussion we find ourselves in and I presented our views on the situation and what "we" thought was the best course of action.

I respect your differing opinion and thank you for sharing it and for taking the time to understand my perspective as well.

Actually, as to your one question, I oppose state sanctioned assignation via drones but as part of am arsenal in the prosecution of a military campaign they are of great value.

Just as I do not think it appropriate for Canada to send a drone into the U.S. to kill someone, I also do not think we should be using drones to kill people in countries where we are not involved in combat

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Mike In Ga

A pet peeve of mine, foreign aid or "paying them to like us" as I think of it these days and sadly the more money we give the less hey like us in reality

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

I think you will actually find that the majority of weaponry in the Assad military are of Russian/Soviet origin rather than being supplied by the Americans.

Though they may have used money we gave them to pay for some of them.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Mike in Ga

No doubt philosophic discussions are important, but the decision to enter hostilities and commit military force against a sovereign nation is not philosophic it is very, very prgamatic

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

Russia is not "the west" and that is who supplied the weapons

So the answer to your question is No.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

You and Mike make a good team and I would refer you to my response to him concerning the philosophic and pragmatic

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

I disagree with

While if pragmatic concerns are rigidly followed then the demands of each moment get prioritized leaving your civilization without any long term goals.

It is possible to be pragmatic in the future and also to be humane and visionary in looing to the future.

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    13 years ago

Mike...this is off-topic, but ah certainly like the Allman Brothers "Eat A Peach" album cover as yer avatar. Great album...!!!

sorry...back to the 'new war'.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

OvO

I view visionary and philosophic as different but In understand and accept that others se tem as the same thing

Thanks for all the back and forth

 
 

Who is online







96 visitors