The Syrian Dilemma - What To Do?
Syrians retrieve sleeping dead after alleged chemical attack kills more than 500 people, including scores of children.
This citizen journalism image provided by the Local Committee of Arbeen which has been authenticated based on its contents and other AP reporting, shows a Syrian man helping a woman as she mourns over the dead bodies of children after an alleged poisonous gas attack fired by regime forces, according to activists in Arbeen town, Damascus, Syria, Wednesday, Aug. 21, 2013 .
The British House of Commons, late this afternoon (5:35 pm Aug.28, 2013) REJECTED a proposal by Prime Minister David Cameron to provide limited military assistance to the U.S. in preventing further use of Chemical weapons in Syria.
With President Obama evaluating the information providing strong evidence thatBashar Assad unleashed chemical weapons on the people of Syria, Briton, his #1 ally, has informed him they will not participate in military intervention.
Now the question is should Obama move ahead, based on the information he has with only Turkey and France at our side? OR should Obama move move ahead at all?
A while back President Obama drew his infamous red line, putting his credibility and the credibility of the United States on that line, which puts us in the position that we must do what we said we were going to do and go in, or we break our word.
If we do go in, to what extent should we go? Just cruise missiles, cruise missiles and air strikes, or the unlikely, cruise missiles, air strikes and BOTG? But most important,..... ,what effect will whatever we decide have on the direction of the war rebellion?
The videos I have seen make it clear Chemical gasses were used, and the reports I have listened to indicate the rebels lack the ability to launch such an extensive attack. So the Assad regime had to have unleashed this horror. The videos are shocking and graphic. People were choking, twitching and writhing in pain. A young childs' arms legs and eyes were twitching all various directions at once, another had white foam coming out his nose, with his eyes rolled up in his head, apparently in a catatonic state.
These creeping killers, these horrible gasses, that in the case of saran, is a gas you cannot see, you cannot smell, and you don't even know when you have been exposed to it until you get sick, after which you get dead. Others attack your nerve centers causing your body to slowly shut down until your dead.
So here's the dilemma:
We can't take out the WMD's with missiles and air strikes because that would disperse the gasses.
We can't confiscate the stockpiles with boots on the ground w/o getting into a full scale war.
The only thing we can do, at this time, is to cripple the Syrian military with missiles and air strikes making it impossible for Assad to disperse more chemicals.
BUT ....and there is a but ,a big one ..... If we cripple the Syrian military, it will open the door for al qeada and the Hezbollah, both of which are very active in this conflict on the side of the rebels, to get a solid foothold and possibly take control of the country.
Do we really want to be partners with al qeada and Hezbollah?
Or do we want to allow this horror to contineu.
So ... there is the problem in a nutshell.
Any suggestions?
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

We will eventually go in with a NATO coalition, Assad will deposed and we "help" the rebels establish and interim administration, which will not have the earmanks of al qeada or Hezbollah.
Then we will see what happens. Which could almost anything, .......my head hurts, I can't think about it any more.
What do you think will happen?
I suggest we stay out of it. The British are thinking strait.
Sure he has a choice, he ignores the red line statement, like he does the transparency statement.
I don't think it matters what the report says. The UN General Assembly has no real power-- only the Security Council does. And they can only act if none of the 5 major powers veto it. Of course both Russia and China, who allies of Assad, will veto any resolution giving the go ahead to any attack on Syria.
Obama foolishly backed himself into a corner when he said the use of WMDs would be a "red line".
If the UN finds Assad used chemical weapons, Obama will look like a wimp who doesn't keep his word if we don't attack. And other dictatorships worldwide will take notice of our impotence...
OTOH, having said that using WMDs is a red line-- if the UN finds those weapons were used by the rebels-- than Obama should attack the rebels (which would help Assad). I can't imagine the U.S. attacking the rebels.
U.S. foreign policy re: Syria has been a disaster-- and the same can be said for our actions in Egypt.
If you have been following the news regarding Syria, you will know that Assad has been reining death and destruction on his people for over two years, killing over 100,000 Syrian men, women, children and babies. Western weapons and technology are the only means available to cripple the Syrian militarysignificantly enough to prevent Assad from murdering more of his people and bring this violence to a finish.
Now he has started to utilize chemical warfare, and act that is a war crime. Are you suggesting it is better to allow Assad to continue to bomb and gas Syrian civilians, killing 10's of thousands more of them, rather than send in missile and air strikes in an attempt to bring an end to the violence?
You're jumping to the conclusion we are planning to invade Syria with ground troops, which could not be farther from the facts at hand.
As far as "leaving another country in ruins"
The country is already in ruins and Assad apparently is not done yet.
See More Photos
The Red Line statement was made on national television and has been repeated on national television. What kind of transparency are you looking for?
There is no good option. Going into Syria would be like going into hell to settle a fight between the devil and the demons. the least bad option is do nothing, then deal with whoever survives the civil war.
This is the rough spot the administration is in for sure...
I find myself asking if Afghanistan and Iraq hadnt happend to color this, would the decision be this much of a nail biter still or not?
My personal stance is we should stay out... but Obama had to red line the situation and now we are stuck doing something solo or looking like we're full of empty threats. More cowboy politics...
We just think we can fix this with simple solutions and it's just so broken.
I tend to agree with you Badfish.
Keep out of it. Help innocent people get out of it (relocate). And hope they keep it internal.
if only it were that simple. The Middle East has been a thorn in the side of America ever since Henry Forddevelopedhis production line.
Just a slight clarification; Hezbollah is actually supporting Assad. Al Qaeda is the strongest element of the rebel faction and would be the folks most likely to benefit from any action we take against Assad. There are no "good guys" here. Best to just stay out of it altogether. Better to look weak than get involved in this mess.
How many more people do you think it is possible to "re-locate"?
And that's just the children who've been relocated. . (Click on the link to see what life is like for them).
Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news , world news , and news about the economy
No matter what, Israel will become involved, and theopposition has their good ol' scapegoat. Then the region is fucked.
...and of course there are some redlines that Obama will not cross...
FWIW, as to actually going into Syria-- the president has clearly stated that we will not do that (so, unless its believed that President is a blatant liar-- we will not be going into Syria.)
If we do engage in any military action, it will be done by firing Tomahawk Cruise Missiles from warships. (N.B: the range of these weapons is 1000 nautical miles..)
Which would mean that Assad would continue to gas civilians-- probably even more so now that he knows he can get away with it. In addition, if we take no action, other terrorist groups worldwide now know that the U.S. is a "paper tiger"...
It seems likely the current civil war will go on for years.
And its already beginning to spread to Lebanon, also Iraq. Huge numbers of refugees are in Lebanon, Turkey, Jordan-- and as the war continues their number will only increase. Neither side will win for a long time...
"Red-Lines"...who needs 'em!
Nope. Wrong again!
The opposition consists of several groups. True "jihadists, Al Qaeda and extremists". But there is also the Free Syrian Army, which are moderates, many are secularists.
Your assertion that FSA consists of radicals is 180 degrees wrong!. In fact the opposite is true. (If you followed the news, you would know that-- and also know that in addition to fighting Assad-- the FSA and al-Qaeda have actually been fighting each other!!!
DOH!
And this one Syrian Children Paying a terrible Price
Below are photos of rows of temporary buildings that stretch as far as the eye can see in a desert refugee camp that is now home to 160,000 Syrians.
The Zaatari camp in Jordan has become the countrys fifth largest city, with 6,000 people a day arriving after fleeing war against Bashar al-Assads dictatorship. From: The Mirror News (read the whole article)
Exactly!
Jerry, we have done this before, and if common sense is to prevail, we must NOT strike Syria as we did Iraq. I have seen various reports all over the media about the use of these chemical weapons, including repeated citing of "evidence" of this by John Kerry. While in absolute terms, the evidence shows the use of chemical weapons, there is no absolute evidence that it was used by the regime. Merely assuming from hearsay that the rebels are not skilled enough to use them on this scale, is jumping to conclusions. A strike in Syria will be just as detrimental to the US as the strike in Iraq. No good will ever come out of it. And by the way, who exactly are we supporting in Syria? Al Qaeda???
I know, I "misspoke" when I posted that. I later remembered saying it somewhere, but I couldn't remember what thread it was on, I don't know what I was thinking. Thanks for the heads up Chucky.
I agree we are likely helping As Qaeda if we take steps to cripple the Syrian military, I'm sure that's why Obama ishesitatingabout going in there. But we can't allow people to use chemical weapons and not do anything about it, all that does is send a signal to other rogue countries, like North Korea and Iran that it's ok to use chemical weapons. Not to mention, if Assad pulled the trigger on this one or not, if we don't do anything, Assad may get the idea to use the chems again, only in a bigger way. He does posses the largest stockpile of the shit in the world.
Footnote; We have 28,000 troops in S. Korea and the Korean DMZ, and N. Korea has its' Taepodong-2 Rocket which is capable of reaching US Territory, and Kim Jong un, who hates the United States with a passion, is an unknown entity. Might he get a notion to use chemical weapons iftheworld does nothing about the worstmassacre by chemical warfare in the history of the world?
(?!) We are not striking Syria as we did Iraq. Iraq was an all invasion of that country with troops, tanks,artillery,missiles,rockets and Dick Cheney. Syria is a completely differentscenario.
If we go into Syria it will be as we did in Libya where we used air support to help therebelsprevail without the loss of one American life and without putting one American boot on the ground.
That was a week ago, the evidence is in, thechemicalscame from Assads' military. We just don't know who gave the order
It will cripple the Syrian military, destroying their aircraft, missilelaunchpads, airport runways and radar facilities, making it impossible to carry out any further chemical attacks.
If anybody see's anything good that can come out of attacking Syria considering this please take the floor. I'm all ears.
How about eyes. Please, go to this link The-terrible-destruction-of-syria-in-graphic-photos
I think Vietnam started with a one time bombing mission.
If a few missiles don't work, what next and how far do we go?
Petey,
If you have any opinions regarding this particular article, I would suggest you remove the above link and post your comments on this thread.
I consider your posting a link to one of your own articles on the same topic, to be an attempt to highjack this discussion, and have reported it as such.
JV
OK , I have removed my comment as per your request .
Here is the amended comment :
Yes . Before decisions can be made you need to understand the realpolitik .
You can find an article about that on NT . I would go into the details but that might be considered a derailing of this thread . Anyone wanting a link to that article can send me an email .
After that article is read the fog will be lifted and decisions will be correctly grounded in reality .
BTW Jerry , feel free to go to my article and link to yours . As long as the topics are relevant I consider it to be performing an informational service for the readers . If you don't that is your perogative .
Petey,
If you think you have a handle on the realpolitik of this issue, post your "facts" right here, you will not be derailing anything, it will just be a demonstration of how one author thinks his opinion is the correct opinion and the other guy is wrong.
Your article " The Realpolitik of the Syria Issue ", is nothing more than a few impractical ideas, laced with your opinion and posted in a short dissertation withutter disregard for the correct use of punctuation marks.
What makes you think your opinion is the correct opinion and the readers will somehow have the "fog" lifted that surrounds this problem once they read your little dissertation?
I make no claim to know the "realpolitik" regarding Syria, nor do I believe I have any solutions to this nightmare. This article was posted to pose a few questions and seek any suggestions the readers may have about what they think we may be able to do.
( Btw, steering readers to your own work is unethical, if your work has merit the readers will find it on their own. )
OK , I guess I deserved that criticism by posting my link in your article . However I think my article speaks for itself . As a resultI have no intention of defending it here . I posted a link to your article there . Feel free to actually look it over . Your comment doesn't seem to bear any relationship to what is in my article . Let readers judge for themselves .
I guarantee I won't be doing that in one of your articles again .
You shouldn't be doing it in any article.
Doesn't say much.
There is no defense for thatarticle.
I saw that, thanks. I returned the favor.
I did look it over (took 8 seconds). My comment is totally related to your article dissertation! It is a 100% accurate , unbiased description of everything you said.
What readers.
Opps! Lost one of your periods somewhere.
Oh .... here it is! ' . ' com'on little period, did that mean old Petey leave you un attached to a sentence?
As I said elsewhere among my friends we consider it perfectly acceptable to cross link to our own articles . I will continue to do that with them [with their permission ] . In your case you are clearly not a friend so I won't do that with you . BTW you said :
That was not a nutshell . That was a long drawn out disorganized rant . If you want a nutshell that would be my article . Apparently you think I am stupid enough to be drawn into defending my article by making inaccurate statements about it here . Guess what . I'm not interested .