New York Times: Strike on Syria Would Lead to Retaliation on Israel, Iran Warns
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/29/world/middleeast/syria-iran-israel.html?_r=0
Iranian lawmakers and commanders issued stark warnings to the United States and its allies on Tuesday, saying any military strike on Syria would lead to a retaliatory attack on Israel fanned by the flames of outrage.
The warnings came against a backdrop of rising momentum among Western governments for a military intervention in the Syrian conflict over what the United States, Britain, France and others have called undeniable evidence that President Bashar al-Assads forces used banned chemical weapons on civilians last week, killing hundreds. Mr. Assad has accused the insurgents who are trying to topple him of using such munitions.
Iran, which itself came under chemical weapons assault by Iraq during its eight-year war in the 1980s, has been a loyal ally of the Syrian government. Iranian hard-liners often say Syria is Irans first trench in a potential war with hostile Western powers. Iran has blamed Israel for the conflict in Syria, saying Israel is trying to bring down Mr. Assad.
In case of a U.S. military strike against Syria, the flames of outrage of the regions revolutionaries will point toward the Zionist regime, the semiofficial Fars news agency quoted Mansur Haqiqatpur, an influential member of Parliament, as saying on Tuesday.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel said Tuesday after security meetings in Tel Aviv that, The State of Israel is ready for any scenario. We are not part of the civil war in Syria but if we identify any attempt whatsoever to harm us, we will respond and we will respond in strength.
Iran has always taken the moral high ground on the issue of chemical weapons, actively opposing their use. If it turns out that Mr. Assads side deployed the weapons, it will be difficult for Iranian leaders to explain their support for Mr. Assad to their people, analysts point out.
A potential military intervention by the United States in Syria also represents a test for Irans new president, Hassan Rouhani, who condemned the use of chemical weapons on his Twitter account on Monday, but stopped short of blaming either side in the Syrian conflict.
On Tuesday the new foreign minister of Iran, Mohammad Javad Zarif, stressed that Iran condemned the use of chemical weapons by any group. He also said Iran had pressed the Syrian government to assist the United Nations weapons inspectors who are in the country conducting an inquiry.
There is no evidence, he said, that chemical weapons were used by the Syrian government. But in remarks quoted by the official Islamic Republic News Agency, Mr. Zarif said there was some evidence that such munitions had been given to Syrias insurgents.
Many analysts close to Mr. Rouhani privately say that Syria is an obstacle to change inside Iran. The countrys hard-liners say any attack on Syria is in fact an act of war against Iran, and point to a support pact in which both nations have vowed to defend each other in case of a military attack by a third country.
Naturally Iran does not want to lose Syria as a foothold in the region, said Davoud Hermidas-Bavand, a professor of international relations at Allameh Tabatabaei University in Tehran.
But in the long run a solution for Syria will mean that officials in Tehran can soften their stance towards the U.S., he said. It means we would have a more open domestic atmosphere.
Iran is widely seen as having close coordination with Hezbollah, the militant Shiite Lebanese organization that is an ideological ally. Both regard Israel as a common enemy, and Hezbollah is reported to have many rockets deployed in southern Lebanon capable of striking deep into Israeli territory.
Iran and Hezbollah are heavily engaged in helping Mr. Assads side in the Syrian conflict. Iranian military advisers have been seen in Syria, and Iran provides military support and training to Hezbollah fighters, who have joined the Syrian armed forces in recent months to retake rebel-held areas.
Irans supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, meeting with visiting Sultan Qaboos bin Said al Said of Oman in Tehran on Monday, predicted the Syrian conflict would escalate far beyond its borders if other regional nations continued to aid the Syrian opposition.
Their supporters must know that this fire will finally engulf them as well, Ayatollah Khamenei said, according to the Mehr news agency.
Tags
Who is online
88 visitors

We step into the middle of a religious and civil war and take sides,the entire region will pay the price; hell maybe even the globe. It's sickening seeing all the mayhem and brutality; but it is the consequences of back-assward cultures making shitty decisions. We go in there and cause even more devastation, we will only fan the flames, not slow down the fire. Yeah Israel will be attacked,as will Lebanon, Jordan and many more...they are all targets and WILL be drawn in.
I don't have to say anything Larry. You said it all.
Ironically, if the US. (and France, Britain, and others) attack Syria, Assad may attack countries who have not taken part in the war against him-- because he's prefer to attack them rather then major world powers.
And there's historical precedent. Interestingly, Israel was not a participant in The Gulf War. either. However, that didn't stop Saddam from firing Scud missiles at Israel. Amongst much of the Arab World the sheer bigotry against"infidels" (so-called "non-believers" such as Christians and Jews") is so great that "non-believers" are often made scapegoats and attacked during a conflict-- even if they hadn't been participating!)
Looks like you are hoping for some major massacres and other atrocities. (And apparently you also consider President Obama to be the "Anti-Christ"? LOL
. Well, what if the western powers decide not to attack Syria after all (or just do a few minor missile strikes on Assad's military bases instead)-- your blood lust might very well be quite disappointed!
Yup. And if ya think about it, anyone who is crazy enough to use chemical weapons most likely won't have any qualms about attacking another country just to take the heat off themselves a little bit. And if they can get some support in the muslim world for standing against the evil unbelievers, so much the better.
Very astute analysis, oh crazy one-- very astute indeed! Thank you for your most valuable contribution to the discussion!
Heck-- if he even fires one round from a starter's pistol it will be armageddon. In fact-- it will definitely be even worse than armageddon!!!
(/sarcasm)
And a very Merrie BOOM to you and yours!
Boom...BOOM BOOM!
True.
Much of the "glue" that holds most Arab societies together is hatred.
Hatred of "the other".
Sheer hatred of the so-called "non-believers".
Its even true between various Muslim sects-- the war in Syria is basically Sunni Muslims vs Shia Muslims. Even though both of these religious sects are Muslim...each considers the other to be heretics...not true Muslims.. and therefore each considers the other to be "non-believers"!
(This actually explains much of the ongoing violence we see in so much of the Arab World today).
Then are you saying that if N. Korea did use chemical weapons, the US should attack them as well?
Nah, that wouldn't start a nuclear war /s/.
So the solution is to fire missiles that will kill innocent people no matter how accurate they are? The other problem is that hitting a few airfield and command posts will be interpreted as a weak response anyhow.
Armageddon my arse. Way too many good people left on the earth for that red herring.
Not to mention the US has invaded how manyMuslim countries? Kuwait, Iraq, Afghanistan, Iraq (again), where was this outrage then? Same place it will be when Assad's crib is rubble. They'll burn the flag, Obama effigies or throw some rocks. When they get the cajones to really oppose the dictators who oppress them, then I'll take notice.
Yeah you were being clear but perhaps I was not. What I meant to convey was the idea that if the US sees engaging those who use chemical weapons as a means to convince others that we mean what we say, then what would we do in the case of N.Korea if they did the same? What sorta response would be viable and prudent if N. Korea uses chemical weapons against their own?
More so, while responding to the use of condemned weapons is a noble enterprise, why has there been no sorta military response to N. Korea's ongoing acts of horror?They have killed many, many more of their ownby a variety of atrocious means for years, than have died in Syria during this civil war.
I think he has Russia confused with the US. lol
If the U.S. strikes Syria, what makes anyone believe that they won't strike back, or that their ''friend'', Iran won't join the fight.
A few ''surgical strikes'' could lead to a region wide bloodbath. IMO, Israel will bear the brunt of our strikes.
Possibly so; but Israel isn't likely to fuck around if struck particularly if the U.S. tells it to "Do what you have to."
That's not how it's gone down in the past; Israel should not defend itself with one hand tied behind its back.
Ok and thanks. We don't see eye-to eye on this,thoughI dorespect your position.
Agreed.
We do have to weigh the consequences of our choices. Would the action significantly affect the outcome? In the larger scheme, does it actually bring any more stability, life, or peace to the situation? Imho, in this case, it would not. Because I don't believe that the Syrians want the freedom that you mention. They throw off one mantle of oppression for another. We cannot measurably affect that outcome without going to all out war, and we can do very little about the huge amount of chemical weapons without going to war with them. And even more civilians will die, and it will be the good ol' US of A doing the killing instead. A couple of missiles will barely make a knick.
Maybe someday the people ofSyria will become aware that the lives that they have are not the norm of developed countries and will throw off their oppressor.
Living under guard of a back-assward religious culture that dictates nearly every facet of one's lives, is crawling in the cradle of oppression. The two warring factions in this religious civil war, both contain those that fit the bill of islamic extremists. No matter who comes out ahead in this fight, what is left will be only another repressive regime. One that hates us regardless of what we do.
Besides the fact that Syria is not seeking freedom, I believe that while this statement of your's is honorable, I do not believe it is pragmatic or possible.
If they are stuck Mac, I don't think that they will wait for the U.S. to say anything one way or the other. They will unleash a attack with all their forces.
Perhaps our leaders should refrain from making these kinds of statements entirely. Sorry but IMO if Obama didn't back himself into a corner with this stupidly broad remark, we wouldn't strike Syria.
i believe barry has screwed up the entire ME so much he may have to ask cheyney for help!
No one is saying that we should kill innocent people.
My guess is that the plan is not to use drones to make numerous attacks on houses in villages where Taliban are alleged to be hiding. Rather, a relatively small number of accurate cruise missile hits in the center of a large military base or three.
From your remark, I take it that your preference would to be a major effort-- massive bombardment of many, many targets, followed by perhaps several years of boots on the ground? Daily drone strike on villages-- ongoing for years?
How 'bout 'cause they're murdering children? I realize they're the already born kind, but I kind of think the "pro-lifers" in Congress and among the Republican base might also consider them as "lives."
'Course, since the Tea Party and religionist-right weren't moved to do anything to prevent additional Newtown or Columbine-type murders of (already born) children, I'm not surprised that they don't see the moral issue in the murders of Syrian children.
I admire consistency.
It's fuckin' hypocrisy that pisses me off.
We need to stay out of it.
You mean like that Iraq thing?
Where were all the Constitution strict-constructionists back in the day -- or even after
Creating a Secret Propaganda Campaign to Manufacture a False Case f... .
Falsely, Systematically, and with Criminal Intent Conflating the At... .
Misleading the American People and Members of Congress to Believe I... .
Misleading the American People and Members of Congress to Believe I... .
Illegally Misspending Funds to Secretly Begin a War of Aggression .
Invading Iraq in Violation of the Requirements of HJRes114 .
Invading Iraq Absent a Declaration of War .
Invading Iraq, A Sovereign Nation, in Violation of the UN Charter .
HUH! Where the fuck were all those Constitution scholars then?
Gee reading that list makes this whole Syria thing feel like a re-run eh?
That's a cop out; I made it abundantly clear that the selective indignation is partisan and hypocritical; if you criticize one, ethically and as a matter of integrity, you criticize both.
You can be as sick as you choose but "all that's past is prologue." Iraq had ZERO TO DO WITH 911!
Hey Mac, I was on the Mall protesting back in the summer of 2007 for all the reasons you've listed. Just because Bush was a lying, war-mongering asshole doesn't mean Obama gets a pass for acting the same way simply because he has a "D" after his name.
Chucky,
I'm not giving Obama a pass; I'm awaiting his decision, and until he makes one, to speculate that he'll make a wrong one is premature.
I've implied my preferred actions in a number of comments; still, I understand the pros and cons of both acting and failing to act. Should Obama back off on his "red line" statement, he'll be called a flip-flopper by the right-wing so he'll catch hell from them no matter what.
4,000 dead and wounded Americans, their families, and countless Iraqis wish Bush had flip-flopped instead of lying us into war and adding additional lies to "justify" the WMD bullshit that started it.
It seems that many Americans feel that just because Bush lied about WMDs...that must means that anytime any president says that someone has WMDs-- it must always be false!
Faulty logic to say the least . . .
Just going with the odds, afterall, a politician is a politician and anybody who puts their faith in one is begging for disappointment. Also, do you not believe that Al Qaeda could get their hands on a chemical weapon? Just sayin'.
I think you're right. If they feel threatened, they will act as they see fit.
Although in this case, despite what the U.S. may or not say publicly, I'm pretty sure the U.S. would be quite happy if Israel acted.
Israel faces two serious threats:
1. The most serious threat to Israel is the Lebanese terror group Hezb'Allah, an ally of Assad-- most of their fighters have left Lebanon & are now fighting in Syria.(Iranian troops are also fighting in Syria).
H. has literally thousands of rockets in Lebanon aimed at Israeli cities. If they started firing them, the Israeli onslaught on Hezb'Allah controlled areas in Lebanon would be ferocious.
2 The other possible threat would be Assad using poison gas on Israel. Even one minor such attack would result in most of Damascus leveled in short order. But even if Assad doesn't care about what happens to his people, Assad & his top leaders would be hunted down & killed by the Israelis...
I agree with your points Purple. I just watched a interview that stated that Assad has one of the largest stockpiles of WMD in the world. The Military estimates that it would take 75,000 to 100,000 US troops to secure all of them.
A surgical strike is IMO, only going to open up a bloodbath far exceeding what we're seeing in Syria today.
That's a strong possibility.
But what if it was really small. No military value-- but just to show them hat we have the means, and more importantly the will to act.
Pick just one target-- one that is symbolic but not necessarily of any real military value. And even avoid not only Syrian civilian but also military casualties.
Say, for example, only hit his presidential Palace. Just a few Tomahawk Cruise missiles hit it...or even his biggest military base.
Probably no casualties, no significant damage to his military. So small that (hopefully) neither he nor any of his allies will launch an attack on our allies in the area (mainly Israel, Turkey, Jordan). But OTOH, it serves its purpose.
Purple, I think a mistake that many are making is that a strike is going to deter him. That is only a guess at best IMO.
There have been strikes in other situations and those struck retaliated.
Iran and the Iraqmilitants have already stated that if we strike Syria, they will attack U.S. interests in the M/E.
Assumption are dangers things, and many of our assumption in the past have resulted in retaliatory strikes against us.
Too scary to consider; an opening-up of the conflict that could sooooo easily set the entire region in flame. That is why even now, with this civil war taking place so close to Israel, vigilance is so important. While the world may be riveted to Syria now, if Isarel became directly involved in a war with them, the resulting response froma few other unfriendlycountries would set it all off.
I believe that is the last straw that many other countries have used over the years; "We are having problems and need to use Israel as a scapegoat". I could see the Syrian regime becoming so desperate as to pull in other's to take the heat off itself.
He has been a very dangerous man for quite some time now, just ask Gahdaffi...oh, wait....never mind.