CATO Institute report says poor Americans have it too good
Conservative think tanks have spawned a cottage industry churning out dubious studies purporting to show that poor families are living high on the hog on public benefits, a claim that anybody who has actually experienced poverty in America would find laughable.
These papers are then amplified by the right-wing media, forming the basis for calls to further eviscerate a social safety net thats already been tattered and torn by 30 years of ascendant neoliberalism.
The latest addition to the genre is a study published this week by Michael Tanner and Charles Hughes at the CATO Institute. They calculated the maximum benefits of every federal anti-poverty program in which a single parent with two kids could participate, including things like tax credits for the working poor and supplemental nutrition and health benefits for pregnant women and young children, called it all welfare a word that has long been unpopular to a public that otherwise supports measures to help the neediest and used it to form the claim that welfare provides a perfectly decent quality of life.
Running the numbers in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, Tanner and Hughes claim that the current welfare system provides such a high level of benefits that it acts as a disincentive for work and urge lawmakers to consider ways to shrink the gap between the value of welfare and work by reducing current benefit levels and tightening eligibility requirements.
Tanner and Hughes acknowledge that surveys of welfare recipients consistently show their desire for a job. They acknowledge that a significant share of those receiving public benefits are working Walmart employees, for example, famously rely on public assistance to get by , meaning that taxpayers effectively subsidize the Walton familys vast fortunes. And they note that programs like TANF are time-limited to a maximum of60 months except in most cases.
They also acknowledge the central flaw in their conclusion: in real life the typical family in their study doesnt come close to receiving the maximum benefit from every single program for which theyre eligible. But here the authors caveat doesnt go far enough. Due largely to the fact that eligibility requirements have already become harder to overcome, these programs are helping fewer poor families get by. In 2009, around three out of four poor families with kids werent getting any TANF benefits . At the height of the economic crash, about 25 percent of those eligible for food stamps werent receiving them ; during better times, that number hovers around 40 percent. And as the CATO study concedes, six out of seven poor families arent getting housing assistance.
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/08/22/cato-institute-report-says-poor-americans-have-it-too-good/
