╌>

The Nihilism of the American Right Wing

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  paul  •  13 years ago  •  2 comments

The Nihilism of the American Right Wing

Will the American Right Kill Us All?

by Robert Parry

It is a touchstone of the American Right that the Framers drafted the U.S. Constitution in 1787 to tightly constrain the federal government and to promote states rights and that this supposed originalism is inviolable regardless of the perceived needs of the nation or the dangers implicit in this so-called strict construction.

For various reasons from the mainstream medias timidity to the disdain some progressives feel for the Constitutionscompromises on slavery this right-wing Founding Narrative rarely gets challenged, even though it is a demonstrable fiction. But this lazy tolerance of the Rights made-up history now is becoming an existential threat to mankind.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

The Rights made-up history......some quotes

Lately there has been an embarrassingly nave call from the Tea Party to require Congress to specify in each of its bills the Constitutional authority upon which the bill is grounded. Nothing could be easier: the first and last clauses of Article I, Section 8 gives Congress black-and-white authority to make any law it so desires. Nor was this authority lost on the Founders.

Limited government advocates are fond of cherry-picking quotes from The Federalist Papers to lend their argument credibility, but an adverse collection of essays called the Anti-federalist Papers unsurprisingly never gets a glance. Here is a sample from New Yorker Robert Yates, a would-be founder who walked out of the Philadelphia convention in protest, written a month after the Constitution had been completed:

This government is to possess absolute and uncontrollable power, legislative, executive and judicial, with respect to every object to which it extends. The government then, so far as it extends, is a complete one. It has the authority to make laws which will affect the lives, the liberty, and the property of every man in the United States; nor can the constitution or the laws of any state, in any way prevent or impede the full and complete execution of every power given.

and

As we have seen, the first and last clauses of Article I, Section 8 made the Tenth Amendment a lame-duck measure even as James Madison composed its words in 1791 and so it remains today. The sweeping powers to make all laws necessary and proper in order to provide for the general welfare, had already been bestowed upon Congress. The Johnny-come-lately Tenth Amendment closed the constitutional pasture gate after the horses had been let out.

This apparently has never occurred to the likes of Gov. Rick Perry and his far-Right cohorts who believe a state may reclaim power by withdrawing its consent, in effect repossessing their previously delegated power through state legislation. Superficially, the logic of this position seems sound: if the states had the legal authority to delegate power, then they may use the same authority to un-delegate it by law.

But a close re-reading of the Tenths wording nixes such reasoning. Oddly, the Tenth Amendment does not say the states delegated their powers to the federal government although it may be argued that it probably ought to have said so. It says The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution are reserved to the States.

Thus, according to the Tenth Amendment, the Constitution itself delegated the power to the federal government. States, in other words, now have no standing to reserve-back what they had never delegated-away in the first place.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Barb, right back atcha! Great seed on U.S. health care costs.41.gif

 
 

Who is online





CB


106 visitors