Friggin' media circus - Baby Veronica case: Victory unlikely for either side as mediation begins
Historians in the 19th century described Cherokee stickball as an ancient but brutal tradition, leaving players bloodied and bruised, sometimes even maimed or dead.
More than a game, it was an alternative to war, a way to settle disputes over hunting grounds and property, perhaps even child custody.
Today, Cherokees play a gentler version of the sport. And serious disputes are, of course, settled in court.
But some Cherokees still symbolically take stickball sticks with them to the courthouse.
Baby Veronica's biological father, Dusten Brown, held a pair over his head as he walked out of a tribal hearing Friday - a gesture of Cherokee pride, but not necessarily a sign of victory.
The hearing in Cherokee Nation court Friday afternoon came immediately after a hearing in Cherokee County court Friday morning, stretching more than five hours combined.
With a gag order put over the case and all records sealed, anybody in a position to know what happened can't talk about it.
Everybody else is just guessing.
"With his sticks held high, he looked like a proud man" after the tribal hearing, said Cassy Shufeldt, a friend of Brown and his wife, Robin.
Walking next to Dusten Brown on the way out of the Cherokee courthouse, Robin Brown flashed a smile at news cameras.
"She felt great yesterday," Shufeldt said. "I can tell you she felt great."
But that doesn't necessarily mean that the two court hearings had gone well for the Browns, Shufeldt said.
Their mood was lifted by supporters who waited on the courthouse lawn to cheer as the Browns left, she said.
Many of those same supporters turned out again Saturday for a noon protest in front of a state office building in downtown Tulsa.
Meanwhile in South Carolina, the home of Veronica's adoptive parents, media quoted an unnamed attorney saying that Friday had been "a good day for Dusten Brown."
ONE CHILD, TWO FAMILIES Veronica Capobianco: Her adoptive parents wanted a hearing Friday to end with them taking physical custody of her again, but they left having agreed to enter negotiations with the 3-year-old's biological father, a member of the Cherokee tribe. But that could just be because Veronica remained in Oklahoma, at least for the time being.
Matt and Melanie Capobianco wanted Friday's hearing in Cherokee County court to end with them having physical custody of the 3-year-old girl again, according to a statement that their spokeswoman issued before the hearing.
Instead, the hearing ended with both sides agreeing to enter mediation.
Think of it as the modern court system's version of stickball - an alternative to waging legal battles in front of a judge.
The two sides will likely sit down face-to-face with no attorneys present, said Steven Hager, a former mediator who now serves as the director of litigation for Oklahoma Indian Legal Services.
A trained mediator will lead the negotiations but not impose a settlement, Hager said.
"Mediation is more an art than a science," he said. "A good mediator knows when to be empathetic and when to be firm."
It can take a few hours or a few days, but mediation usually comes to agreement that "both sides can live with."
"You have to give up on the idea of winning," especially in the Baby Veronica case, Hager said.
"This is not going to end well. The hope is to find a compromise that ends it as gracefully and as least destructively as possible for the child."
http://www.tulsaworld.com/article.aspx/Baby_Veronica_case_Victory_unlikely_for_either_side/20130818_11_A1_CUTLIN728431

This whole case is turning into a media circus thanks to the Capobianco's. They have, time and time and time again, called "news conferences" to gain public support for stealing a Cherokee child through not following the law.
Mediation is not the answer to this story. ICWA is the answer. Follow the friggin' law people and STFU.
For a better understanding of what this case is all about, follow the links on the left hand side of the link for Tulsa World. Believe me, you'll learn stuff you had no idea was happening.
Will we ever find out what Dusten and the Cherokee Nation was threatened with to force the father to "mediate" over the custody of his own daughter when ICWA should have been followed in the first place, and the Capobiancos and the birth mother lied about everything from the beginning?
I still suggest that if he had been anything except an Indian there would be nothing to mediate! As the child's biological Father and since the birth Mother has relinquished her rights the child is Dusten's. Oh wait he's an Indian. Throw out the laws!
Agreed, Honemana.
Mediation by ass, since this is supposed to be a nation of laws, all they have to do is follow ICWA.
Well and truly said. Like I said, he's an Indian so throw out the law!
Indians are so easy to screw over with help of courts, even SCOTUS, if I were the Capobiancos, I'd agree to anything proposed... even joint custody.
Then when I got my hands on Veronica, back in South Carolina, I'd just file a move in the SC court to bar Dusten from coming anywhere near her. They would be granted the motion, of course, else it would take years for it to get through all the legal maneuvers and they would have her in the meantime.
No way in hell would I agree to mediation if it were a binding one, if I were Dusten. I would never allow them to take her out of Oklahoma. He will never see her again if she leaves the Cherokee.
)..(
If the Cherokee court and the Nation have their say, she ain't gonna leave.
Steven Hager, a former mediator who now serves as the director of litigation for Oklahoma Indian Legal Services."You have to give up on the idea of winning," especially in the Baby Veronica case, Hager said. A trained mediator will lead the negotiations but not impose a settlement, Hager said.
"Mediation is more an art than a science," he said. "A good mediator knows when to be empathetic and when to be firm."
It can take a few hours or a few days, but mediation usually comes to agreement that "both sides can live with."
I would suggest that the Capobiancos are definitely there to win--at any cost. This is a court approved mediation but I still feel that the deck is stacked against Dusten and hehad better not let his guard down. Flowery words are about the same as patting somebody on the back as you feel for the softest place to stab him in the back. When this is over is there an avenue of appeal?
Kind of likepissing on my foot and telling me it's raining, tsula.
Yep! I would much rather be rained on than the alternative here!
tsula - this is an area where I love to say "it depends". The Cherokee Court and the Cherokee Nation, technically, have control over this case - regardless of what Capobianco thinks. "ICWA gives tribal governments a strong voice concerning child custody proceedings that involve Indian children, by allocating tribes exclusive jurisdiction over the case when the child resides on, or is domiciled on, the reservation, or when the child is a ward of the tribe; and concurrent, but presumptive, jurisdiction over non-reservation Native Americans foster care placement proceedings."
So, yes, there is an avenue of appeal.
That looks good to me 1 and I especially like your bolded statement. This may just be a level playing ground after all. Thanks. Will you be posting updates?
I'm asking what your smiley meant.
If that child ever gets to South Carolina she will never leave or see her father again until she is an adult.
You should ask such a question????
Betcha the churches don't see themselves as cults.
Robert, please clarify which one is the cult in your opinion.
Yep, that's my question as well... who, Robert, do you refer to as the cult?
And Robert did what Robert does best - make a bold statement that means nothing to anyone but him- and run.
Tail-Between-Legs.
She. is. not. their. daughter.
There. I typed it slowly so that you could understand. They lied to get the adoption through the SC courts. The birth mother lied. The attorney for the Capobiancos lied. The GAL lied. The Attachment and Bonding Expert was coerced and lied to white wash the letter to the courts in favor of the Capobiancos, so it was a lie also.
There is no hostage, except Dusten Brown.
Rather nebulous and cryptic Robert - "trying to save their daughter". Who's trying to save their daughter?
I get the sad impression that he is still trying to start something with this. The dumb statement of "trying to save their daughter" would be the catalyst since she is the daughter of Dusten Brown and is NOT their daughter. The fuse is lit!!
So what you are saying here, in all your majesty, is that the sovereign Cherokee Nation, their culture, their courts, their laws are those of a cult? Interesting self serving description of The First People.
You are now calling the Indian Nations cults?
You are deliberately trying to instigate a fight here, Robert.
Robert, you haven't kept up with the case, nor do you understand the law.Do some research before commenting.
Yes, ''silly you''.
Yes he is by carefully choosing his words and intent. Wait for it for there are more to come since banishment for willful maliciousintent does not seem to be a viable option here.
Robert's attempt to chastise Native Americans for their lack of honor and failure to follow the law fails to recognize that the Capobiancos and everyone involved with them, from their lawyer on down, by virtue of the fact that they willfully lied in order to receive the rendering of the courts in their favor....
have in fact negated, by law, that rendering.... if the letter of the law is followed.
The lack of honor falls solidly on the side of the cult of these pseudo Christians.
Indeed but that will not stop him from doing it, at will. It has been, with my limited experience, that those who preach propaganda ultimately, if not stopped, find people who will believe them. Not good and needs to be challenged at every turn.
What you said, Honemana
I agree!
And I get so aggravated because I see the wording and intent of the law as being really quite simple and straight forward. Yet, the Capobianco's "group" has taken this simple and straight-forward law and are attempting to twist it enough so that it will be dismantled - for not being equal in service.
RW, if WE all know this is what he does as I said, with malicious intent, then just who is protecting him and why? What can possibly be gained by allowing him, and his games, to continue unhindered? And you all fell for it. Again. How many agains are enough? The rights of the one do not trump the rights of the many!! If this is so, then a general exodus is also in the cards for we are not allowed to protect ourselves from the poison.
"then just who is protecting him and why?
Rhetorical question, RW! I already knew the answer to the WHO! I wanted to truly know WHY as no constructive dialogue could possibly ensue while that was in place!
You are dead on when you say ignore him as I shall attempt to do in the future with no strict promises, though, you understand! The road to Hell is paved with good intentions.
Robert is a troll - period - and we have to, unfortunately, tolerate his "trollness". But, as you have all said - ignoring him works very well.
Huh, that in truth is exactly what everyone seems to be saying and yet it persists, doesn't it? If it isn't this one there is always another one to come out of hiding! I'm slowly, because I amreally slow, coming to the conclusion that it might just be time to pull up stakes and find another home for this is not what I came here for!
Thanks, RW. The old man is easily confused and what we have been discussing is confusing with a capitol K to be sure. I'm going to have to think this one through and not do anything too hasty but all in all I figure I am walking on eggs. Be well!
Let's get it back on topic, OK folks? We can give the trolls their due in a separate thread.
You have another home where that kind of thing doesn't happen and you don't have to pull any stakes to get to it.
Well, that pretty well sums up what the SC folks think Robert - thanks for the update.
The tribe and the tribal courts, under the law, have dominance in the case. Again, that's under the law. Now, if we are going to become an unlawful nation, and in many cases it looks as though that is happening, the law will be totally ignored until the case returns to SCOTUS, which many of think will occur.
Thanks for the update.
Our behavior is ''cultish'', unlike your which is boorish.
Now that your finished with your rant Robert, ''get over it''...Hope that sounds familiar to you.
Oh, just a point that you should consider before your next rant. The Tribal court has dominance in this case. You, being a big law and order guy should have known that.
Have a wonderful day.
When something goes in our favor, we're getting a "free ride."
When we fight for what is ours (this is laughable in a way for we are talking about one of our CHILDREN!) through legal means, because the law has clearly been broken, we are a cult.
Perhaps we should just be good little Indians and politely bend over.
@ Robert:
She is registered as a member of the Cherokee Nation. That makes her a Native American and one of "ours," whether you and the Capobiancos like it or not.
If they walk away with her in the end, it is highly doubtful they will fail to avail themselves of the resources set aside for her by the Cherokee Tribe which will significantly lessen the financial burden of her upbringing on them.
Yeah, I know - and I luv all of 'em.
What would make me happy is if the main steam media carried the story of the ''expert'' for the SC couple recanting her support. Or if the main stream media, carried the story about her attorney and their ''Locator''...But wait, can't do that, since it would cast doubt on their claim.
That's the way I see it also. We're pushing our daughter to maintain her high grades, do community "stuff" and be active in school so she will be able to apply for and, hopefully, receive scholarships based on those activities.
Robert - here's the technical answer for you - and it really is a simple answer:
"An Indian tribe shall have jurisdiction exclusive as to any State over any child custody proceeding involving an Indian child who resides or is domiciled within the reservation of such tribe, except where such jurisdiction is otherwise vested in the State by existing Federal law (meaning a PL-280 state, which SC is not)."
"Where any petitioner in an Indian child custody proceeding before a State court has improperly removed the child from custody of the parent or Indian custodian or has improperly retained custody after a visit or other temporary relinquishment of custody, the court shall decline jurisdiction over such petition and shall forthwith return the child to his parent or Indian custodian unless returning the child to his parent or custodian would subject the child to a substantial and immediate danger or threat of such danger."
The SC courts and the SCOTUS denied tribal jurisdiction, AND SCOTUS denied returning the child under the criteria established.
SCOTUS did not fulfill their constitutional responsibilities either time, nor did the SCOSC the second time.
Way too many violations of law - by the courts and by the petitioners.
Robert - No, the tribe's interest is not contrived.
The U.S. Congress stated in Section 1901(3) of ICWA "that there is no resource that is more vital to the continued existence and integrity of Indian tribes than their children and that the United States has a direct interest, as trustee, in protecting Indian children who are members of or are eligible for membership in an Indian tribe..." (25 U.S.C. 1901 [3]).
Indian children have a unique political status as members of sovereign tribal governments. Congress, through the Constitution, statutes, treaties, and the general course of dealing with Indian tribes, is charged with the responsibility for the protection and preservation of Indian tribes and their resources, including Indian children.
The special political status of Indian tribes, as well as the history of biased treatment of Indian children and families under public and non-Indian private child welfare systems, is the basis for the enactment of ICWA (25 U.S.C. 1901).
The purpose of ICWA is to do the following: Protect Indian children, Preserve and strengthen Indian families, Ensure permanency for Indian children, Protect the continuing existence of Indian cultures, and Ensure that tribes can exercise their sovereign authority over child custody proceedings. It is through relationship with family, elders, tribal community, and culture that the Indian child's sense of permanence and identity is protected (25 U.S.C. 1901 et seq.).
Tribal courts have primacy in ICWA cases. If the tribe is located in a PL-280 state, then the tribe and state have concurrent jurisdiction - but the tribe has full involvement at all times, even if shared.
Seriously, thanks for your input - that was a good comment.
The Capobianco's would receive nothing from the Cherokee - only Veronica would as a tribal member. Not sure how any "benefits" would be handled - that would be up to the tribal council and the court.
Your daughter's at Berkley?? I'm in San Fran - get to hear 'bout all the "bad" things those Berkley kids do
. Nah - don't know 'bout that so much now, but back in the day- that was the place for the Crosby, Stills and Nash live-in's/love-in's and Winona Duke and those other agitators.
Wish her luck.
Got that right.