Neighborhood News and Views – Living Wage or Minimum Wage
As the group sat around the picnic table last evening, the topic of a living wage landed on the table for discussion.
We had many more questions than answers.
What is a living wage?
Is a living wage for the worker? for a worker and a spouse? for a worker and a spouse with one, two , three, .. children?
Is a living wage the same in rural Ohio as it is in Manhattan?
Should the minimum wage ---- be a national standard? differ state by state? differ by region? by city?
What should the minimum wage be today and should it be indexed to inflation?
After voicing and considering these and other questions, the consensus of the group was that this was quite a complex issue and that there was no simple or easy answer to any of the questions. We decided to talk about the individual questions and came to the following consensus.
A living wage is a fallacy since it varies greatly depending on family situation, geographic location and the economic and societal norms of the region. It is ridiculous to consider that wages for a position would vary based on the workers marital status or number of children in his family.
The decisions to marry to have a child or multiple children are personal decisions and a persons wealth, income potential and ability to amass wealth over time should be factored into the making and timing of those decisions.
It is simply impossible to determine that $XX is a living wage for the U.S. middle class and in our view efforts should be directed to other issues affecting the middle class and working poor.
A more concrete discussion can be had about what the minimum wage should be in the U.S.
In our view a minimum wage should be a national standard, though we acknowledge that the cost of living varies greatly in different areas of the country, which would limit the gaming of state and local governments by businesses with the threat of relocation to lower wage states.
We have seen and heard a number of ideas on what the minimum wage should be $10.00, $10.74, $12.00, $15.00 or even as high as $20.00 per hour and the people proposing those numbers are passionate in their defense of their positions and we respect all those opinions.
A couple of basic points seem clear to us 1) the minimum wage has not kept up with inflation since the 1960s, 2) the current minimum wage is too low, 3) the minimum wage must be somehow indexed to inflation so that it rises (and perhaps falls) with the economic conditions of the times and the minimum wage should be a national standard.
A minimum wage of slightly less than $11.00 per hour would bring it in line with the inflation since the 1960s and $15.00 per hour is a number we hear people clamoring for in protest walkouts against fast food restaurants and other businesses. In our view, neither of those is the right number in view of the current economic climate but rather we would suggest that the minimum wage be set at $12.50 per hour nationally (with no variances higher or lower by individual states) and that it be indexed to the same scale on which increase in social security are determined going forward.
The minimum annual wage for a full-time worker would be $26,000 and in our view wages above entry level positions would also scale up over a short period of time.
Well thats what we think and I am sure that others feel much differently but all should agree that changes are needed to in order to revive and revitalize a strong middle class in the U.S.

Bring up minimum wage, the poverty level, the shrinking middle class or economic recovery and the conversation will tend to include talk of a living wage, raising the minimum wage and other related social and economic issues.
What say youallabout the minimum wage versus living wage?