Native Americans to get millions after 'big victory' in Supreme Court
"The Supreme Court has ruled that the government must fully reimburse Native American tribes for millions of dollars they spent on federal programs.
The federal government had agreed to fully reimburse money tribes spent on programs like law enforcement, environmental protection and agricultural assistance, but Congress capped the amount of money earmarked for that reimbursement.The tribes sued, and the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver said the money must be fully reimbursed.
The high court on Monday ruled the Ramah Navajo Chapter and other Native American tribes must get their money back.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote the majority opinion for Justices Antonin Scalia, Anthony Kennedy, Clarence Thomas and Elena Kagan. Chief Justice John Roberts, and Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Samuel Alito dissented.
"We stressed that the government's obligation to pay contract support costs should be treated as an ordinary contract promise," Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in the majority ruling which confirmed a Colorado appeals court decision.
"The government was obligated to pay the tribes' contract support costs in full." "
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/06/19/12294547-native-americans-to-get-millions-after-big-victory-in-supreme-court?lite
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

I wonder if the President will sequester the payments?
Good to see the law working for the people that deserve what the government has been refusing to give them.
Very interesting vote split there. Who'd ever think Clarence Thomas would vote the correst way on an issue.
Sorry - don't know how that gap got up there (darn cut/paste).
"Congress allocated $1.6 billion to the Bureau of Indian Affairs for "the operations of Indian programs" in 2000, according to news agency AFP, but only $120.2 million was paid out."
Wait - you mean the U. S. government WITHHELD $1 Billion dollars in payments to the Indian Tribes. Say it isn't so - "our" government wouldn't do that to anyone such as the Blacks, Hispanics, Asians, women, gay groups, warm-and-fluffy lovers, so why is it OK to do it to Indian tribes???? Oh, it's also OK to spend $320 billion in aid to Egypt, Israel, Syria, Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan - but not to paythe Indian tribes for services performed under contract with the U. S. government?????
Something don't smell right folks.
Chucky - I was stunned to see that - and Kennedy was with him. Betcha they heard about it in the back room, eh?
Gary - you know the gov will find a way to get out of it somehow. I mean, why pay what you're supposed to when you can get away with it involving the Indian tribes, eh?
Maybe we're beginning to see where the billions the BIA "lost" and can't find went.
Is anyone surprised by Robert's and Alito'svote?
Don't worry about the receipt, BF.
The US government is so far behind in what it owes Tribal Nations based on treaty agreements it signed and the billions of dollars it can't "find" that it has "lost" that belong to the Tribes that a few lost receipts won't ever make a difference.
Since the BIA is in control of Indian money to start with it all comes full circle.
No-brainer really; this was good decision.
Actually the correct way isn't always what the liberals think is the correct way Chucky. Would actually be nice to see one of the Liberals in Congress or the Supreme Court being brave enough to vote the correct way instead of what is considered to be the party way.
It always stinks 1stwarrior. Until we get representatives instead of leaders up there in Washington, it's going to continue to stink. And once we forget about party lines and get representatives for the people we will find the people are a lot more fair than the leaders are.
We only have one Native in Congress - Tom Cole - and he is fighting as hard as he can. Dammm - it's really sad that there is so much apathy towards us by the elected officials who don't even bother to get to know us.
We have tons of qualified people to run for Congress - but they don't want to because of the total political quagmire and throat cutting that must be done.
Ben Nighthorse Campbell was one of the very best - but he said the back stabbing, heavy handedness, political suicides don't fit with Indian culture/heritage/traditions.
What is sad is that the highest court in the land had members who were so sorry and low down in their legal and moral ethics they did not feel the Tribes were entitled to be reimbursed, even though any lay person with the ability to read and understand English would know they were entitled to the reimbursement.
We are talking here, people, about the highest LEGAL minds in the United States of America. They did not have to ponder any obscure interpretations or wonder what the Founding Fathers meant by Olde English phrases... all they had to do was honor the straight forward treaty language of legal documents.
And they voted NOT TO DO IT! They should be disbarred on extreme moral and ethical grounds.
The reservation model is too often a failure and needs to be dismantled.
Reservation inhabitants continually lag behind in nearly every societal category and the idea of perpetual reparations and reimbursement needs to end.
Before they can "end" they have to "begin."
The US government is woefully behind in living up to the treaty agreements signed with the Tribal Nations in return for this land called the United States of America. It has not fulfilled one single treaty agreement. Not one.
It's kind of like you buying a house and signing a contract to pay the bank for the money they loaned you, then deciding a few months into the deal you don't want to pay any more but you want to keep the house.
Get over the idea that Indians are getting a free ride; nothing about their existence is "free." Treaties were signed, the conditions of which have never been met; therefore, they cannot possibly come to an "end."
Please do not use the title of Indian. They are first Nation people.
Sure , if you say so :
The court "should" have listened to the tort attorneys as this was a claim for moneys spent under a legal contract. "If" they put the Indian factor in it to try to weigh their decision - man - what the hell are they doing on the bench???
South of the border, we are called Indian, Native American, or American Indian. We much rather being referred to by our tribe, such as Chickasaw. If not by tribe, Indian is preferable.
First Nation is for the folks above the border in Canada.
'Scuse me sixpick, but the Dems are more than noteworthy in the cause of the sequester. 'Member ol' Harry saying, five years ago, "I ain't gonna put up no budget - we don't need one." His little minions, while busy kissing his butt, mouth his words repeatedly. The Dems have voted down four of Obama's budgets and refuse to discuss any of the Repubs.
This is a party of three - they are all to blame.
When are your house payments going to end arch??? When the loan is paid off. When is a treaty going to end arch???? When the payments begin.
Huge difference.
Wait a minute - SCALIA voted for it????? OMG!!!!!!!!!!!
mimi - this contract money has nothing to do with the "lost" earnings from mineral, agricultural or grazing leases - THAT's where the $41B got lost. This money being awarded is not even in the budget for the Indians - it's in the budget for the Small Business Administration's Economic Development budget - -has nothing to do with the tribes. Yet, four of the nine had to make it an Indian issue.
''what the hell are they doing on the bench???''....Good question.
I just read a story the other day, where AZ has 11 American Indians in their state legislature.
What you said, 1stwarrior.... you go, man!
(the Dingo)
1stwarrior, you are saying this was a straight up contract reimbursement? That the fact that Indians were on the other side of the contract with the government should not have even been considered at all... am I understanding that correctly?
That even if ACME had performed the obligations set forth by the contract, SCOTUS should have, on the legal grounds alone, returned a "full house?"
Actually, no (I need to quit mixing my cases up)- " The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDA) directs the Secretary of the Interior to enter into contracts with willing tribes under which they will provide services such as education and law enforcement that the Federal Government otherwise would have provided . It requires the Secretary to contract to pay the "full amount" of "contract support costs," 45 U. S. C. 450j1(a)(2), (g),subject to the availability of appropriations, 450j1(b). In the event of a contractual breach, tribal contractors are entitled to seek money damages under the Contract Disputes Act. In Fiscal Years (FYs) 1994 to 2001, respondent Tribes contracted with the Secretary to provide services. During each of those FYs, Congress appropriated sufficient funds to pay any individual tribal contractors contract support costs in full but did not appropriate enough to pay all tribal contractors collectively. Unable to pay every contractor in full, the Secretary paid the Tribes on a uniform, pro rata basis. Respondents sued under the Contract Disputes Act for breach of contract. The District Court granted the Government summary judgment. The Tenth Circuit reversed, finding the Government liable to each contractor for the full contract amount. " (Damm - how do you control font on this thing????)
Please note - " It requires the Secretary to contract to pay the "full amount" of "contract support costs," 45 U. S. C. 450j1(a)(2), (g),subject to the availability of appropriations,".
Congress authorized $1.6B and only gave $120.M - whose pooch got screwed on this one and by whom????
As usual, Sotamayer did an absolutely beautiful opinion - I'd vote for her.
As well they should. You make a contract (individual or government), you pay it.
TTGA:
The problem is they are so used to screwing Indians over they thought they could get away with it again.
You expect this type of skullduggery in common courtrooms.... but when the top court of the land with the final say of elite law pulls this kind of shit... when the contract is laid out in black and white and read all over for all to peruse and understand.....
the damn low down white trash morally bankrupt pieces of filth should be disbarred and thrown out of their "for life" cushy jobs on grounds of moral turpitude and ineptness.
Ah, but that's the point mimi, the highest court in the country did not do that. The majority said just what I said, when you make a contract, you pay it. If you expect a unanimous decision, you're dreaming. Very seldom does the court give a unanimous opinion on anything; that's why majority decisions are the rule. You certainly should be unhappy with some people in the Executive and Legislative Branches for making the court case necessary in the first place, but they don't have lifetime tenure. You have a chance to remove them every two or four years.
I'm a dreamer, TTGA. In my dreams of this country, the highest court in the land has the greatest legal minds in the land; and when looking at a contract entered into by the government of this land, laid out in black and white, clear and concisely, with no error for interpretation, those great legal minds should have come to a unanimous opinion....
a contract is a contract is a contract, and you fulfill a contractual obligation.
Screw the rest of it.
That is why the teaching and hand-holding must go on. They have to learn and we must be gentle in our teaching. 'Course, with a couple of'm, it's gonna be kinda hard.
Afraid I'm a cynic rather than a dreamer love. The greatest legal minds in the country are making ten times as much money running high powered law firms. These are the ones who wanted to turn in their knee pads and stop chasing ambulances by taking the King's Shilling.
N/A,
We don't want these ones elected either. Think what might happen if the mob gets to choose how the Constitution is interpreted. It's bad enough the way it is.
But, they are appointed per the Constitution.
A legally executed contract and it has to be go SCOTUS to force the gov't to pay..Amazing
That it is. Not surprising, though, it happens quite a bit. That's what happens when you let the lawyers run things.
@TTGA:
Chaucer said it long before Shakespeare....
"Kill all the solicitors!"
Tribes and the courts are not the best of friends since 1986 and William Rhenquist and his court.
John Marshall established the Canons of Construction for when the government is dealing with the tribes - The [Courts opinions sometimes] refer to the manner in which treaties and agreements with Indian tribes are to be interpreted. Largely in recognition of the unequal bargaining power of the parties, the Supreme Court has developed a set of canons of treaty construction. In essence, these canons provide that:
"(1) treaties are to be construed as the Indians understood them;
(2) treaties are to be liberally construed in favor of the Indians; and
(3) all ambiguities are to be resolved in favor of the Indians."
The canons are now well-established, and apply to statutes enacted by Congress as well as negotiated treaties and agreements. As applied to statutes, the canons essentially ensure that Congress, although it has the power to abrogate or limit tribal rights, does so clearly and unambiguously.
Mimi,
I wonder if they finally found out the definition of the word "is". If they have, would someone please notify William Jefferson Clinton. I think he's still trying to look it up.
Still bet it's too big a word for Bill's self-absorbed mind.
If you really feel up to it, got the any of the laws/acts/treaties written "for" the Indians and attempt to read it. Can you really, truly find any clarity or understanding in the documents???
And there is a clause that can remove them from office - for failure to perform their duties.
That can be a two edged sword Gunny.
Again, 'ccording to the Constitution, only Congress can impeach them - so much for justice.
'Nuther curious thought - why does Congress feel it's appropriate to cut/curtail monies to the tribes when the tribes have contracts/treaties that state differently?
Consider for a moment - if the Feds aren't paying the Indians for contract work done, what about the non-Indians conducting contract work?? Hmmmmm
No, I'm actually saying that "our government", the government of the people, would also not pay non-Indians for contract work.
How wrong is that???