╌>

Israel Faces Deepening Isolation, Kerry Warns - really? Check your facts.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  13 years ago  •  13 comments

Israel Faces Deepening Isolation, Kerry Warns - really? Check your facts.

Mr. Goldberg's article is in light print. My comments are in bold print.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry's peace mission to the Middle East is semi-quixotic, if not wholly quixotic. I doubt he'll reach his goal of negotiating a final-status agreement between the Palestinians and the Israelis. The two sides haven't even agreed yet to the topics they'll discuss in negotiations.

But we should give Kerry this: He has managed to at least partially capture the attention of the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. I say partially because the Netanyahu government's self-destructive West Bank settlement program continues apace (though the latest round of construction is scheduled to take place on territory that would almost certainly be granted to Israel in final-status talks).

Mr. Goldberg first states that the settlement program is "self-destructive". Then he admits that those projects will in all probability be part of Israel in final status talks. This underscores the fallacy of what anyone who has ever claimed the settlements are an obstacle to peace. The fact is, they are an obstacle to the ultimate destruction of Israel, since they will have to destroy more than originally intended.

There are some early signs that Netanyahu is realizing the price his country may one day pay for its settlements, in particular those near Palestinian population centers. He met recently with some of Israel's leading manufacturers, who expressed their worry that their products may one day be boycotted in Europe, a worry he shares. Kerry, capitalizing on this anxiety, has warned Netanyahu in recent weeks that if the current peace talks bear no fruit, Israel may soon be facing an international delegitimization campaign -- in his words -- "on steroids."

A word about the BDS (boycott, divest, sanction) movement. It has not worked. It will not work. Roger Waters and Annie Lennox do not purchase enough goods to make a difference. The movement is a failure, because people who want to do business with Israel significantly outnumber those who don't, because they understand the reality on the ground. In case you don't know what the reality is, the reality is that the Arab/Islamic world would like to remove Israel from the map because of their deep-seated hatred. The Palestinians are the pariah of the Arab/Islamic world, and the Arab world has a single use for them. This is their use.

According to officials I have spoken to, who requested anonymity so they could speak freely, Kerry thinks the one thing Netanyahu fears as much as Iran's nuclear program is the growing power of the international movement that seeks to isolate, scapegoat and demonize his country. (One caveat: Kerry, like most Americans who know Netanyahu, understands that the prime minister's narrowest but most potent fear is of being unseated.)

Although Netanyahu is worried that the campaign to make Israel appear to be an illegitimate state could hurt the country's robust economy, he is said to be even more worried that this campaign will erode Israel's ability to defend itself. The theory is simple: A country seen as illegitimate, not only by the powerful Arab lobby at the United Nations but also by Western powers, will have little standing if it is forced to retaliate against sustained attacks from groups such as Hamas and Hezbollah, both of which remain committed to Israel's extermination. Netanyahu thinks that the campaign to delegitimize Israel could force Western powers to rein in Israel, or at the very least, rush to condemn it before it has the chance to defend itself.

This is pure fantasy, and Mr. Goldberg gives you an obvious clue, smack in the middle of the paragraph, which represents the sweeping failure of the theory. Hamas and Hezbollah are committed to Israel's extermination. This ALONE justifies every action Israel takes to defend itself, including the permanent annexation of territory to bolster their defenses.

Netanyahu's two fears are related. Israel will find it increasingly difficult to one day act against the Iranian nuclear program if it is hobbled by the hostility of the international community. For years, I've been arguing that Israel would find more sympathy in its campaign against Iranian nukes if it was more willing to compromise with the Palestinians. Netanyahu, unlike other prominent figures on the Israeli right, has agreed in principle to a two-state solution, but he hasn't done very much to bring it about -- he has only grudgingly and temporarily suspended expansions of the settlements located on land that would almost surely be part of the future state of Palestine.

Mr. Goldberg repeats another failed mantra, but gives uses different words. "If Israel would only give the Palestinians what they want, there would be peace in the Middle East". Anyone familiar with the so-called Arab Spring? Was that not enough to show you that the region is in a permanent state of conflict, with or without Israel?

But Netanyahu has lately been leaning in the direction of the Israeli political center. And by doing this he is making the truculent base of his party, the Likud, quite nervous. Netanyahu, I'm told, has taken to disparaging some of the politicians to his right as "insane." These are the politicians who delude themselves into thinking that their country is a superpower, and can behave as one.

Goldberg, a strident Liberal, is among those who believe that Israel should take all its cues from the US, and trust that everything would work out. Israel is not the 51st state, but is fortunate to have the unyielding support of the American population and government. Poll after poll has indicated this. That does not mean that Israel should commit suicide if the US directs them to do so.

So, when the European Union recently issued guidelines that will restrict its members from (among other things) funding research conducted on the far side of Israel's 1967 borders, these politicians decided, in their wisdom, that Israel should engage in a partial boycott of the EU. They're demanding that Israel withdraw from a lucrative EU-sponsored research-funding program to protest the settlement exclusion guidelines. Netanyahu also finds the new EU guidelines reprehensible (and they are, in fact, highly problematic, potentially placing settlers in the far-flung Jewish colonies of the West Bank in the same category as Jewish residents of the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City). But he understands that he can't win a fight with the entire EU if it decides to enact a partial boycott of his country. On the one hand, EU hostility toward Israel isn't particularly helpful to Kerry or his chief negotiator, Martin Indyk. Threats directed at Israel from Europe, the continent whose cruelty and hatred helped create a need for a Jewish national refuge in the first place, may, in the short term, bolster Israel's far-right, which could handcuff Netanyahu in negotiations.

What Mr. Goldberg fails to realize (or admit) is that any partial or full boycott of these products will adversely affect the Palestinian population. At last count, 22,000 Palestinians are employed by these companies. The number is probably higher today. And, as stated earlier, this is more symbolic of pressure from the Arab League than anything else. These companies will have little difficulty thriving. Take note that the largest employer of Palestinians in the territory in question is a company called Sodastream. They have more than $1 billion in sales, and just received shelf space in Wal Mart. Good luck, EU.

On the other hand, the majority of Israelis are sensible, and they know, as Netanyahu knows, that Israel can't exist in an entirely friendless world. Partly because of the actions of the EU, Netanyahu is listening to Kerry's warnings with newly open ears.

Israel will always have friends, and they will always have enemies. IMHO, those countries who are friends would be better off.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-08-12/israel-faces-deepening-isolation-kerry-warns.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

These articles appear all too often. It's tiring when people posing as authorities write articles that contain mostly opinion.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

If one counts up the "democracy initiatives" of the Arab spring countries , how many have turned into actual democracies and how many into dictatorships ? There seems to be only one real democracy in the middle east ...Israel . Is Iraq a democracy ? ... who knows ?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

The criticisms lodged against Israel always had the taint of bias. These "initiatives" only serve to remind us of that bias. It reminds us of the type of people that perpetuallyclamor against the Jewish State, claiming crimes that theythemselves are guilty of.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

I'm sure it will never come to pass, but I look forward to the day that an MSM journalist acknowledges the fact that the foundation of Israel's policydecisionsare based upon the premise that they face an existential challenge to their very existence from their neighbors. This fact is often buried in columns written by "journalists" like Goldberg (see paragraph 5), who give it very little credence to Israel's case.

Morons...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

The good news is that Israel has always shown its resolve at the proper time, regardless of the proclamations from the Kangaroo Court of World Opinion. They know what's at stake, and it's not a few votes from some constituency that they need to procure votes for.

It's survival.

Period.

Petey's story underscores the relative silence from the world in reaction to Arab rocket attacks on civilian populations. Succumb to world pressure? Let them stick it up their bigoted asses.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Nonsense.

The question comes down to: Will we allow the sacrifice of Israel for oil and seeming stability?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

This article makes a lot of points. Just a few thoughts:

1. BDS is indeed a failure.

A while back, on another site, someone was enthusiastically claimed she would boycott Israel. A few others said that they would boycott as well.

Apparently they didn't understand how boycotts worked-- in order to boycott a country, you have to first be buying their products, and only then can you stop buying them ! I asked her what Israeli products she had previously been buying-- and that she would now discontinue buying. LOL!

Of course most of the boycotters were never buying any Israeli product in the first place....

Oftimes news of an boycott will motivate Israel supporters to start buying more Israeli products:

Anti-Israel Boycott Backfires in Canada
Another anti-Zionist attempted boycott in Canada has backfired, with Israeli products enjoying sales rates much higher than usual.
Anti-Israel groups had threatened MEC Canadas Mountain Equipment Co-op - with a boycott because of its inclusion of Israeli products in its inventory. But barely anyone showed up for the boycott, and instead, large crowds of Israel supporters came to buy Israeli products. ( Read it all )
Here's another example from the same page (I believe Buzz mentioned this one a while back):

Shades of April 2009
The story appears to be a repeat of what occurred in April of this year at a Toronto liquor store.

After a Jewish non-Zionist group tried to organize an anti-Israel protest in front of the store, asking Passover celebrants to mark their holiday without Israeli-made wines, hundreds of pro-Israeli consumers took the opportunity to hold a pro-Israel festival and bought up the stores entire stock of Israeli wine.

Brands such as Carmel, Barkan, Golan Heights, Gush Etzion (Efrat), Binyamina, Baron, Segal Dalton and others were sold out within a matter of hours.
During the "Mohammed Cartoon Crisis", much of the Muslim world was boycotting Danish products. The Danes were worried about their economy-- they export a lot (particularly dairy products) to the Muslim world. But the net impact was the exact opposite of what boycotters had hoped for. Supporters of free speech and democratic values throughout the world started buying lots of Danish products! (I myself participated-- every night I made it a point to eat some Danish Blue cheese and have a few Tuborgs!. It was one form of political activism I thoroughly enjoyed).
Currently I am looking for more Israeli products to buy. For those who might be interested, apparently Sodastream is a wonderful product. (But I don't drink soda). In addition, the company provides well paying jobs for not only Jews but for Palestinians as well:
Israel gives Palestinian Arabs jobs and a future for themselves and their children. Palestinian leaders and other Israel haters worldwide give Palestinian suicide vests and teach them hatred.
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Fantastic video Krish!

We don't drink much pop, but some, and have looked at SodaStream before. Now we WILL get one, help out the environment, save some money, and promote a good company.
:~)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

...

There has been increased terrorism in the Egyptian Sinai-- jihadis crossing the Gaza border into the Sinai to attack Israel. But there have been attacks gainst Egyptian soldiers in the Sinai as well-- several Egyptians murdered by Hamas (and/or other groups from Gaza)-- so Egyptians are really getting pissed at Gaza extremists killing Egyptians.

Under Morsi this was mainly ignored, but now the new gov't is taking action.

Recently a terror cell in Sinai from Gaza)pwas planning attacks on Israel. Someone took them out (probably Israel). However, some analysts believe that Israel had coo[eration from Egypt. That Egypt and Israel are working closely together against jihadi terrorists in the Sinai (it is in their mutual self- interest).This new development is certainly not an indication of increasing isolation-- quite the contrary.

Another interesting case is that of Azerbaijan. (Some of the following may be a bit speculative): Its a former Soviet Republic in Central Asia. Muslim (But traditionally a moderate form of Islam). In the UN I believe they vote along with the Muslim bloc-- mainly not to get this huge bloc angry with them.

But there's another aspect to this. There is a large Azeri minority in Iran. (Iran borders Azerbaijan), and Iran treats them badly. So the Azerbaijanis do not like Iran!

As a result of this, they have a good (somewhat "secret") relationship with Israel.

But this is more interesting: apparently the Azeris have agreed to let Israeli planes use one of their airbases-- should the need arise. Hmmmm...

One of the problems facing a possible future Israeli attack on Iran is the distance. Planes would have to refuel-- over very dangerous hostile territory-- in order to make the round trip (to attack Iran and return to Israel).

Of course if they only had to fly one way, and then were able to land in a friendly country just over the Iranian border to refuel before making the trip back... Hmmm #2.... Grin.gif

And then there are the Sunni Gulf states and Saudi Arabia. Without going into a lot of detail: the bottom line is that they are more afraid of being attacked by Iran then being attacked by Israel.

And apparently Morocco has been secretly trading with Israel..probably also one or more Gulf states.

There are close ties between Israel and the Kurds...(apparently this goes back to the first Gulf War when some Israelis secretly went to northern Iraq to give military training to the Kurds who were fighting Saddam)

Europe? I believe Bulgaria and Finland-- while not exactly major world powers-- have very friendly relationships with Israel...

And there's China... but that's a whole 'nother story.....

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

All this, and without even touching upon Israel's rather large weapons exporting business. Let's also not forget the huge energy exports that will be going full bore by 2016.

The bottom line is this:

If you think you're being some kind of hero by not buying Israeli hand cream, just consider how much hand cream you have to stop buying to equal the sale of a single drone. Bowing to and making platitudinous pronouncements to your Arab clients is about the best you can do now. The US is now an energy EXPORTER, and OPEC sales are taking a hit. It won't be long until they go back to the tents.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

If they want to understand diplomacy, it's Israel, trying to survive while not upsetting too many certified idiots in Europe and America.

Many countries are befuddled by the Israeli attitude-- an attitude that they can't understand.

The Israelis do not want to be exterminated. And they actually take steps toward preventing that.

Many other countries find that to be strange and it confuses them. They just can't understand it.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

K,

I didn't see the "/S" at the end of your post. On the odd chance that you're not being sarcastic:

Many countries rely on the OPEC nations for their energy needs. Feigning befuddlement keeps the spigot on.

 
 

Who is online


Snuffy


104 visitors