The Problem With Corporate-Only Tax Reform
On Tuesday, President Obama proposed a grand bargain whereby he would be willing to decouple corporate tax reform from individual tax reform, largely because calls for individual tax reform have gone nowhere in our hyperpartisan Congress. As we discussed here, the President proposed cutting the top corporate rate from 35% to 28%, the top rate on manufacturers to 25%, and then eliminating a number of deductions and preferences to pay for the cut. The plan would be to make the reform revenue-neutral over a 10-year period, but to generate net revenue in the initial years, with that additional revenue used for job creation.
But theres a big problem with decoupling corporate reform from individual reform.
So-called C corporations the only type of business that generally pay tax at the entity level and the subject of the proposed reform comprised only 6% of all business tax returns during 2008. The remaining 94% was made up of S corporations (12%), partnerships (10%) and sole proprietorships (72%).
These three business types do not pay corporate-level tax; rather, the income earned by the business is allocated among theindividual owners who pay the tax on the incomeat the relevant individual income tax rates.
Lets assume this corporate tax reform were made into law starting in 2014, and the top corporate rate was dropped to 28% while many of the business tax deductions and preferences mentioned in the Presidents speech for example, elimination of LIFO inventory accounting , adjusting depreciation schedules, and limiting interest deductions were cut from the Code.
In 2014, an individual taxpayer will jump from a 28% marginal rate to a 33% marginal rate once taxable income exceeds approximately $226,750 (assuming married filing jointly status, $186,250 if single). The rate then continues to increase, reaching a high of 39.6% once taxable income exceeds $457,450. [i]
So whats the problem?
The problem is that if corporate reform is decoupled from individual reform, the Googles and Facebooks and IBMs of the world will be paying a maximum tax rate of 28% on potentially billions of profits, while a small businessperson who chooses to operate his business as an S corporation, partnership or sole proprietorship and earns $250,000 from that business will be paying tax at 33%. This disconnect will only get worse as the individuals business grows more profitable; to wit, a sole S-corporation shareholderwho earns $500,000 of income in his business would pay tax on the last dollar of income at 39.6%, while a C corporation with $5.0 billion in income would pay only 28% on its last dollar of income.
Clearly thats a problem, particularly for a President that has built both his campaigns around the concept of protecting the middle class. Now, you may take issue with my categorizing someone who earns half a million a year as middle class, but the point remains the same: an individual business owner could pay nearly 40% in tax while the worlds largest corporations pay only 28%.
Making matters worse, consider the possibility that the deductions and preferences that are pared from the Code as part of corporate reform will apply to all businesses, not just C corporations. For example, if the rules for depreciation are changed, what are the odds that Congress would limit the application of these rules only to assets held by a C corporation? If they choose not to, an individual who operates his business as an S corporation, partnership, or sole proprietorship would get the worst of both worlds: he would lose depreciations deductions without the benefit of the tax rate cut.
Decoupling corporate tax reform from individual reform as pitched by the President would lead to a golden age for the C corporation, as there would be little incentive for individual business owners to plod along with limited deductions and a maximum tax rate that is12% higher thanits C corporation competitors. This is just one of many reasons the Presidents latest proposal for tax reform was dead on arrival.
[i] The return of the phase-out of itemized deductions and personal exemptions which actually increase the top marginal rate to closer to 43%. In addition, beginning in 2013, a taxpayer with net investment income and AGI in excess of $250,000 ($200,000 if single), will pay an additional 3.8% tax on that investment income, bringing the maximum rate on items like interest income to 43.4%.)
http://www.forbes.com/sites/anthonynitti/2013/08/01/the-problem-with-corporate-only-tax-reform/
Tags
Who is online
109 visitors

Overall tax code reform - personal income tax and corporate income tax is badly needed and patches and fixes here and there to score political points by both parties will not help the country in the long run
It would not surprise me if this got passed how many businesses have left the states due to the government tax system against them as it stands against them today. I'd go with Royal Lancer's idea.
I have heard it suggested that corporations which are not publicly owned should not pay taxes at all . Monies earned are passed through to the owners of the business and are taxed there so that would be double taxation .
Does that make sense ?
Royal Lancer
A different time but regardless of what the tax rates end up being set at, the deductions, the credits, the subsidies, the loopholes need to be removed from both the personal and the corporate tax code and a new simpler, fairer tax code put I place
Tax the rich is a nice campaign slogan but tax code reform is more complicated than that
Shub
Thanks for your perspective
See my response to Lance above
Petey
I think you are talking abut S-Corporations in which the profit from the business is taken as income by the owner as personal income but as I understand it, there is no double taxing of the profits.
The S Corp small business owner just does not have the ability to use all the loopholes, credits et of the corporate tax code that are available to big corporations.