╌>

Why is Indian Child Welfare Act so important to the Indian people???

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  1stwarrior  •  13 years ago  •  14 comments

Why is Indian Child Welfare Act so important to the Indian people???

Yet they say I am a bad Indian. Who has ever seen me beat my wives or abuse my children? What law have I broken? Is it wrong for me to love my own? Is it wicked in me because my skin is red, because I was born where my fathers lived, because I would die for my people and my country?

--Sitting Bull

Because few federal laws govern the disposition of state court cases involving adoption, guardianship, and abuse and neglect, the existence of the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. 1901 et seq.) may come as a surprise to lawyers handling Indian child custody cases for the first time.

The Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), which was adopted by Congress in 1978, applies to child custody proceedings in state courts involving "Indian" children--children of Native American ancestry. The provisions of the ICWA represent a dramatic departure from the procedural and substantive laws that most states have enacted to govern child custody proceedings. Because Indian children are treated uniquely in the legal system, and because there is an increasing number of court proceedings involving Indian children, the need for lawyers to understand the ICWA is fast becoming imperative. (Since the ICWA was enacted, more than 250 state and federal court decisions have been rendered.)

Ensuring a Future
A look at history reveals why Congress determined a special law was needed to protect the rights of Indian children and their parents. Before 1978, as many as 25 to 35 percent of the Indian children in certain states were removed from their homes and placed in non-Indian homes by state courts, welfare agencies, and private adoption agencies. Non-Indian judges and social workers--failing to appreciate traditional Indian child-rearing practices--perceived day-to-day life in the children's Indian homes as contrary to the children's best interests.

In Minnesota, for example, an average of one of every four Indian children younger than age one was removed from his or her Indian home and adopted by a non-Indian couple. A number of these children were taken from their homes simply because a paternalistic state system failed to recognize traditional Indian culture and expected Indian families to conform to non-Indian ways.

Other children were removed because of the overwhelming poverty their families were facing. Although, admittedly, poverty creates obstacles to child rearing, it was used by some state entities as evidence of neglect and, therefore, grounds for taking children from their homes.

It was not only the high number of children being removed from their homes, but also the fact that 85 to 90 percent of them were being placed with non-Indians that caught the attention of Congress. Congress was actively promoting the continued viability of Indian nations as separate sovereigns and cultures at that time. By enacting the substantive placement preferences in ICWA--which require that Indian children, once removed, be placed in homes that reflect their unique traditional values (25 U.S.C. 1915)--Congress was acknowledging that no nation or culture can flourish if its youngest members are removed. The act was intended by Congress to protect the integrity of Indian tribes and ensure their future.

A second, and equally important, goal of Congress in enacting the ICWA was to ensure the placement of Indian children in homes that would reflect the unique values of Indian culture. This was achieved by the placement provisions of the ICWA, which govern both voluntary and involuntary placements of Indian children and define placement preferences that public and private agencies must follow. (Note that Indian tribes are permitted under the ICWA to change the order of the act's placement preferences, so you must investigate with each tribe you encounter the order of its particular preference scheme.)

According to the ICWA, when an Indian child is placed in foster care, the placement agency or party must place the child--in the absence of good cause to deviate--with: (1) a member of the Indian child's extended family (including non-Indian members of the family), (2) a foster home licensed or approved by the child's tribe, (3) an Indian foster home licensed or approved by a non-Indian agency or authority, or (4) an institution for children that has the approval of an Indian tribe.

To determine which placement option best meets the intent of the ICWA, the placement agency must consider the need to approximate the child's family setting as closely as possible, to keep the child as near as possible to his or her family's home, and to place the child in the least restrictive environment.

When an Indian child is placed for adoption, the ICWA requires that, in the absence of good cause to deviate, the child should be placed with: (1) a member of his or her extended family, (2) other members of his or her tribe, or (3) other Indian families. In this situation, too, it is necessary to determine whether the tribe involved has altered the standard preference scheme.

In either a foster care or adoption placement, if the party advocating a deviation from the placement preferences demonstrates good cause to deviate, the state court can sanction a placement that does not conform to the standard placement criteria.

The Department of the Interior's guidelines for state courts lists the following as examples of good grounds to deviate: (1) a request to deviate that comes from the biological parents or the child (provided he or she is of "sufficient" age), (2) extraordinary physical or emotional needs of the child (as established by qualified expert testimony), and (3) the determination--after a diligent search for a family that meets the placement preferences--that a "suitable" family is not available.

Is It Working?
The standard by which any law should be judged is whether it has achieved its stated legislative objective. The ICWA was enacted to prevent the continued removal by state agencies, courts, and private agencies of large numbers of Indian children from their families and--equally important--their culture.

At the very minimum, the existence of the act has brought attention to the unique needs of Indian children and provided state agencies and judges with a valuable, cross-cultural educational tool. Although the removal of Indian children from their homes continues to occur at an alarming rate, the ICWA mandates a process that, if adhered to over time, will eventually ensure the survival of Indian tribes and cultures well into the future.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

This is a very important concern to the Indian people. Failure to comply will tear apart the Indian community, rid its population of future growth, delete its membership, and relegate it to non-existence. Is this another form of termination?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Don't think there was much. The book was published in 1976 and ICWA passed in 1978, 10 years after being battled about.

Are you Central Cali?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Is this another form of termination?

It could be, 1stwarrior. They seem to take it as seriously as some of the commenters here.

If ICWA is terminated we are back to social service agencies coming into Indian homes and removing babies because they don't like the poverty on the reservations and don't think it's a nurturing environment for them. Well, duh! Children of all ages will again be taken from their parents and sold to foster homes for abuse and cultural displacement.

"Kill the Indian to save the man."

Perhaps the Tribes should file a Class Action Civil Rights suit against the federal government to make them uphold the treaty terms with regard to housing, sanitation, medical and educational facilities on reservations because failure to do so will result in removal of their children and/or death of their children which is in effect genocide.

And in light of the position of SCOTUS having a conflict of interest the Nations ask that the World Court hear the case.... ROFLMAO

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

This is despicable and abhorrent. If this were happening to black families who live in poverty it would never be tolerated and the president would be making speeches about it.

The most disgusting thing and the most telling is that the mother waited almost a year for the police to arrive and arrest her for the trumped up charges against her of drug use, called in by the spiteful neighbor who did not like her.... they never showed up, though that was the basis for removing first her year old twins then later her young school children.

Yes, much, much money to be had by the white foster homes where these Indian children were placed while the Indian foster homes where they, by law should have been placed have sat empty, some of them for six years and more.

Profiteering is exactly the word for it, Honemana.

Everyone posting here should follow your link and read this story.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

I'm going to read each and every one of those parts, Honemana. It's just beyond me how Indians have refrained from a full scale uprising over the taking of their children alone.

Forget the land, the unemployment, the sickness and disease that is stratospheric compared to the national average because of the government's failure to adhere to treaty requirements to provide sanitary infrastructure and medical facilities; forget the government's failure to provide, by treaty requirement, accessible schools and education....

the taking of children which continues to this day is enough to warrant the War Path and I am surprised that there has not been death on the reservations, not of Indians, but of social workers. It only goes to show how far down the souls and spirits of Native Americans have been beaten and kept under the heel of government, yet time and again social service workers and "fact finding" committees have descended on the reservations and returned to Washington to tell Congress they have absolutely no idea what causes the high incidence of alcoholism and suicides among Native American young people.

Well, DUH!!!!!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Honemana,

Please go to 1stwarrior's article:

The gloves come off - Civil Rights Suit filed as Adoption of Veronica finalized.

and post your link that I have just read. It is totally relevant.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

I have posted it; hope folks take the time to read it. It angers me that this type of thing is never in mainstream news. Were it any other minority it would be front page news.

And I feel so impotent in my anger because no other minority is so at the mercy of federal government for their very existence.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

I'm sorry that thread bothers you Hone - I wish you had let me know.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Smile.gif

 
 

Who is online





109 visitors