╌>

Palestinian Minister Hints Peace Deal Would Be Temporary Arrangement Before Conquering Israel Outright

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  13 years ago  •  17 comments

Palestinian Minister Hints Peace Deal Would Be Temporary Arrangement Before Conquering Israel Outright

As Secretary of State John Kerry pushes full steam ahead to try to bring the Israelis and Palestinian back to the negotiation table, a new video is casting doubt regarding true Palestinian intentions and tactics. Palestinian Authority Minister of Religious Affairs Mahmoud Al-Habbash in an on-camera sermon on Friday hinted any peace deal secured would secretly be only a short-term arrangement by comparing it to a truce the Muslim prophet Mohammed negotiated but broke two years later.

At the Friday Ramadan services, which were attended by Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and broadcast on Palestinian television, Habbash explained to Muslim worshipers that Palestinian Authority officials "only through the wisdom of the leadership, conscious action, consideration, and walking the right path" are headed toward "achievement, exactly like the Prophet [Mohammad] did in the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, even though some opposed it."

The Hudaybiyyah peace treaty of 628 A.D. refers to "a 10-year truce that Mohammad, Islam's Prophet, made with the Quraish Tribe of Mecca. However, two years into the truce, Mohammad attacked and conquered Mecca."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

The Religious Affairs Minister emphasized that Mohammed's choosing the path of negotiation with an enemy was not "disobedience" to Allah, but was rather "politics" and "crisis management."

Indeed, he broke the peace treaty two years later and conquered Mecca.

The Palestinian minister called Mohammed's example "the model" to be followed.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

No way!?

Mo' wasn't the good ol' boy muslims paint him to be?

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

imho, if we exploited all of our natural resources and moved to energy independence, much of this part of the world would be less of a problem for everyone.

that said, having heines-throw my fellow soldiers with lies in front of congress-kerry involved gives me great worry.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

The important thing is not achieving actual peace but the election value for the Dems in making "peace" . By the time the "agreement" is broken it will be too late .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

What a boon this would be for any that can bring some sorta agreement between the two sides. If there is actual treaty signed, whoever seen as the principal producer will reap much political clout.

If the administration waits just a little longer, they could come to the rescue just as the world looks as if it's ready to plunge of the precipice, and be seen as saviors.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

What a boon this would be for any that can bring some sorta agreement between the two sides. If there is actual treaty signed, whoever seen as the principal producer will reap much political clout.

Every recent American President has tried..and most have tried hard.

Well, with the possible exception of GWB--- he made a few feeble efforts, and really "at the last minute"-- toward the end of his Presidency. (He was more interested in pushing his cockamamie idea that Arab cultural values were consistent with democratic values. Pushing for democracy in Iraq-- anyone who reads the news knows how that has turned out.

Well, He did have one success of sort-- he was responsible for the Palestinians finally having a democratic election! (They voted in Hamas, a violent and barbaric terror group! One totally opposed to democratic principles, and who imprisoned, tortured, and murdered numerous Palestinians.. Frown.gif )

If the administration waits just a little longer, they could come to the rescue just as the world looks as if it's ready to plunge of the precipice, and be seen as saviors.

IMO, there's no way there will be peace-- or even any meaningful agreement that "is a step toward peace". (Most of the media loves to talk about how this or that is a "step towards peace" Over the years there have been many, many "steps towards peace" toward solving the Arab-Israeli conflict . . .

I don't think a real peace is forever impossible-- maybe in 20 years or so it will (hopefully) happen. But certainly not now.

It's hard to imagine that the Obama administration is unaware of these realities. So I am wondering why they are even bothering? (The only thing I can come up with is that it may be an attempt to look good in the Arab world.. perhaps a few groups there will say "Well, at least they (the U.S.) tried". But given the current hatred of the Obama administration in most of the Arab world, I doubt that this will change their views in the slightest. So why is Kerry even going through this absurd charade?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Well, with the possible exception of GWB--- he made a few feeble efforts, and really "at the last minute"-- toward the end of his Presidency. (He was more interested in pushing his cockamamie idea that Arab cultural values were consistent with democratic values. Pushing for democracy in Iraq-- anyone who reads the news knows how that has turned out.

10925832-large.jpg

Surely; GWB was a sensitive and affectionatefriend of the Arabs.

It's hard to imagine that the Obama administration is unaware of these realities. So I am wondering why they are even bothering? (The only thing I can come up with is that it may be an attempt to look good in the Arab world.. perhaps a few groups there will say "Well, at least they (the U.S.) tried". But given the current hatred of the Obama administration in most of the Arab world, I doubt that this will change their views in the slightest. So why is Kerry even going through this absurd charade?

I don't get it either. Maybe they believe that stalling is an adventagous tactic?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

What was promised by Obama? It probably cost a billion dollars just for the PA to show up.

That's a lot of rockets.

That is certainly not a good idea.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

I don't get it either. Maybe they believe that stalling is an adventagous tactic?

I just came across an article that tries to figure out what Kerry and the rest of the Obama administration must've been thinking. Some of the arguments are pretty interesting.

Perhaps even more interesting than the article itself are the comments. Some very astute observations in the comments section:

7 reasons the Americans think this time will be different
Undeterred by widespread Israeli and Palestinian skepticism, John Kerry is convinced he can broker a permanent accord. What does he know that we dont?
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

At first that cartoon would seem to make sense. But, in fact, it isn't actually accurate.

1. True-- if Abbas made a peace deal with Israel, Hamas wouldn't go along. However, there another, even stronger, reason that Abbas won't agree to peace. The fact is that he and his followers will never accept Israel's existence. They do want a new country to be called "Palestine". But they want it to include , land "From the River to the Sea"--in other words not only Gaza and The West Bank-- but also all of what is now Israel proper! In other words-- Israel won't exist!

In addition, any Palestinian official that makes peace with Israel (and allows Israel to exist) will be assassinated in short order.

2. That settlers can control Netanyahu's government is false. In fact, when Israel decided to withdraw from Gaza, many settlers in both the West Bank (and in settlements in Gaza) opposed it. They protested, even physically opposed leaving. So the Israeli government used the army to remove settlers from Gaza by force when necessary! The Isreli govrnment opposed the settlers-- and the gov't won!(Somme really excellent coverage, with great photos, are here:

Exodus From Gaza

The forcible evacuation of August 2005

J EWS have lived on and off in Gaza for millennia, long before Islam or Christianity were founded, and for many centuries before the concept of a Palestinian nation was born. In the past, others have driven Jews out of this strip of land that hugs the eastern coast of the Mediterranean. But in August 2005, in a period of just seven days, 21 Jewish communities were forcibly removed by their own government, as Israel became the first country in modern history to relinquish land acquired in a defensive war to an enemy that had not yet made peace with it.

It was the Israeli armys largest ever non-combat operation, involving 45,000 soldiers and policemen. Most of the world welcomed the unilateral withdrawal. Israelis were evenly divided: on the eve of the pullout a Tel Aviv University poll showed 48 percent of Israelis supported the plan, hoping that it would improve the life of Palestinians and lead to an end, or at least to a sharp drop, in acts of violence and the daily outpouring of genocidal propaganda in Palestinian society directed towards Jews.

Virtually not a single Jewish resident of Gaza left voluntarily. Many had to be carried out by soldiers and police. In some cases water cannon and batons were used, but there was no serious violence. After the residents had gone, the Israeli army, at the behest of the Palestinian Authority, destroyed the settlements, leaving only the synagogues, which it was hoped the Palestinians would respect. On September 12, 2005, the last Israeli soldier left Gaza, and it took just 15 minutes for the first abandoned synagogue to be set alight.

exodus13.jpg An Ethiopian-Israeli policewoman crying as she
administers the evacuation of Jews from Gaza.

exodus6.jpg Trying to shame Israeli troops over what opponents of the evacuation termed the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Gaza, a settler holds her baby in front of soldiers waiting to evict them from their homes in Neve Dekalim after the deadline for voluntary pullout had passed.

The settlers (and many Israelis who weren't settler) wanted Israel to remain in Gaza. The government wnted them to leave, the settlements destroyed. The government controlls the settlers-- and not vice-versa as this cartoon erroneously implies!

The fact is, the settlers cannot stop the government from doing what the government wants to do. (The cartoonist definitely has no clue as to the realities in the area)

This is an excellent photo essay by Tom Gross-- I highly receommend you check it out (also what happened to the huge masses the Israelis built in Gaza). LINK

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    13 years ago

The Palestinian - Israeli negotiations are more than likely doomed. Both sides have raving lunatics behind the scenes pushing agendas no human can reasonably accept. We know the Palestinians have always been up front about the destruction of Israel and the rhetoric is in the news frequently.

We don't hear much about crazed Israelis, do we? Does Rabi Yosef have followers? Yes, quite a few. His sermons and positions have been comdemned by American Jews, but his voice has been influential as the leader of the Shas - Israel's fourth largest party in the Knesset.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

From 7 reasons the Americans think this time will be different

6. The Americans do not regard Abbass failure to seize Ehud Olmerts 2008 offer to Abbas which included a full withdrawal from the West Bank with one-for-one land swaps to encompass major settlement blocs, the division of Jerusalem into sovereign Israeli and Palestinian areas, and the relinquishing of Israeli sovereignty in favor of a non-sovereign trusteeship in the Holy Basin as proof of Abbass ultimate intransigence. They believe both Abbas and Netanyahu have been impacted by the passage of time, by the new regional environment, by a shared concern at the conflict moving into a zone in which it becomes unresolvable. Its not entirely clear why or how they believe these factors might soften the sides positions and lead them to take decisions they would not previously have taken. Regional instability is unlikely to push Netanyahu toward a greater readiness for territorial compromise, for instance, though the desire for greater concerted pressure on Iran might. But believe they do. Unlike the Olmert offer, sprung on Abbas on a take it or leave it basis by a prime minister soon to leave office, any deal this time would be arrived at gradually, through mutual trade-off and compromise.

(My bold )

Ok.

I think I get that a starting-point will naturally assume some extreme positions; but, am I the only one who sees Israel giving more, right from the get-go?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

In my opinion totally a political ploy probably at a very high cost to the USA without any possibility of ever succeeding. May last long enough to provide a political advantage, but in reality zero percent chance of continuing beyond that time.

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

And Christians have never broken a treaty.35.gif

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

Ok little girl, all of the oil that comes out of American soil goes to the world market.

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

Why are Palestinians there? Because that area of the world was called PALESTINE for the last three thousand years. Comment removed for CoC violation. 76.gif 102.gif

Jack, I don't think you were involved in the meta article about the new code enforcement policy, so I am going to give this to you as a freebee, but I suggest you read it. It can be found under the CoC tab. {ph}

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Why are Palestinians there? Because that area of the world was called PALESTINE for the last three thousand years

So what?

As long as I can remember, in the United States some people referred to themselves as "New Englanders". And that area had called "NEW ENGLAND" for many years-- long before I was born (that was way back in the late 1800's, if I remember correctly. Smile.gif )

The area that is now Pakistan, India, and Sri Lanka has been refered to as SOUTH ASIA for some time now.

So here's awhat you are missing : sure, those areas had a name for a long time. But like PALESTINE, NEW ENGLAND and SOUTH ASIA are NOT the name of any country-- nor are they the name of any race, religionn or ethnic group.Rather, these names refer to a geographical region-- consisting of many distinct groups!

(And BTW, before the re-establishment of the state of Israel in 1948, Jews living there often rederred to themselves as "Palestinian Jews"-- or even "Palestinians". "Palestine"did not refer to any specific country, race, ethnicity or religion-- it just referred to a very general region!)

 
 

Who is online





122 visitors