America’s De-industrialization revisited (or can we fix this mess)
by Einstein Insanity
My previous blog entry on the de-Industrialization of America (with the City of Detroit being a notable example of it) was linked on a friends Facebook page, and one piece of feedback that came from it was I dont think the solution is as easy as he does when there are no emerging markets that arent already cemented in the off shore mentality. and I thought it would be appropriate to respond to it, because yes it is an important point.
First off, I never stated anywhere, neither here, nor any other blogging site that I frequented in the past (NewsVine, etc) that such a transformation will be easy. In actuality such a transformation will probably be one of the hardest things that America will have attempted (if it attempts this). In some ways harder than even the massive manufacturing and mobilization that came during World War II.
It will be harder because it will require the mindset of America to change. The war itself created that impetus during the 1939-45 time period.
It will be so hard because both political parties today are essentially locked into the same economic ideology (Supply Side Economics based on the writings of Milton Friedman), the population for the most part is pretty much locked into that exact same mindset, that same population are essentially clamoring for the next get rich quick scheme, and the way that we benchmark how our economy is doing has holes in it the size of barn doors spread wide open.
On top of that, we have had essentially 45 years of fundamental economic neglect (with the focus being on profit taking, or rent seeking as some economists like to define it), along with a population that quite honestly doesnt seem to have the desire to expand beyond their horizons.
An example of that can be seen in this persons statement, When there are no emerging markets being the key to me. Back when Henry Ford created the assembly line, there was no market, emerging or otherwise, for the car. There really wasnt even much in the way of roads either. This didnt stop Ford from creating the Model T, which may not have been the first car, nor the first attempt at mass production of a car, but it did revolutionize the industry, and for many decades, the economy as a whole.
The point here is that when we re-industrialize, we need to be creating those new markets, like Apple did when it created the iPhone, but that needs to be a continual process, which is unlike what Apple is now doing by not continuing that process, and Apples fortunes are starting to drop significantly, with the company now being seen by many as a follower, not a leader.
One can go back to the words of a president (or at least his speechwriter).
We choose to go to the moon. We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard, because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we are willing to accept, one we are unwilling to postpone, and one which we intend to win, and the others, too.
One thing is for sure though, not even attempting is even worse than attempting and failing in the attempt, because to do so is to give up. Once you have given up, quite honestly, is there any reason left to do anything at all?
Going back to the Apollo program for a moment. While the program itself may have been single ended, with no direct monetary gain, the economic activity that the program created is essentially second to none, and in some cases, the developments that resulted from the program are STILL benefiting the nation economically. How many investments can you say are still benefiting the economy 40 years after the program ended.
What this may actually boil down to is that the biggest problem that America faces is the malaise that seems to show that the nation has given up, and quite frankly, thats the saddest, and scariest thing thats happening.
I will end this with another quote from JFK
Only those who dare to fail greatly can ever achieve greatly.
Link to orginal article is here .
Tags
Who is online
113 visitors

Of particular interest to me is this quote...
It's the difficulty of our situation that is so undertalked about. What we need to do isn't easy, nor should it be. Those things worth doing can be/should be hard. Why? Because it makes them mean more.
So that is what happened to EI.
Perhaps we need to find a balance between demand and supply side economics
Fresh ideas are always needed in a world that believes originality is dead.
Should we continue down the trickle down theory the same as before? No, but we can't go toward a demand side either since we only have so many resources on this planet.
The other day an idea came to me. When all the money in the world is returned to the banks the total is $0.00 worldwide. With supplies limited and demand from consumers for new stuff. Why not eliminate green grass and fill it up?
Look at our primate cousins: Apes limited supplies tend to be male dominate and start wars between tribes. Bonobo are the opposite supplies is plentiful, female dominate, no wars.
How can man move closer to the Bonobo?
Well...I know that the Bonobo don't discriminate with regard to their 'partners.' Doesn't matter gender, age, etc. So looking at discrimination is a good place to start. Equal opportunity (don't equate that with equal outcomes).
This is a thought that I've had a lot. That is one thing about industrialization that I'm having a bit of a hard time working out in my head. Economically we need something, but it definately needs to be environmentally sustainable.
After the second world war, America had a number of things going for it, one of which was that we were sending an incredible number of returning GIs to school. It was a time when education was cherished and taken advantage of. Another was that there was a waiting market for our products from war torn countries that we were helping to rebuild.
Compare that to today. We are slipping in our graduation rates in both high school and college, and we are having difficulty developing demand at home for our own products.
The only area that I see that is large enough to have the sort of impact that we need to re-industrialize America is in the area of clean energy. Big oil and the coal corporations are going to fight this sort of thing to the death, and does our population have the education to pull off that sort of change? From what I see, we have about a one in ten chance of making the aforementioned happen.
I love the Goldilocks theory. Not too small not to big, but just right. To answer your question the answer I believe is somewhere in the middle of microeconomics and macroeconomics. We have the space all around us to create such an environmentally and economically sound dream it is realizing it.
What we need (imo) is something that is going to spark the interests of the people. It doesn't have to be 'green energy' (although that certainly could be a start), but it does need to be big... in ideas, and imagination. Of course, that takes risk, and there simply isn't anyone around that has the cajones to take that risk right now.
those who blame the de-industrialization on detroits demise are simply removing a splinter while ignoring the giant liberal beam engorging their eyeball.
these same claims were used for those who lamented the end of buggy-whip production, and are no less silly today.
the liberal believes, quite humorously, in a limited supply of wealth as well. like a very limited concept of the marketplace, its ability to change, so is their folly in belief that wealth cannot be created, but instead must only be redistributed.
this nonsense has been peddled by those wishing to justify class warfare for many generations. that their continued rediculous mantra even exists today is unfortunate. even this day, on morning schmo, all of the left redistribution apologists were pushing this crap with references to income inequality. ratner, who claims to have some grasp of basic economics admitted that "income inequality" cannot be "corrected" without government intervention (read redistribution, or any other _________-ism that we used to convict people for)
dear low information voter:
there is no such thing as income equality, there never has been, there never will be.
I'd say no . There have already been some inroads in these areas without any fighting or destruction from those big companies . When they become fully economically competitive they will take off .
Because of the investment that the US made to their younger people, we were able to go to the moon. We need to find something that will really spark the interest of our young people to want to gain a good education, and then follow through on that...just as our government did after WWII.
Hey...JoAnne,
Where in the article is there any mention of 'liberals, income inequality, class warfare,' or any of this 'stuff' that you are mentioning in your comment? Off topic much?
This is your usual let's-take-a-shot-at-liberals-for-whatever-without-actually-giving-any-specifics.
I insist this time;
1) "left redistribution apologists" - let's have some specifics because you're just tossing out the right-wing "HAVES" talk. Explain how the redistribution works and caused Detroit's problem
2) "income inequality" - give me the figures on CEO pay vs. Workers' pay when worker production is up 22% since the inception of Minimum Wage but workers' pay is up only about 9% -- whereTF is the other 13%?
Answer these then I'll give you the next round.
I'm real pissed about these Tea Party one-line slams that their shills regurgitate but never detail.
There's more to education than what fits on a bumper sticker, JoAnne.
Do you know about the sale of the Silver Dome?
I enjoy autobiographies.
FACT: Since 1950 CEO-To-Worker PAY RATIO is 1000 to 1 (CEO Pay has increased 1000% over workers pay).
Learn before you post.
LOL...(((((AMac))))) How are you my friend?
Doin' just fine and thank you for asking, leonahardware -- and here's more information for those on the right that think a vehicle with more than one bumper sticker is an Institution of Higher Learning. You f'rs dare utter the term "low-information voter" when you have no idea why shit happens?!!!
What the Tea Party doesn't explain -- and what is RANK and file (emphasis on the RANK), is when wages are low, it kills THE TAX BASE -- IT ERODES CONSUMERISM WHICH FURTHER ERODES THE TAX BASE -- ERODED CONSUMERISM KILLS JOBS BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE LESS TO SPEND SO BUSINESSES HAVE TO LAY OFF EMPLOYEES WHICH FURTHER ERODES THE TAX BASE BY CREATING MORE UNEMPLOYMENT, WHICH MEANS MORE TAX DOLLARS GO TO UNEMPLOYMENT, and THE CEO's take thir fat white assess to the suburbs -- which -- ERODES THE TAX BASE.
And does anyone know what happens when a city's tax base gets eroded?
And does anyone know what happens when Repoblican-subsidizing corporations outsource jobs and then a lie about the high business taxes in America -- WHICH MOST OF THEM DON'T PAY?
30 Major Corporations Paid No Income Taxes In The Last Three Years, While Making $160 Billion
AM I GETTIN' THROUGH TO ANY OF YOU BUMPER-STICKER-"Educated" think-you-know-it-alls?
Again I ask -- any of you Detroit-bashers know about the sale of the Silverdome?
Don't any of you Tea Party parrots tell me about Detroit and a declining America!
YOU'RE THE REASON!
from each according to ability, to each according to need
Wow! Poignant
albeit non-specific, not in any way addressing what I wrote and adding nothing to the dialogue; but WTF you are to be lauded for your consistency of presentation.
Oh! BTW, did I ask you about the sale of the Silverdome?
how about we just call Detroit a "so called" example of the folly of liberal redistributionism, and just hope it will all go away.
"summer of recovery"
ROTFL
Whoa! JoAnne -- I didn't think you could come back with any salient points.
Which shows you how frequently I'm correct about such things.
Mankind is divided into rich and poor, into property owners and exploited; and to abstract oneself from this fundamental division ;and from the antagonism between poor and rich means abstracting oneself from fundamental facts
~Stalin (murderer of millions)
drive-by malarkey
And that is why Stalin is considered one of the villains of all time.
Are you suggesting that Stalin is the go-to guy for fairness and ethics in the world?
Always love E I's articles
It seems to me that the crux of the matter is the parenthetical question in the title -
(or can we fix this mess)
And, though I know E I (and others) will likely disagree, the answer is simple and concise.
Of course we can fix this mess that is not doubt, but the question is whether "we the people" will muster the will and focus to make the necessary changes and take the necessary actions (some of which will not be pleasant) to fix this mess.
We can fix this mess but whether we will decide to and just do it remains a critical and unanswered question.
all of our troubles are over. barry has chosen to ignore article 2, section 3..he shall take care that the laws be faitfully executed...and just decreed that the hit on businesses is postponed for a year in disastercare. in addition, our dear leader dusted off his last campaign speach, and made some "Stylistic changes". now he is offering no specifics, but basically picking a few large corporations, giving them a break on the highest corporate taxes in the entire world, and using the expanded tax base for more "investment"
many estimate this will essentially be another 700 billion goodie bag for green road/bridges shovel ready nonsense.
but hey, the tax and spend liberal is not blamed for anything this crap caused last time, so what the heck.