╌>

Father and ICWA Continues Fight For Custody Against South Carolina Supreme Court and U.S. Supreme Court - July 27, 2013

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jsbach  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Father and ICWA Continues Fight For Custody Against South Carolina Supreme Court and U.S. Supreme Court   -  July 27, 2013

Dusten Brown continues fight for custody of Veronica

By MICHAEL OVERALL World Staff Writer on Jul 27, 2013, at 2:27 AM Updated on 7/27/13 at 2:53 AM

6259_discussions.jpg Dusten Brown and his wife along with his daughter, Veronica

When the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against the biological father last month, it sent the case back to South Carolina for "further proceedings not inconsistent" with its opinion.

Dusten Brown pinned a lot of hope on those four words this week when he asked the court to clarify its ruling.

Did the justices intend for Veronica's best interest to be considered before settling the custody dispute?

The justices also instructed the lower courts to end the case quickly and prevent "further delay and heartache for all involved."

Does that mean the lower courts shouldn't take the time for a best-interest hearing?

The state Supreme Court of South Carolina decided last week to take custody away from Brown as soon as possible and bring Veronica back to her adoptive parents in the suburbs of Charleston.

A family court has scheduled a hearing for Wednesday to work out a plan for the "transfer of physical custody."

Brown filed a petition with the U.S. Supreme Court late Thursday, asking for a chance in family court to argue that it's in Veronica's best interest, after 19 months in his custody, to stay with him permanently.

Veronica spent the first two years of her life in South Carolina with Matt and Melanie Capobianco.

The courts originally decided that the birth father had the right to stop the adoption and take custody under the Indian Child Welfare Act, which gives preference to Indian families and tribes in the adoption of Indian children.

But the U.S. Supreme Court overturned that decision, ruling that ICWA didn't automatically guarantee the father custody.

This week's petition doesn't ask the court to changes its mind about that.

But, as Brown points out, the court didn't strike down the Indian Child Welfare Act, only a particular application of it to this case.

In her dissenting opinion, Justice Sonia Sotomayor explained that ICWA still applied in other ways, giving Brown's parents and other members of the Cherokee Nation the right to adopt Veronica if he loses custody.

Brown signed away custody in January 2010, when Veronica was 4 months old. But he says he intended to give custody to the birth mother and never approved of an adoption.

Veronica is nearly 4 years old now and has no memory of her time in South Carolina, he says.

The birth mother, Christy Maldonado, broke off her engagement with Brown during the pregnancy and arranged a private adoption.

She's now part of a separate federal lawsuit trying to have parts of the Indian Child Welfare Act declared unconstitutional.

Her attorney dismissed the father's effort to take the case back to the Supreme Court as futile.

"This long saga has finally come to an end," Lori Alvino McGill said. "And we expect Veronica's long-overdue transition home to begin as planned next week."


Michael Overall 918-581-8383
michael.overall@tulsaworld.com

____________________________________________________________________________________________

Opinion:

For me, I find this ordeal quite frustrating. Top priority of most courts is to keep children with their parents, so why is this any different? Because he's a man? A Father rather than a mother?

If the adoptive parents really cared for this child, they would stop and realize the young girl deserves to remain with her father. It's heart-breaking for everyone, but in the end, this child will resent the adoptive parents for not allowing her to remain with her father who has had Veronica almost two years now.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I imagine the real mother better stay clear of the real father in this situation, because if I were the real father and I only vaguely remember the story, which I researched about a month ago, well... I don't think it would be a pretty picture as he being Indian or not, he really got the shaft.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

The folks in South Carolina did not adopt Veronica - they petitioned to adopt her and the two courts of South Carolina said no, the Birth Father, had the Baby Girl and could keep her.

 
 

Who is online





113 visitors