╌>

There's No Formula for Fixing Detroit, and That's a Good Thing!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  22 comments

There's No Formula for Fixing Detroit, and That's a Good Thing!

Justin Fox of Harvard Business Review has a very interesting and insightful view of the Detroit bankruptcy and his view of what the future might or could hold for the once great metropolis.

The news of Detroit's bankruptcy has brought countless explanations of what went wrong, some of them pretty interesting. But the main point of a bankruptcy especially this bankruptcy, which has been looming for decades is to get a fresh start.

So it's been dismaying to see how little attention has been paid in the past week's news coverage to the fact that central Detroit is already in the midst of fresh start, a revitalization that feels far more organic and durable than past top-down efforts like the construction of the Renaissance Center in the late 1970s and the arrival of casinos in the late 1990s (although the casinos do appear to pay the bulk of the city's bills at the moment). Decrepit buildings in downtown and midtown are being renovated and converted into loft apartments, hotels, restaurants, and offices. Compuware and Quicken Loans have moved their headquarters and thousands of employees from the suburbs to the city. There's an incipient venture-capital and startup scene, and lots of small creative businesses. The area's pro sports teams are almost all back downtown. Young, upwardly mobile people are actually moving to Detroit.

Outside of this rejuvenating core and a few residential neighborhoods that are still holding strong, Detroit is an under-populated, crumbling mess. In 1950 the city had more than 1.8 million inhabitants; this year the population will probably slip below 700,000. Providing city services like police protection and garbage pickup across 139 ever-emptier square miles keeps getting more expensive and difficult (Detroit now has much lower population density than famously sprawling Los Angeles although it's still denser than more recent boomtowns such as Houston and Phoenix). Just since 2000, the city has lost 26% of its people, with the white flight that began Detroit's decline in the 1950s long since overtaken by an exodus of middle-class African-Americans.

Those left behind are increasingly those who can't get out with a per capita income of just $15,261 and 36.2% of the population below the poverty line, Detroit is now by most measures the poorest big city in the country.

So what do you do about that all that?

I moderated a panel titled "Is Detroit the Next Berlin?" and the general consensus was that no, the huge inflow of federal money and artsy types from all over that converted the once-depressed German capital into a global hotspot was not going to be replicated in Detroit although a few artsy types were already there and some federal money sure would be nice. So here are some other paths:

Immigration. New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg made headlines two years ago by arguing that Congress ought to "pass a law letting immigrants come in as long as they agree to go to Detroit and live there for five or 10 years, start businesses, take jobs, whatever." That apparently isn't going to happen, and recent immigration, while surely a positive for Detroit, hasn't been on the scale that has helped revitalize big cities nearer the coasts. In fact, the city has so far attracted far fewer immigrants than its suburbs which does indicate that there's opportunity for improvement.

Shrinkage. Not long after NBA Hall of Famer Dave Bing became Detroit's mayor in 2009, reports surfaced that he was thinking of bulldozing a quarter of the city. Reality has turned out to be less dramatic, but the city is definitely working to reduce its footprint to abandon some neighborhoods in order to focus on making others thrive. That could help with cutting costs and improving services, but groovy urban farms aside it's not what you'd call an entirely positive development.

Policy innovation. The most thought-provoking thing I've read about Detroit in the past week was a blog post by The Century Foundation's Jacob Anbinder sketching out four possible government policy fixes: (1) let property owners (about half of whom aren't paying their taxes at the moment) choose what their taxes are spent on, (2) make city workers live in Detroit (less than half do, and this is something Mayor Bing has already been talking about), (3) let wealthier municipalities temporarily take over parts of Detroit for economic development purposes, which is allowed under Michigan law, and (4) do away with the region's ridiculous public transit divide in which the suburbs and the city run separate and disconnected bus systems. Are these the right prescriptions? I don't know. But bold experimentation certainly has to be part of the picture.

Bankruptcy. I'm guessing Chapter 9 has been inevitable for Detroit for a while, but the timing and specifics of it were forced on the city by Republican governor Rick Snyder, a former business executive (at Gateway Computers; remember them?) and venture capitalist. Snyder seems like a pragmatic guy who genuinely wants to enable an economic rebirth for Detroit, and his decision has been welcomed by the city's new entrepreneurs. Bankruptcy is, after all, a way to get out from under past commitments that they had nothing to do with. But a lot of those commitments were to municipal workers, who (the ones who actually live in the city, at least) make up much of the Detroit's remaining middle class. The most surprising elements of the city's bankruptcy filing have been the claims that Snyder-appointed Emergency Manager Kevyn Orr has made about the dire state of the city's pension funds; there's widespread suspicion that he's overstating the problem. That's got to be at least partly a negotiating tactic, but it's a dangerous game Orr is playing. It's not that city pensions should be untouchable they definitely won't be, now that a bankruptcy judge is likely to be calling the shots. But the great tragedy of Detroit over the last half century has been an inability to share responsibility and opportunity across racial and municipal lines. If the bulk of Detroit's bankruptcy costs are borne by a bunch of (mostly black) city workers for the benefit of a bunch of (mostly white) entrepreneurs and corporate workers, what kind of restart will that be?

Money. In a much-debated New York Times op-ed a few days ago, Steven Rattner who managed the Detroit automakers' successful bankruptcies in 2009 argued that the only feasible way forward is for the state of Michigan (and to a lesser extent the federal government) to help Detroit out. Michigan has had a pretty awful decade, but it's still in much better shape than Detroit. And it seems like many of the state's leading businesspeople, and its governor, have come around to the idea that the state can't thrive again until its biggest city is on the comeback trail. There are limits to what money can do, and I imagine that anything that could be labeled a "bailout" would spell political suicide for Snyder. But hey, maybe he's itching to go back into the VC business so he can invest in Detroit.

Entrepreneurs. The downtown Detroit boomlet is to a remarkable extent the work of one wealthy risk-taker, Quicken Loans chairman and co-founder Dan Gilbert. According to the blog Detroit Unspun, Gilbert and his firm Rock Ventures now own or control more than 30 properties downtown, totaling 7.5 million square feet. That's a huge bet on a far from sure thing, and while sometimes I think entrepreneurship gets oversold as a cure for economic ills, it's hard to think of anything that would do more to get Detroit going than the presence of a couple more Dan Gilberts, and a few hundred or thousand mini-Dan Gilberts.

http://blogs.hbr.org/fox/2013/07/theres-no-formula-for-fixing-detroit.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

I thoroughly enjoyed the article which focused on the re-emergence of Detroit like a rising phoenix rather than dwell on who is to blame and focusing on what could and should be rather than what should not be done.

I especially like his summation of the all of the information presented above, when he states....

Does all this add up to a formula for fixing Detroit?

No and you may have noticed that I completed avoided the topic of fixing Detroit's schools, which is clearly crucial yet diabolically hard.

But to a certain extent the lack of formula is the point.

A fresh start for Detroit means entering uncharted territory and that's exciting.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

Information is power, so give information to the people.

I agree with Policy innovation blogger, but everything else you have mentioned is giving the money to the rich. Wouldn't liberals disagree with that. The trickle down does not work if I recall.

Detroit getting a fresh start is a good thing as long as this doesn't turn into Haiti

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Shub

NO idea what you are talking as I did not "mention" anything other than that I enjoyed the article and liked the author's approach to the Detroit bankruptcy.

So I do not understand when you say

but everything else you have mentioned is giving the money to the rich. Wouldn't liberals disagree with that. The trickle down does not work if I recall.

Nor do I understand your reference to Haiti

Care to elaborate

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

speaking of examples of liberal progressive results, this morning i flipped thru the usual channels expecting the lead stories on the propaganda outlets to be all about obama's redistribution speach. i was at first surprised, as one led with a monarch, the next led with a train wreck, and a third with a huge municipal bankruptcy. but then, i realized, all of these were actually the same as obama giving a speach on the economy.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

my moneys on baltimore (tax money that is) being next.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

the best thing about detroit is, now at least we can see the true goal of liberal progressive redistribution union/government partnership.

hope i am not around when they are able to do the same for the entire country.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

The intent of the article was to discuss the author's views on what could, should and might come from a re-emergence of Detroit out of bankruptcy and what types of investment and projects might work or not work in that process.

It was not intended as a forum for bashing political ideologies that you oppose

Try to focus - I know it is hard, but we are discussing what will happen (or not happen) in Detroit post bakruptcy

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

Detroit has had money problems since the fifties.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Try to focus - I know it is hard, but we are discussing what will happen (or not happen) in Detroit post bakruptcy

Imagine you are 65 or older. You have worked all your life, paid your taxes and planned your retirement. All the visits to the finacial planner gave you that warm fuzzy feeling, that you and your better half will have enough to live out a modest life and not be a burden to your family.

Now imagine someone decides that you do not deserve to retire as you intendedand that you will be a burden to your family. Thereby creating finacial hardship and a further drag on the economy, when they have to put you in a state run "Home". All because you got screwed out of your hard earned pension or your parents did.

Sonny: Kiss me.

Det. Sgt. Eugene Moretti: What?

Sonny: Kiss me. When I'm being fucked, I like to get kissed a lot.

From the movie-"Dog Day Afternoon" (1975)

This issue is not about Detroit making a "comeback". This is not just about union pension plans. Nor is it about anything else they want sell you. It's about rich people restructuring Detroit's debt to make future investment more lucrative. All at the expense of the people of Detroit. Any plan which doesn't include the people of Detroit is a huge government failure.

It has been called a significant legal case precedent for a reason, even before it is decided. Just another law changed to benefit the "one percenters". Your retirement is next.

Kiss me.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Immigration. New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg made headlines two years ago by arguing that Congress ought to "pass a law letting immigrants come in as long as they agree to go to Detroit and live there for five or 10 years, start businesses, take jobs, whatever."````

Some interesting ideas here. I think this idea is actually a good one.

Except for one thing: what immigrant in their right mind would voluntarily move to a hell-hole like Detroit?

And "take jobs"? Well, I'm sure even the current residents would love to do that. But what if there aren't any jobs?

"Start businesses"? Most immigrants don't have the large amount of cash that takes. And it won't be easy to find people willing to invest in a business in Detriot-- there are other considerably safer investment opportunities elsewhere.

IMO it is hopeless.

Unless there is a huge infusion of cash from "the government." (What most people don't realize is that cash from the government comes out of our pockets via taxes. Want to help Detoit-- well, I suppose that's worth having our taxes go up, don't you? 39.gif )

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

what immigrant in their right mind would voluntarily move to a hell-hole like Detroit?

Apparently this one :

but OTOH he was drunk .

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

O M

I get your point, thanks for sharing and a movie reference is always welcome

That being said, there is no money left in Detroit's checking account - so is it better and fair to restructure the debt package so that everyone gets a little less or to simply let the city default on its obligations so that in the course of time (and not a long time) everyone gets nothing.

And the bankruptcy is being handled by the federal court (which is we the people), not some group of "rich people" in a back room dividing up the spoils. News flash there is very little "spoils" for anyone

I feel sorry for retirees that will receive lower benefits (but still some of their pension), I feel sorry for the creditors who loaned Detroit money and/or bought municipal bonds in good faith and I feel sorry for the people of Detroit (those who have stayed the course) who are and will receive a lower level of civil services.

There is, and has been for decades, an insufficient tax base, coupled with fiscal mismanagement and a process of delaying problems until the future in Detroit to support the level of debt and the generous pension plans that were negotiated to placate union members over the years.

If the debt is not restructured, the outlays adjusted to match the revenue and better fiscal management processes instituted the problem cannot be solved and while the government can partner with the city and the private sector in the aftermath of the bankruptcy to accelerate the reemergence and restrengthening of the city, simply pouring in money ("bailing out") is simply delaying the problem for a few years and is not in the best interests of the city or its people.

Change must occur

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

for those who would rather ignore the causes of detroit's demise, i would respectfully suggest that those who choose to ignore the failures of the past, are doomed to repeat them.

please consider dismissal of the facts that lead to this, and other possible bankruptcies as being terribly short-sighted at the least.

if one looks far enough into the past, one can predict the future.

liberal progressivism is a proven formula for economic disaster, poverty, and even murder.

always has been, and always will be.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

boo fricking hoo

i know all the money i have paid into, and will continue to put into soc sec, i will never see.

i know my husband and i will probably have to work well into our 70's

we dont have any assumptions when it comes to the fed managing our retirement funds (lib promises aside), and we certainly dont think the young obama voters of today will be able to support us.

so boo fricking hoo, suck it up, and apply for one of barrys new normal part time jobs.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

irrelevant to the topic

but a funny looking graphic, gotta love Wilder as Wonka

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Everyone play nice please!

Remember disagreement without being disagreeable is a sign of intelligent, civil debate

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

so boo fricking hoo, suck it up, and apply for one of barrys new normal part time jobs.

This type of compassion is so touching. Especially, when any settlement of the debt can and should consider the retirees in question. If it doesn't, yes, it will be repeated anytime someone wants to escape legal financial commitments. When it is repeated I hope this class of righty's gets it first.

Speaking of "ignoring". Ignoring ones debts and responsibilities has consequences other than a fresh start for the record number of corporations sitting on cash.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

Worst thing they did was to put the fires out in 1967. We all knew the liberals had completely destroyed the place by then. Detroit will not reemerge all the good hard working people left years ago.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Wasn't Moriarity(Cassady) a liberal beatnik type of Kerouac's conjouring? But,I digress.

The twelve years before democratic Detriot mayor Cavanagh ('62-'67) were two republicans. Seems they had a hand in all this too.

Cabo ('50-'57) died in office. He came from Borroughs in '33 to help deal with Detroits "financial problems", Really? Served 7 consecutive terms as city treasurer. I'll bet he got paid to run Detriot further down.

Mirianni ('58-'61) served on city council before and after being mayor. Convicted of tax evasion in '65. Where did all that money, not claimed, come from? Capone was convicted of the same thing, am I right? Say no more.

Yeah man, it was the libs. Every stinkin' politician who ran the city was touched by it's corruption, not just the democrats.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Where the problem originated or whois to blame is no longer really that important

Where Detroit goes from here is what should be discussed

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Absolutely. Just making a point.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

I could send you a book of matches if you're looking for donations.

 
 

Who is online


CB


113 visitors