The Next Fed Chairman: Navigating Between Scylla and Charybdis
John Taft is CEO at RBC Wealth Management and contributed this article to LinkedIn.
I hope you all find it as interesting as I did
Like all media, the financial press prefers to focus on personalities rather than policies. Not surprisingly, we keep reading about who will replace Ben Bernanke as the next Chairman of the Federal Reserve System. Will it be Janet Yellen, the Feds current Vice Chair of the Board of Governors, in a bid for continuity? Or former Treasury Secretary, White House adviser and Harvard University President Larry Summers, because it completes his resum? Or possibly former Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, in continued defiance of the Peter Principle that incompetence eventually reaches its own level?
In point of fact, who the next Chair will be matters far less than what is his or her policy of how.
Think of Bernankes successor as the first mate on Odysseus ship. The Greek hero attempts to sail between offsetting dangers on the coasts of Italy and Sicily. Yet there is little if any wind (economic growth), the ships sails are already fully deployed (zero interest rates) and the skipper (President Obama) and the rest of the crew (Congress) have long ago left the tiller unattended and are below deck arguing about what to have for dinner. How will the next Fed Chair navigate between the modern day equivalents of the mythological six-headed monster Scylla and the whirlpool Charybdis? How will he or she continue to provide enough liquidity to keep the U.S. economy from slipping into Japanese-style deflation, while at the same time refraining from creating conditions for prolonged and debilitating inflation?
This policy conundrum is whats euphemistically called managing the exit. It is the single most important issue facing financial markets and the U.S. economy today.
To manage our way through it, the quality I would most want to see in our next Fed Chair is what Warren Buffet calls an Inner Scorecard moral fortitude of sufficient strength and quantity to resist political pressure on an epic scale.
Because thats what theyre going to face.
I want a Chair who can resist calls for the Fed to steer a course toward one or more of the cowardly, underhanded monetary policy solutions to the dilemma that the U.S. and other developed nations have created namely, entitlements we can no longer afford in a slow-growth, post-financial crisis world.
We have promised ourselves no end of riches, from pensions through to health care, and from education through to big stock-market gains, writes Stephen D. King in his new book, When the Money Runs Out: The End of Western Influence. These promises can only be met, however, if our economies continue to expand at a rate weve become accustomed to.
Lacking the ability to grow our way out of our problems, our elected government has abdicated its responsibility for decision-making, as Fortunes Moshe Silver observes . Time and again, our political leaders have demonstrated their inability to either increase revenues by raising taxes or to cut spending by scaling back entitlements.
Expect them, instead, to continue to turn to the next Fed Chair and ask him or her to steer towards one or two policy solutions, either:
- The Scylla policy of continuingto keep interest rates at historically low levels for as long as possible.To maintain what PIMCOs Bill Gross has termed financial repression. Tocontinue to test what Chairman Bernanke calls the zero lower bound. Theintention and effect of this back door solution is to confiscate returnsfrom savers, namely retirees and other depositors. These pilfered savingshelp do two things: (1) replenish the capital of financial institutionswounded by the financial crisis, and (2) hold down the cost of servicingthe ever-increasing notional amount of debt our government will eventuallyhave to repay.
- Or the Charybdis policy ofinflating our way out of our public debt problem. To continue to flood thefinancial markets with liquidity until inflation creeps up. The intentionand effect of this policy, too, amounts to confiscating returns fromsavers and depositors so the federal government can repay todays debtswith cheaper dollars in the future.
Both approaches will shipwreck our economy over the long run.
Chairman Bernanke is, in my opinion, a modern day hero. I have written and stated publicly that he and former Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson deserve the Congressional Medal of Honor for the rescue package they designed and sold to Congress that kept us from replaying the Great Depression of the 1930s.
Homers hero Odysseus took 10 years to return from Troy to Ithaca after the Trojan War. Were five years into Chairman Bernankes journey back from the financial crisis of 2008-2009. Maybe its possible he himself could stick around to finish the trip. That would be my first choice.
But if not, I hope the next Fed Chair has the capacity for independence it will take to safely navigate us through the rest of our economic odyssey.
Tags
Who is online
98 visitors

I came across this incredibly interesting article by John Taft, is CEO at RBC Wealth Management, with his perspective on the upcoming appointment of a new Fed Chairman and the challenges that the new chairman will certainly face.
I find it very important to note that he places no particular importance on whether the new chairman is a democrat or republican, liberal or democrat but rather on the practical view and execution of economic policies.
I am sure that many will disagree with his conclusions, but I hope that all can agree that the next Fed Chairman will be very important in leading the nation of the stagnant "recovery light" and returning robust growth to the U.S. economy.
Enjoy!
Everyone probably knows themeaning of Scylla and Charybdis, but in case someone story does not, here is a simplified explanation from Wikipedia
I can picture deflation as a whirlpool , w/o problem . What would be a good analogy for hyperinflation ?
I seek a chairman that isn't going to use seniority over the rest of the federal reserve, but is willing to listen to those below them and get some ideas flowing that have been ignored by the senior staff under Ben.
Petey
Here is an interesting article that gives analogy to explain hyper inflation
Let me know what you think
Shub
I think that is exactly what the author is saying in so many words - a chairman that thinks for himself, listens to others and has a real idea on how the recovery can and should work in the long term and not just a series of short term fixes.
Do you think we will see such a chairman?
OK , read it . Maybe hyperinflation should be a can of carbonated beverage that is shaken before opening ?
Petey
I can see the similarities
IF we do what is the catch?
didnt lizzy warren want it?
i hear one of barry's most trusted financial advisors Corzine is looking for work!
JoAnne
Thanks for that lighter moment
Your first suggestion has a job that she really digs now and your second suggestion should never be anything but an inmate in my view