╌>

Whole Foods' John Mackey: Why Intellectuals Hate Capitalism

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  11 years ago  •  0 comments

Whole Foods' John Mackey: Why Intellectuals Hate Capitalism

http://reason.com/reasontv/2015/08/12/whole-foods-john-mackey-capitalism

"Intellectuals have always disdained commerce" says Whole Foods Market co-founder John Mackey . They"have always sided...with the aristocrats to maintain a society where the businesspeople were kind of kept down."

More than any other outlet, Whole Foods has reconfigured what and how America eats and the chain's commitment to high-quality meats, produce, cheeses, and wines is legendary. Since opening his first store in Austin, Texas in 1980, Mackey now oversees operations around the globe and continues to set the pace for what's expected in organic and sustainably raised and harvested food.

Because of Whole Foods' trendy customer base and because Mackey is himself a vegan and champions collaboration between management and workers, it's easy to mistake Mackey for a progressive left-winger. Indeed, an early version of Jonah Goldberg's best-selling 2008 book Liberal Fascism even bore the subtitle "The Totalitarian Temptation from Mussolini to Hillary ClintonandThe Totalitarian Temptation from Hegel to Whole Foods."

Yet nothing could be further from the truthand more distorting of the radical vision of capitalism at the heart of Mackey's thought. A high-profile critic of theminimum wage, Obamacare, and the regulatory state, Mackey believes that free markets are the best way not only to raise living standards but also to explore new ways of building community and creating meaning for individuals and society. At the same time, he challenges all sorts of libertarian dogma, including the notion that publicly traded companies should always seek to exclusively maximize shareholder value ( go here to read a 2005 Reason debate about the social responsibility of business featuring Mackey, Milton Friedman, and Cypress Semiconductor CEO T.J. Rodgers). Conscious Capitalism , the book he co-authored with Rajendra Sisodia, lays out a detailed case for Mackey's vision of a post-industrial capitalism that addresses spiritual desire as much as physial need.

Reason TVs Nick Gillespie talked with Mackey earlier this summer at FreedomFest , where among other things, Mackey debated billionaire Peter Thiel on the role of monopoly and competition in business.

Runs about 16 minutes.

Produced by Todd Krainin. Cameras by Zach Weissmueller and Paul Detrick.

Scroll below for downloadable versions. Subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. CHECK ANY QUOTES AGAINST THE VIDEO FOR ACCURACY.

reason: Hi, Im Nick Gillespie with ReasonTV, and today were talking with John Mackey. Hes the co-founder of Whole Foods Market and the co-author of Conscious Capitalism . John, thanks for talking to us.

John Mackey: Glad to be here, Nick.

reason: What Im especially interested in talking with you about is the attacks that you see capitalism under, systematically. I know that, from reading your book, and from talking with you, you believe that capitalism is not only the greatest wealth creator, it helps poor people get rich, it helps everybody along the way. But you see it as constantly being misrepresented, even by its champions. Why is capitalism under attack?

Mackey: Intellectuals have always disdained commerce. That is something that tradesmen did; people that were in a lower class. And so you had minorities, oftentimes did it, like you had the Jews in the West. And when they became wealthy and successful and rose, then they were envied, then they were persecuted and their wealth confiscated, and many times they were run out of country after country. Same thing happened with the Chinese in the East. They were great businesspeople as well. So the intellectuals have always sided kind of with the aristocrats to maintain a society where the businesspeople were kind of kept down. You might say that capitalism was the first time that businesspeople kinda caught a break, because of Adam Smith and the philosophy that came along with that, and the industrial revolution began this huge upwards surge of prosperity.

reason: Is it a misunderstanding of what business does? Is it envy? Is it a lack of capacity to understand that what entrepreneurs do, or what innovators do, is take a bunch of things that might not be worth much separately and then they transform it? What is the root of the antagonism towards commerce?

Mackey: Its sort of where people stand in the social hierarchy, and if you live in a more business-oriented society, like the United States has been, then you have these businesspeople, who they dont judge to be very intelligent or well-educated, having lots of money, and they begin to buy political power with it, and they rise in the social hierarchy, whereas the really intelligent people, the intellectuals, are less important. And I dont think they like that. And I think thats one of the main reasons why the intellectuals have usually disdained commerce: they havent seen it, the dynamic, creative force, because they measure themselves against these people, and they think theyre superior, and yet in the social hierarchy theyre not seen as more important. And I think that drives them crazy.

reason: What happens to a business person, I mean, because a lot of the times they are plucky upstarts; theyre innovators, theyre disruptive, and theyre fighting against the power. And then what happens that once they get to a certain point of influence or power, then they start to try and rig the market or freeze the market in their favor?

Mackey: I dont know if its a psychological switch so much as that they werent necessarily grounded in the philosophy of capitalism. They werent necessarily advocates of the free market. They were just advocates of their own advancement, their own personal enrichment. And so I think oftentimes, they dont make a distinction between when theyre entrepreneurs on the way up versus when theyve arrived, and theyre attempting to not fall, so they try to rig the game, and we have crony capitalism that way.

reason: We live in an age now, and youve talked about this a lot, where there are just an unbelievable amount of government mandates that restrict the ability of business owners and employees to really negotiate about stuff. Theres things as obvious as the minimum wage, where it says, Under no circumstances, a business cannot offer somebody less than this amount. How do these affect your ability to run a business that is in an extremely competitive market?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc

Who is online





69 visitors