Detroit files for bankruptcy protection
DETROIT -- The city of Detroit filed for Chapter 9 bankruptcy protection in federal court Thursday, laying the groundwork for a historic effort to bail out a city that is sinking under billions of dollars in debt and decades of mismanagement, population flight and loss of tax revenue.
The bankruptcy filing makes Detroit the largest city in U.S. history to do so.
Tags
Who is online
97 visitors

Apparently the pensions Detroit pays public service employees have been very generous-- and as is the case with others cities, this major source of cash outflow just keeps increasing. Detroit is attempting to change this-- but I would imagine they will face major headwinds...
It seems that the unions and the bond holders might end being treated in a similar manner to those who wereunsecured creditorsin the GM bankruptcy
What is that saying - what goes around comes around"
It would seem fair that all creditors would be treated in a like manner
But what does fairness have to do with it right?
"Fairness", more often than not, is really a matter of opinion.
Public unions generally have a different idea of what's "fair" than city officials in a bankrupt city who have to pay out large sums to pensions-- yet also have to provide essential city services.
D.L
I accept your premise
So perhaps a haircut for all creditors is indeed the fair way to proceed through the bankruptcy, since the fiscal crisis will not be abated if the largest unfunded liabilities are not modified alongwith other debts
At first glance that sounds like a reasonable solution.
But-- let's think it through (keeping in mind that to be fair, any settlement nust be fair to both parties).
Lending money involves a risk. And, of course, it also involves the possibility of profit.
So-- from the creditors' POV-- when is it worth it? In which cases is the risk reasonable to take-- and in which situations is it not?
Of course there's no way of knowing for sure in advance. Its an "educated guess"-- and one of the factors taken into account is past history of similar situations.
However, a loan is governed by various legal considerations--its legal contract with legal obligations-- the borrower promises to repay it following conditions hen haas promised to agree to
If the gov't allows one side to not uphold that contract-- and people are allowed to go back on their word-- what is the ultimate result? If those willing to loan money start to see that they have no right to get their money back, and the gov't allows borrowers to be absolved of taking responsibility for their actions which they agreed to, it becomes clear that they won't be held responsible for their commitments (which means the gov't is actually backing a legalized form of robbery of lenders by debtors)--- what effect will this have on lenders in the future?
Other than the lenders being legally robbed, and the debtors being allowed to go back on their word as well as breaking a legal contract-- what do you think will be the result?
Detroits problems are a microcosm of the nations problems. Too many times funds are bastardized in ways that warrant masks and guns be handed out.Often allowing corporations and governments to escape the financial responsibilities promised to employees. Promises people count on for retirement.
BlamingDetroits pension liability on the evil unions is an easy copout. The problem is more complex than the run of the mill 'union hater" can comprehend.
These funds are designed to invest the monies for long term stable growth strategies, as quoted above. Long term growth has lower risk by design. How the pensions were mismanaged seems to not be important to this article, if they are indeed relevant. Unless the Detroit keepers pillaged the fund like the US Congress has pillaged the Social Security fund.
In addition to mismanagement, with todays market conditions even a novice investor can pick stocks and profit. What idiot is still losing money, if that is the real reason?
Fraud can never be ruled out of any investment loss, even when it is disguised as legal. Enough said.
Defrauding the pensions earned, of all those hard working Detroiters and other Americans, while hiding behind bankruptcy laws is criminal, in my opinion. Just once, I would love this type of story to be investigated thoroughly. Tell every lost pension earner, why there is no money left in their plan. Then put every person, who silently had a hand in destroying their retirement plans over time, in prison where they belong.
The way this is handled may prove an historic result ...
I agree.
(And by the way, I am a union member who pays his union dues each month. In addition I also regularly contribute to mu unions' political action fund. In fact, FWIW, several years go I was the union representative at my place of work! )
Detroit made a legal agreement to pay monies to people (retirees).. So, indeed-- is is morally wrong-- as well as a violation of a legally binding contract-- to stop paying those monies. That seems to me to be obvious.
OTOH, when someone makes a loan, and the borrower agrees to pay it back-- it is also legally (and morally!) wrong to not pay back the money they received. That alos seems obvious to me.
So-- who is at fault? What should be done?
The unions are not at fault-- they afe merely asking for their members to be paid monies promised to them! But, similarly, those individuals or entities or individuals who are owed monies promised to them by the city are not at fault either. (In both cases if they aren't paid what the payer promised-- it is basically a case of theft ).
So whose fault is this colossal f*ckup? (In most cases, most people form their opinions not based upon an objection of the facts, but rather based on their pre-existing political biases!)
I started checking the underfunded stateretirement plans. I think you'll find this link very interesting. It seems that Detroit pension plan is one among hundreds that was/are vastly underfunded. The total number should knock you out of your chair. There is a lot of information on this comingearthquake.
I was thinking the same thing Petey...and, which city is next.
Can't blame JP Morgan for this fiasco ... nor for the rest of these .
Very good link post Kavika. Should be reccomended reading for all those promised a pension.
With this topic such a historically prevailing practice, there should be many, many more than thirteen.
One Miscreant, I found another showing the top 50 cities that have the largest underfunded pension funds.Sorry, but I can't link it.
I'm sure there will be.
And one consequence will certainly be that labour unions for states & municipalities will no longer be able to negotiate such generous pensions for their members. It will greatly narrow the inequities in retirement benefits between those employed in the public sector-- and the rest of our nations workers who do equivalent jobs.
Looks like Wisconsin governor Scott Walker is coming out looking prescient ...
Gunny, in researching, I found an article on IL. Your right, they are in horrible financial shape, and could go bankrupt.
Thing is, how far can this domino before the Fed can no longer cover? We see countries in Europe who are basically bankrupt and that is what will happen in the US also.
Ding! Ding! Ding! We have a winner!
Sadly, as with Europe, pensions are the tip of the iceberg. Strike up the orchestra.
My pension will never be close to my paycheck either. But, I am damn greatful to be holding a job these days.
There doesn't seem to be a ready solution; hell, we can't even get a budget put together!
Start protesting now, avoid the rush.
Sure. If we follow the Grecian example...flip and burn a few cars, storm banks, threaten the lives of the well-to-do. The Proletariat can't be held down forever!
Thank you for your service!
I heard a lot of arguments, pro and con. (Claiming that pensions were much too high, soaking the taxpayers. And other arguing they were unfairly low and impossible to live on).
But the discrepancy between the data quoted by both sides was really huge. Too huge to be exlalined by any political bias alone.
Upon investigation. I came up with an interesting discovery. While there may be exceptions, this seems to be true for the most part:
-Civil service workers-- i.e. those that work for the government generally have pensions that allow them to live quite comfortably. And in some cases they really are taking advantage of the taxpayer.
This includes many city employees, state employees, cops, fireman, schoolteachers, social workers. (BTW, it does not include the military-- a bit unfair IMO as members of the military literally risk their lives...)
-OTOH, people employed in the private sector (and the military) have pensions that are small-- in many cases impossible to live on. (And many have no pensions at all). There are exceptions--among them, I believe, are defense plant workers, auto workers, Teamsters (?)
But apparently what is causing municipalties (and soon probably some states) to have serious financial problems is the ever increasing amounts of public fund that must be paid towards the pensions and other benefits of retired public employees.
DLIP-Frankly, I see what you presented is a statistical divide and conquer slight of hand. Not intended as a personal attack on you, just how I feel about justification of theft, in businesses all across our nation. Please explain, if I misunderstood the intent of your post.
While those numbers may be somewhat accurate, with exceptions, it in no way excuses business policies, practices and laws, that break the contracts made with millions of employees. No matter how fat or meagre it may look in statistical analysis. Honest people earned what is being taken from their futures. It's not a handout, they worked hard and long for it.
Plain and simple, businesses find it easier to find ways screw the employees who did the work, rather than paying corporate execs and stockholders less. And that isn't just union employees.
Absolutely. Entireindustriesand businesses failed as the auto industry failed. The article(s)referenced here,include all liabilities of corporations and governments, not just pensions.
However, when they money got tight, it exposed the fact, that theyunderfunded pensions to keep poor management practices hidden from stockholders, government and employees alike.
I really do hope Detroit and others can find ways to be better and worthy of future investment, by the very corporations who caused the fiscal shitstorm to begin with. Most of the corporations in the U.S. are sitting on beaucoup cash anyway. Check the balance sheets.
At it's height, Detroit had 1.8 million residents. It now has around 700,000. In the last decade alone, 250,000 people have left Detroit.
The once glistening city of Detroit now has large sections that are in complete shambles...
pre election: osama is dead, gm is alive
post election: ambassador stevens is dead, detroit is bankrupt.
for the low information voter who always votes as they are told by the democratic party: the unions caused the destruction of detroit, as well as decades of liberal/progressive city government. unions are interlinked with the democratic party, and in ohio proved it by giving obama the re-election as payment for the auto bailout. unions are also completely infiltrated by the mob. the mob is a criminal organization, that uses extortion, blackmail, human trafficing, prostitution, graft, and murder.
this is the mob, unions, and the democratic party, and detroit is only the first to fall because of their filth.
Well there ya have it folks, the evil unions have caused all this country's financial problems.
All one needs to do is change one word in the above statement to see the true reality of our future. "Mob" should have been "Congress".
That's a fairly crisp opinion JFT. What constitutes wealth? What constitutes the amount of wealth required to make one "un-American"? What about people that use their wealth to advance help to the needy and provide jobs. Does driving a Mercedes constitute wealth, or a Chevy, or a bicycle? How big or small a house does one own to be considered "American"?
Or perhaps the wealthy are defined as those who have more than me. Or you.
I absolutely know folks who would look at your possessions JFT and consider you to be very wealthy, most likely a shrew and a crook, and would consider it to be most unfair that you have as much as you do, and they so little.
If you were a "real" American, you'd consider selling off some of those possessions to help those who have less!
;^)
See how arbitrary ascribing wealth is?
There are women who would be happy to "suck you dry" for parting with some of that cash ... And have you seen what is on skype ?? Holy shiite !
More of When you retire just die quickly so we can give more to our rich buddies.
Barb and One Miscreant,
Not pickin' a fight, truly, I am interested in your opinions.
Do you believe that unions are free of mob association and/or do you see Unions as playing a role in Detroit's situation?
Greece should follow Detroit's method of escaping
Honestly, it's tough at times to see who some comments are directed towards in this format. It looks to me as though Barb and I were responding to JoAnne's comment. I could be wrong. JoAnne, having not responded to the challenge, counts as a drive by.
To answer your question LH, no. Unions are not free from the corruption of the mob, nor are they free from any other seedy influences either. I will never put it on such a pedestal. Any organization, in that light, is influenced by the corrupt state. Corruption of government influences all of society. In short, when the government is corrupt, so is the environment of any who do business with it. So is the society allowing it.
Unions do play a role in Detroits plight. However, my comments on this thread and others are meant to support not only union workers but all workers. Are my comments pointed directly at corporate America and our governments in general? Absolutely. It's about damn time that we as a people stop allowing them to dictate the way things are to be and take control of this mess.
My question to you and anyone else is this: Do you think union workers are the only workers to lose pensions?
Just so you know this is a rhetorical question: When a private firm does the same thing to its employees do you think this is front page news? NO. They are not represented in the court of public opinion. They get glued, screwed and tattooed, without as much as mention. So blame the evil unions, if you want to folks, we're all getting it in the end. (pun intended) Stand up, fight back.
Not ignoring what you are saying, just pointing out that your assessment of what constitutes "real wealth" is arbitrary. I look at the work of some like Bill and Melinda Gates and see how much good they have done with their wealth. Admit it, even with just food, a roof over your head, and medicare, you could give up some and still make it.
I know folks who live in the Mission in Grand Forks ND because that is how they want to live. They chose not to work or have any material possessions. Should we Robin-Hood those more wealthy to give some of it to those who have chosen not to pursue more?
LOL!
Well thanks Barb for not answering my question. I don't discount what you posted because I DO believe what you say is true; but, thank you for your passion.
:~)
Thanks for your appraisal OM, much appreciated.
Absolutely frickin' not.
I believe that it's a conglomeration of greedy folks and corporate entities, mismanagement and a real lack of foresight. I also believe the biggest crooks to blame for the issue sit in DC.
Flame you're a hoot!
:~)
Amen.
I will encourage a change in governmental behavior. When they stop screwing the working class to fund their decadance, I'll die happy. Knowing that our children won't get the same treatment by our elected officials and their corporate pimps.
Your ears are big. {return needle} Yes flame a Hoot!
ok
:~)
In that case then, there will be none to give; those who create wealth will not have the means to give to those who chose not to possess wealth, when they have given their fill. Money doesn't grow on trees, it is created and acquired. What is the middle ground where one is too wealthy or too needy? And who gets to decide this? You? Me? The rich? The poor?
I wish you knew me off-line Randy.
Grew up poor, scratched my way somewhere to the middle of middle-class. Right now we are about as hard-working, paycheck-to-paycheck as it gets. There isn't any wealth in either mine or Arlene's family.
I worry about the thumb of corporate America and the politicians in their pockets, and I also worry about the clueless mobs who would willingly loot any that they see having more than them.
I believe I do. I just think that it is simply impossible until there is a complete evolution of the human race, one that will not happen for many generations and one that will literally transform who we are as a species on planet Earth. Attempting to perform that through social engineering will only lead to total chaos and complete failure. Attempting to change it through force will only take the power and wealth outta one person's pocket and put it into another's.
flame-I wish I had said that.
Larry-Just look around pal. It's already begun in other parts of the world. Europe, the Middle east, et al. It's only a matter of time here, not generations. It doesn't have to be violent like some profess. The unarmed protest makes the powers that be shake in their boots. It wasn't all that long ago, current generations in fact, that forced a U.S. president to resign.
Thanks gang for the great conversation; you all have given me something to chew on.
I am to meet-up with my wife as we go to celebrate our 27th anniversary tonight.
Evening All!
:~)
Looks like the smart people of Detroit voted with their feet. Maybe I'm on to something here.
These may be two reasons Detroit a #1 city 50 years ago has come to be what it is now.
List of mayors of Detroit
and
Detroit Gave Unions Keys To The City, And Now Nothing Is Left
That's pretty much the cause of the economic crisis taking place in much of Europe as well. (The difference, however, is that the situation in much,much worse there...)
Wouldn't that be like putting bankers in jail for the 'Great Recession'?
Or bringing coals to Newcastle?