╌>

‘Please Mr Obama, stop supporting terrorists here in Egypt’ -- Melanie Phillips

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  20 comments

‘Please Mr Obama, stop supporting terrorists here in Egypt’ -- Melanie Phillips
14 July 2013

In all the welter of words about the ousting of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, very little has been written in the mainstream media about the extraordinary contortions of the Obama administration, which did so much to put the Brothers into power there in the first place.

The administrations first reaction was to threaten to cut off US aid to Egypt in order to punish the military for unseating the Muslim Brother President, Mohamed Morsi. Then a State Department official vouchsafed that Morsi had been undemocratic, and the administration backed away from outright confrontation.

Nevertheless, reports persist that the US continues to support the Brothers against the Egyptian military. As Raymond Ibrahim reports ,the US ambassador to Egypt, Anne Patterson, has come to be seen as a Brotherhood stooge:

... soon after the overthrow of Morsi, U.S. ambassador Anne Patterson assured Hisham Qandil, who hours ago was Egypts Prime Minister, that there are many forms of pressure, and America holds the keys to the Gulf.

Among other things, in the days leading to June 30, she called on Egyptians not to protest including by meeting with the Coptic Pope and asking him to urge the nations Christian minority not to oppose the Brotherhood , even though Christians have naturally been the most to suffer under Morsi, especially in the context of blasphemy accusations.

Thus, and once again, the Obama administration makes indubitably clear that its primary interest in Egypt is to see the Muslim Brotherhood stay in power, the Egyptian peoples will the will of tens of millions of secularists, liberals, moderates, and Christians be damned.

Then there was this :

Yesterday El Fagr reported that, during their most recent phone conversation, U.S. ambassador Anne Patterson demanded that Egyptian General Sisi release all Muslim Brotherhood members currently being held for questioning: And when Sisi rejected this order, the American ambassador began threatening him that Egypt will turn into another Syria and live through a civil war, to which Sisi responded violently: Neither you nor your country can overcome Egypt and its people.

Moreover, the day before the Salafi party withdrew from negotiations with the new Egyptian government, Al Nahar reported that Patterson had incited them [the Nour Party, the Salafi party] to tamper with the political scene and the road map and to threaten to withdraw from political participation if Dr. Muhammad Baradei becomes elected as Prime MinisterApparently, these are the many forms of pressure that Patterson earlier assured Hishan Qandil the U.S. would use to reinstate the Brotherhood.

Things have reached such a pass that Patterson has even been called a member of a MB sleeper cell.So what does that make Obama whose bidding, after all, his Ambassador to Egypt is merely doing?

The astonishing thing is that, given Obamas backing for the Brothers, the US currently might be said to be more Islamist than Saudi Arabia.

And all this, moreover, when the Arab world is convulsed in unprecedented ferment, offering the best chance of stopping the advanced of the Brotherhood mortal enemies of the west -- that has occurred for a very long time. As the authoritative Israeli commentator Ehud Yaari has observed ,the ousting of Morsi has delivered a stunning reverse to the Brothers hitherto steady progress towards regional power.

And as Khaled abu Toameh writes ,Egypt is now punishing the Palestinians on account of Hamass support of the Egyptian Brotherhood, by sealing its frontier with Gaza and denying access of food, fuel and other supplies to the Palestinians (with not a peep, of course, from the anti-Israel BDS crowd against this collective punishment).

So now a new and powerful alliance against Iran, the deadly Shia Islamic foe of the west, is on the cards between Egypt, Saudi and the Gulf states. There is a chance to put the Muslim Brotherhood, the deadlySunni Islamic foe of the west, back in its box. Even Qatar, backer of Hamas and the Brotherhood, is now under pressure to reposition itself. And Egypt is getting down to stamping out al Qaeda in the Sinai.

For the first time in living memory, a popular uprising has ousted Islamists from power -- and suddenly the prospects for dealing the forces of darkness a severe blow look brighter than anyone can remember.

Yet at this critical juncture, when western leadership to take advantage of this situation is essential, the US is on the wrong side. Despite posing as the champion of the Egyptian masses who craved freedom, Obama has aligned the US with those seeking to extinguish freedom.

The ironies abound. Having declared he would reposition the US as the friend of the Arab and Muslim world, by extending to it the hand of friendship and promoting the Muslim Brotherhood for all he was worth, Obama now finds that hand is being furiously bitten off.

The millions who took to the Egyptian streets were demonstrating not just against Morsi --the man who was leading the country into both economic ruin and religious tyranny and was tacitly supporting those who were killing Egyptian soldiers -- but also against the man they blamed for putting him there, Barack Obama.

As the Egyptian film director Mazen Said has said in this passionate video :Mr Obama, stop supporting terrorists and leave Egypt alone.

The instinct of the shallow, ignorant, culturally narcissistic west, which cannot conceive of anyone not behaving or reacting like itself, is to say that anyone who opposes tyranny must be a good guy. But at present in the Arab and Muslim world only bad guys, alas, are likely to gain power. The reason is that freedom and democracy do not automatically follow from elections. They depend instead on the prior establishment of free institutions. In the absence of such institutions, elections merely empower more tyrannical regimes. And such institutions largely do not yet exist in the Arab and Muslim world.

Those young Arabs and Muslims who really do crave western freedoms will unfortunately have a long time to wait. For the foreseeable future, therefore, its a war to the finish between barbarism and civilisation.

Maybe one day the US and UK and the rest will finally work out which is which. But not until Obama himself has passed into history where it goes without saying, he will be fixed for all eternity on the wrong side.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Glad to see the Egyptians taking the helm of their own destiny. Nice to see people standing against the dark forces that would drag them back into the 12th century. Mr. Obama would do well to learn from this and put a leash on his guard dog in Egypt.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

cant he just get the most recent lacky to go out on sunday talk shows and blame it all on a disgusting utube video....again?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

And as Khaled abu Toameh writes ,Egypt is now punishing the Palestinians on account of Hamass support of the Egyptian Brotherhood, by sealing its frontier with Gaza and denying access of food, fuel and other supplies to the Palestinians (with not a peep, of course, from the anti-Israel BDS crowd against this collective punishment).

Irony alert!

Double Irony Alert!

Although many of then BDS crazies may attempt to have us believe that Gaza is bordered by, and totally surrounded, only by Israel, the fact is that Gaza borders 2 countries--Egypt and Israel.

Egypt? They are destroying the smuggling tunnels on the Egypt-Gaza border. In addition, they have closed the legitimate Egyptian border crossing with Gaza.

And the so-called "Zionist Entity" (AKA "Israel")? Many trucks with food and supplies move from Israel into Gaza every day .

DOH!

So while the Egyptians are " Genocidally Apartheiding the Gazans (Peace Be Upon Them!) in Violation of International Law " {TM}, trade between Gaza and the "Zionist Entity" is continuing at a rapid pace-- daily!

(BDS efforts continually fail. And here's another irony: in addition to being driven by pure hatred of Jews, the BDS failing efforts, if successful, would hurt the Palestinians more than the Jews! Can you say "Stuck on Stupid"?)

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

76.gif 76.gif 76.gif 76.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

76.gif 76.gif 76.gif 76.gif

Really!

I think we would be a lot better off if some of our politicians (on both sides of the aisle, BTW) would sometimes just keep their mouths shut! 32.gif 32.gif 32.gif 32.gif 32.gif 32.gif

Sometime some the stuff they say is just so totally wrong 44.gif 44.gif 44.gif 44.gif 44.gif 44.gif 44.gif

-- and just plain embaressing!

9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif 9.gif

And for some reason, this sort of thing seems to be especially embaressing when they pontificate re: the Middle East:

"And throughout history, Islam has demonstrated through words and deeds the possibilities of religious tolerance and racial equality."

-Barack Obama, Cairo, June 4, 2009 .

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Yet, those who are actually fighting for freedom and equality in Egypt are Muslims as well.

Go figure.........seems like no matter what the group being demonized is, they have their angels and their demons.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Yet, those who are actually fighting for freedom and equality in Egypt are Muslims as well.

Actually, more tha one tenth od Egypt's population are the persecuted Copts (indigenous Christians who were there long before the appearance of Islam). Sure, many of those fighting for democracy were born into nominally 'Muslim -- but many are no longer believers. And, most of the supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood (and supporters of the even more extreme Nour Party) are devout...

That being said: yes, many Muslims are not extremists. However, IMO, the statement that Islam stands for racial tolerance Is simply not true in todays world.

Go figure.........seems like no matter what the group being demonized is, they have their angels and their demons.

Agreed.

But to cite one example-- there are some 20+ Arab countries. Can you guess (without googling) what percent are democracies?

What percentage have equal rights for women? For Jews? For Christians?

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

I can't, but even if I could I don't find it advantageous to judge from my cultural standards, people who have never experience my culture (which has its own very long laundry lists of unspeakable acts towards those that stood in its way, and NOT in the very distant past.)

We have no high ground to stand on here.

I'm sure you're aware of Manifest Destiny, the monstrous ongoing effects of the slave trade, the Chinese exclusion act, the imprisonment of the Japanese Americans during WW2, and many, many, many more examples.

The Doctrine of Discovery as well.

These things are US. We have no proper standing to judge.

10 million plus Native Americans were exterminated from 1500 to 1900. Bounties were paid to states from the federal government reimbursing for the costs of collecting Indian scalps. In California in 1876 ALONE the federal government reimbursed the state 1 million dollars for scalp bounties. 25 cents for each child's scalp, 50 cents for each womans scalp and $1 for each male scalp.

Don't preach to the rest of the world, because YOU live as you do as a result of these policies.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

10 million plus Native Americans were exterminated from 1500 to 1900. Bounties were paid to states from the federal government reimbursing for the costs of collecting Indian scalps. In California in 1876 ALONE the federal government reimbursed the state 1 million dollars for scalp bounties. 25 cents for each child's scalp, 50 cents for each womans scalp and $1 for each male scalp.

Don't preach to the rest of the world, because YOU live as you do as a result of these policies.

I am aware of all this, and I do agree that the history of mistreatment (and that word is too mild to describe what happened) has been atrocious.

However, I should point out that I personally did none of that.I never murdered any Native American person (nor any other person, for that matter). I have never stolen native American land (again-- I have never stolen any person's land,or even property of any sort). I have never paid anyone to take anyone's scalp-- nor have I done this myself. (In fact I strongly condemn those practices!!!). Any attempts to blame me for any practices that took place before I was even born is-- well-- just really silly!

A while back some African-Americans were pushing for reparations to be paid to them by non-African-Americans. (of course that initiative failed). The treatment of African-Americans has been atrocious-- slavery of course-- and even after slavery was legally abolished.

But again-- why should other Americans today-- whose relatives were alive at the time, be punished for what their (dead) relatives did? And, even more ridiculous-- why should people who did not even have relatives here the time be muzzled-- and have no right to speak out against injustices occurring today? (For examples children of recent immigrant-- even recent immigrants themselves?)

And the idea that people should be punished because they may benefit in some way by some genocide or other horror perpetrated by someone else in the past strikes me as absurd. What if the Axis had won world War II-- and the U.S. was now under Nazi rule-- not a good thing. But of course that didn't happen. The Allies won.

But there were indeed horrors committed by the side we feel are "The Good Guys" (the Allied powers, fighting the Axis powers)-- atom bombing of two Japanese (civilian) cities. The fire-bombing of Dresden. And others.

So-- I have benefited from the defeat of Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. And (I assume you are living in the U.S.?) so have you!

But-- were horrendous violations of human rights (and worse) ever committed by anti-Axis forces? Yup-- on numerous occasions.

So-- does that mean that you and I have no right to ever offer an opinion on any egregious violations of human rights today-- because we have in some way benefited by atrocities committed by those of whom the totality of their actions in the past benefit us in some way today?

If you believe that-- than the only people who can make moral pronouncements are those who have not in any way benefited by past actions of any group who at some point in history committed some horror.

Think about that a moment--that would mean the end of, for example, any groups who are sincerely fighting for human rights anywhere on the planet! That would immediately halt the possibility of any progress by any individuals who are sincerely doing good work.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

No, you didn't do any of the things mentioned, but you did benefit from them. Additionally it didn't end in the 1890. Granted the massacres stopped but, if you want a history lesson, please research, Indian Boarding Schools ended 1980, Indian Adoption Era ended 1978 by passage of the ICWA. Indian termination act. Ended 1973...

I could add many more, but these may give you a different view.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I could add many more, but these may give you a different view.

Thank you for that information. Smile.gif

I am not particularly well-informed about the history of Native Americans. And I also am not knowlegable about the current situation either.

However, what I do know about the history is pretty horrendous-- to say the least. And while I didn't know about the things you just mentioned, a friend of mine in Minnesota has told me about the terrible situation of Native Americans in his area.

It was not my intention to dismiss or even minimize any of this. However, IMO, in general the fact that someone might benefit from something (acts they personally did not commit nor even knowingly ignored) does not mean that they have no right to condemn any atrocities happening today.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Judge not lest ye be judged kinda thing? Actually it's ok to judge if you judge yourself by the same standards.

Yet, those who are actually fighting for freedom and equality in Egypt are Muslims as well.

While I do agree that that is correct, I find this interesting...

Egypt Cabinet has women, Christians; no Islamists

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Dr. I did not think that you were trying to dismiss or minimize it.

I was giving you a view of the U.S. and the horrific things they have done and still do.

You mentioned your friend in MN. I was born and raised in northern Minnesota. Red Lake to be exact. My memories of the area are quite clear. Racism was, and is, the word of the day there. ''SundownTowns'', were just a little of what we have endured.

In fact, next Monday I will be going back there. I know exactly what to expect.

You mentioned that you know little of American Indian history. Why do you think that is?

You do have the right to speak out.My, and Blue Wolf's comments werejust a reminder that America is not the saintedcountry that many seem to think that it is.

Here is another tidbit of information. Many reservations are not ownedby American Indians. White Earth Ojibwe in MN. only own 30% of the res. The rest is owned by whites. I could go on and on, but that is something that you may want to check out.

Sorry for going off topic Len. You may delete my comments, no hard feelings on my part.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Judge not lest ye be judged kinda thing?

Actually it may be more of a case of "damned if you do, damned if you don't.

If we are having a discussion of what has been done to Native Americans: according to the criteria that has been proposed (people who benefit from past atrocities have no right to make moral judgements about anything)-- by that criteria I would have no right to judge anything -- including treatment of Native Americans!

If I did make moral judgements, I would be in the wrong.

But if it was being discussed and I kept silent, I could also be accused of being in the wrong-- because I did not condemn these horrors when they were being discussed!

Damned if you do, damned if you don't. By that standard (No right to make any moral judgement if I benefited in any from what was done before I was even born)-- whatever I did (keep silent or spoke out condemning the racist actions)

Actually it's ok to judge if you judge yourself by the same standards.

Yet, those who are actually fighting for freedom and equality in Egypt are Muslims as well.

While I do agree that that is correct, I find this interesting...

Egypt Cabinet has women, Christians; no Islamists

Originally the majority of Egyptians did indeed want, and did vote for, an Islamist gov't. Even many who were not particularly religious voted for the Muslim Brotherhood-- some because they felt a religiously based gov't would enforce strictly moral codes-- something many favoured.

However, opinions changed. IMO it was not necessarily about most voting against Islamism. Rather, Egypt already had a tremendous amount of poverty. Morsi promised to improve their conditions-- but under Morsi poverty became much worse (as Bill Clinton so astutely observed-- "its the economy stupid"-- when people are in terrible economic straits, in most cases the economy trumps all other issues. And it got much worse under Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood rule.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

In addition, there were several attacks by Hamas on Egyptians in the Sinai (part of Egypt). Hamas is affiliated with, and ideologically aligned with, the Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood. So (Fada pointed this out in a comment here) many Egyptian began to fear an increase of terror from Gaza--- and that if not outright supportive of Hamas and other even crazier jihadi groups, Morsi might not take strong enough action against them. (Actually, terrorism by jihadi groups in Egypt goes back quite a ways...) .

Most Egyptians don't mind-- even approve of-- terrorism when its directed at Jews (and in some cases against Egyptian Christians) But more and more it looks like their pigeons ( Ibises? ) are coming home to roost.

I really doubt that most of the reaction against the MB & Morsi was against Islamism per se. Rather, its anger at what happened to the Egyptian economy under Morsi, plus fear that he would be lax on terrorism.

And, unlike Obama, Erdogan ( and al Jazeera! ), I personally was quite happy that those in power seem to motivated, at least in part, by democratic values. Perhaps also the inclusion of these groups was motivated at least in part as an expression "f*ck you" to the MB and their facistic values-- what better way to do this then by including minority groups that the Muslim Brotherhood hates!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Dr. I clearly stated that you do have the right to make judgements.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Dr. I clearly stated that you do have the right to make judgements.

OK-- then apparently I misunderstood something you said.

Its getting late now, but when I get a chance tomorrow I will re-read your comments.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

We have no high ground to stand on here. Don't preach to the rest of the world.....

Indeed. Obama should stop attempting to meddle in Egypt's internal affairs.

He is only getting them really pissed off at the U.S.:

egypt-protest-obam_1820461i.jpg

th?id=H.4552589169986245&pid=15.1 th?id=H.4682782489116801&pid=15.1 th?id=H.4909956154787366&pid=15.1

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

And your judgements are well thought out Krish.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

And your judgements are well thought out Krish.

Yup.

Because I keep very well informed on this.

(On other areas that I know less about,I'm much more cautious about making judgements)

 
 

Who is online






97 visitors