Deaths of 22 kids from school lunches shines light on Indian politics [Video]... Indian principal on the run after 22 students die from school lunches
Bihar, India (CNN) -- At least 22 children killed. Another 24 hospitalized. All because they ate a free school lunch like millions of other Indian children do every day.
Many of the children started vomiting soon after their first bite of the rice and potatoes. Some fainted after arriving at a hospital in Bihar state on Tuesday
But now, attention is turning to the government's accountability over the school meals and what some describe as wildly different standards across the country.
"It is just a reflection of the sort of neglect ... and these sorts of concerns in that state and states around that area," said Reetika Khera of the Indian Institute of Technology in Delhi.
"In the southern part of the country, children get not only good quality food, they also get very nutritious food," she said. "But this is not the case in Bihar." "
http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/18/world/asia/india-school-meal-poisoning/
Tags
Who is online
97 visitors

"What was the poison?
Don't forget they are trying to make it illegal to fix your child a lunch and let them carry it to school. So jsut saying.
Guess this wasn't that important huh?
(CNN) -- At least 22 schoolchildren died in northeastern India after eating free school lunches that contained a poison, a state official said.
More than 25 others were hospitalized in Bihar state, said Bihar Education Minister P.K. Shahi, after ingesting an insecticide that was in the food. One remains critical, the hospital said.
The poison was organophosphorus, a chemical that the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says is commonly used in agriculture.
Exposure to a high dose can cause an irregular heartbeat, difficulty breathing, paralysis and seizures.
Shahi told CNN the school's cook had questioned the quality of the oil she was being asked to use but was overruled by the head teacher.
He said: "The information which has come to me indeed suggests that the headmistress was told by the cook that medium of cooking was not proper, and she suspected the quality of the oil. But the headmistress rebuked her, and chastised the children, and forced them to continue the meal."
CNN has not been able to contact the headmistress.
A program providing one free hot meal a day to school children has proved incredibly popular as part of India's wider effort to tackle malnutrition . Children aged 6 months to 14 years get take-home rations or are provided with hot cooked food.
The wider $22 billion-a-year welfare scheme aims to sell subsidized wheat and rice to 67% of its 1.2 billion people.
According to the Indian government's figures , nearly half of India's children suffer from malnutrition of some sort.
Shahi said: "Twenty million children are being served hot meals in about 73,000 elementary schools. We have been endeavoring to improve the quality ... However, the challenge is still there because the magnitude of this program is so huge that there are a number of challenges."
He added: "It is really very unfortunate. Even though I would unhesitatingly admit that there are some quality issues before us, but this is the first incident which has happened in the state. In the past we have received complaints regarding quality, but the incident of this nature has happened for the first time. It has really shocked us -- shocked the entire state."
Speaking on CNN's sister network CNN-IBN, district magistrate Abhijit Sinha said an inquiry into the deaths had been launched.
CNN-IBN reported that the children were between the ages of 5 and 12 and from Dahrmasati Gandawan, a village in Saran district, Bihar state. It said their deaths Tuesday triggered violent protests Wednesday in Chhapra, the headquarters of Saran district, and a call from politicians for a general strike.
Madhusudan Paswan, Saran's district education officer, told CNN that 31 of the affected children were sent from the local Sadar Hospital to Patna Medical College Hospital in the state capital Tuesday night.
CNN-IBN quoted Shahi as saying the deaths were a clear result of poisoning, and an investigation would determine whether the contamination was accidental or deliberate.
Since a landmark Supreme Court decision in 2001, all government schools in India have been required to provide free meals to students younger than 13.
It is a nerve agent related to sarin gas, which is used in chemical warfare, the U.S. Health Department says.
Thank you, Six, for bringing up this article again. I was surprised that it generate any interest the first time around. I think it is a very significant series of events implying many political and financial misdeeds.
CNN added additional information later to their report, but it is the same basic story. I'll address their updated article commenting on some of what the report stated:
"
They have a central government that has authority over the states and territories.
" The school meal program is run by the Indian government in collaboration with state governments, Khera said. "
Money is always the problem when a central government is alloting funds to the states, yes ? And generally, subsidy funding (just like here) has different criteria... and it appears to be very political, just like here.
"children receive hot meals in about 73,000 elementary schools.
"We have been endeavoring to improve the quality and ... try to get good food served," he told CNN's Michael Holmes.
"However, the challenge is still there because the magnitude of this program is so huge that there are a number of challenges." He said those challenges are at least partly financial.
"Even though I would unhesitatingly admit that there are some quality issues before us, this is the first incident which has happened in the state," Shahi said. "In the past, we have received complaints regarding quality, but the incident of this nature ... has really shocked us -- shocked the entire state." "
There's the "partly financial" thought again. The "quality" issue that was mentioned at times had me wondering what their idea of quality is. If the food, rice and potatoes, are grown in the same fields, and under the same conditions as food for the state in general --- then why is there a difference in 'quality.' In other words, if the majority of the citizens are poor, so it would seem the majority are eating the same government food. ...So the 'oil' implication seems the likely culprit. Adding to that, the cook originally had suspicions with the oil seeming different.
"A program providing one free hot meal a day to school children has proved incredibly popular as part of India's wider effort to tackle malnutrition. Children ages 6 months to 14 years get take-home rations or are provided with hot cooked food.
The wider $22 billion-a-year welfare **scheme aims to sell subsidized ** wheat and rice to 67% of its 1.2 billion people.
According to the Indian government's figures, nearly half of India's children suffer from malnutrition of some sort.
Since a landmark Supreme Court decision in 2001, all government schools in India have been required to provide free meals to students younger than 13."
I can see how 'rations' could be involved when 'money' is in short supply (for whatever reason--and yes, I suspect the leaders are syphoning funds)...so yes, malnutrition would result for some simply because there isn't enough food supply to feed overpopulation and poverty. But, I'm still hung up on why 'quality' is an issue--the food should all have the same nutritional value if it is all grown the same.
___
So, back to the poisoning, and how did it get there (and I wonder if there could be a 'why' component as well)...
On Thursday, the cook told Reuters on tape: "When I saw the oil it looked like it had a layer at the bottom of the jar. I thought that this is locally made oil, as often there is an accumulation of residual waste at the bottom when the oil is domestically prepared. Generally we get just about enough oil to prepare one meal, as there is no space for storage."
___
But in a later interview with CNN the same day, the cook said she didn't suspect anything unusual about the oil.
Meanwhile, police told CNN that investigators have been unable to find the headmistress of the school in order to question her.
Authorities have not named the headmistress and her husband, whom they also want to interview, local police chief Sujit Kumar said Thursday.
--The cook changed her story later... I think she is being forced to cover-up something. And now the headmistress and her husband can't be found.
Could the state be feeling like there's no answer for their increased population and resulting massive poverty ? Could they have paid the headmistress to supply the oil, why this possible scenario occurred :
" "The information which has come to me indeed suggests that the headmistress was told by the cook that medium of cooking was not proper, and she suspected the quality of the oil," Shahi said. "But the headmistress rebuked her, and chastised the children, and forced them to continue the meal.""
___
Just speculating of course, but reducing state populations 'would' fix a lot of their problems, but only for ' a while.'
As an additional thought of mine, and why I was focusing on their government pointing to a "quality" issue :
Another possible political ploy I was suspecting, was the state government wanting to play up the "quality" issue and its possible health effects on the children would be to get more state funding for the program from their central government (but who would 'get' the benefit of those funds is questionable).
The tainted oil could then have been intentionally tainted and used to simply draw attention to the matter - at the expense of the children's lives...maybe.
Hate this has happened, but sure does prove one thing. Killing people in mass has unlimited means.
I agree, Six.
The report implicates that something similar might have transpired in the past with this notation :
" In 2012: Poisoning sends 38 Mexican kindergarteners to hospital "
People complain that there is too much Govt. intervention in our Country, "Big Govt. " is what its called, well, there seem to not have been enough oversight in these countries, or maybe because of poverty there is less caring...
CM, It looks to me like they have big government like we do :
They have a central government that has authority over the states and territories.
Even though we aren't supposed to be governed by a central government, it's getting harder all of them time to discern if we don't! ..lol
It seems that it must have something to do with:
The wider $22 billion-a-year welfare **scheme aims to sell subsidized ** wheat and rice to 67% of its 1.2 billion people.
The area must not be lucrative enough to get more funding.
A friend of mine is an elementary school teacher in an inner city "ghetto" in the U.S. She said that , unlike India, poor children in the U.S. get two free meals a day! (Free breakfast and lunch). And, of course, prevention of toxicity is much better than that in third word countries (its particularly bad in places like China and India...).
Wouldn't that be nice if their government provided two meals instead of one? Very sad to think that parents would have to worry about toxicity issues in those countries when sending their children to school.
That's so good to read that the U.S. is doing a better job with our program.