╌>

Obama’s Power-Plant Plan Isn't The Answer

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Obama’s Power-Plant Plan Isn't The Answer

One of the centerpieces of Barack Obamas recently announced Climate Action Plan is setting carbon-dioxide emission standards for existing power plants, a move the president said would put an end to the limitless dumping of carbon pollution.

Obamas political opponents, meanwhile, have labeled the move the opening salvo of a war on coal that threatens to destroy jobs and cripple the U.S. economy.

But some important facts are getting lost amid the predictable posturing.

In fact, such standards would be neither the end of the world nor leave an exceptional environmental legacy.

First, there are only three ways to reduce carbon emissions:

+ burn less fuel (through efficiency upgrades),

+ burn cleaner fuel (by switching from coal to gas), or

+reduce demand for electricity (via energy-efficiency programs or reducing demand).

Each has significant complications and limitations.

Power-plant upgrades are simple, in the sense that the technologies and costs are well-known. But upgrading a power plant can be a slow and expensive process, and might decrease emissions by, at best, 5-10 percent, according to the Environmental Protection Agencys own figures.

Switching fuels say, from coal to natural gas is quicker and also technologically possible, but for political and economic reasons, the EPA cannot simply ban coal (which currently provides almost 40 percent of U.S. electricity) and require replacing all of the nations coal-fired plants with gas or renewables; indeed, the EPA has already declined one recent opportunity to do so, rejecting fuel-switching to natural gas because it continue[s] to believe that a final rule that expressly prohibits new coal construction is not reasonable.

That leaves energy efficiency, and thus many environmental groups urge regulation that relies heavily on incorporating energy-efficiency requirements into a quasi-cap and trade system designed to cut power plant CO2 emissions 25 percent by 2020 from 2005 levels.

Those groups say it will take the EPA four years to complete a cap-and-trade regulatory framework and three years for states to achieve the emissions reductions. In practice, however, you simply cannot move at that pace via the Clean Air Act.

While a plain-vanilla rule requiring plant upgrades could conceivably be implemented in that time, history teaches us that the more elaborate the regulatory scheme, the longer the process and the less certain the outcome ; in short, as we explain below, the obscure (even among Clean Air Act cognoscenti) Section 111(d) process cannot produce 25 percent reductions of CO2 emissions by 2020.

In fact, it might take until 2030 promising decades more argument, litigation, and uncertainty, and providing no basis for the United States to make international commitments about emission reductions.

http://www.politico.com/story/2013/07/obamas-power-plant-plan-wont-work-94260.html#ixzz2ZJjJC41I

Editorial by --- By DAVID BAILEY and DAVID BOOKBINDER


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

An interesting editorial by DAVID BAILEY and DAVID BOOKBINDER in Politco which highlights some of the problems and unforeseen consequences and obstacles to achieving environmental goals.

The process will not be as simple as some politicians have portrayed it to be

No reasonable person argues against the need to protect and clean up the environment or against the requirement for renewable energy in the future.

The questions seem to center around the pace at which a transition to and the availability of those renewable energy sources (and natural gas) can be achieved with the most positive effect on the environment and the least detrimental effect on the economy and the people achieved simultaneously.

For all who might comment, I agree with conservation and restoration of the environment, I support renewable energy sources, I empathize with the miners and others losing employment as coal-fired plants close and the ultimate effect on families, cities and states.

This is not meant to be a for and against coal debate, but rather a discussion on what a reasonable transition plan from 40% plus of our nation's energy being produced from coal to a more environmentally friendly mixture of sources.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

the more elaborate the regulatory scheme, the longer the process and the less certain the outcome

Government at its finest ... NOT !

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

Short and to the point, thanks for the feedback and perspective

 
 

Who is online







101 visitors