Senate's Student Loan Fix Math Not Adding Up
Negotiators trying to find an elusive fix to the student loan rate issue are working overtime to reach a solution that wouldnt increase the federal deficit by billions of dollars.
The Congressional Budget Office told a bipartisan group of senators working on a deal that their plan to reform all student loan rates would increase the deficit by $22 billion . So with a goal of finding something that neither cuts the deficit or requires new revenues, staff for the senators are submitting alternative plans based on the framework of that deal to the CBO, two Democratic Senate sources confirmed.
Member-to-member meetings have ceased in the face of a stiffening bent of partisanship in the upper chamber, and a GOP source said negotiations would almost assuredly fall apart if Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid actually goes forward next week with the nuclear option, a rewrite of Senate rules by majority vote.
Though the rules change wouldnt directly affect the legislative voting thresholds, Republicans are unlikely to cooperate on a student loan bill if the button on the nuclear options is pushed. The GOP source was bullish on a bipartisan deal in the Senate before the upcoming August recess if the Senate avoids a rules change. Subsidized rates shot from 3.4 percent to 6.8 percent on July 1, but most students dont sign their loans until August before returning to college for the Fall semester.
The lawmakers on Wednesday submitted a rewrite of federal student loan law that would create two classes of loans, one for graduate students and another for undergrads, based on 10-year Treasury notes. All undergraduate rates both subsidized and unsubsidized would be set at the same rate on a yearly basis and capped at 8.25 percent. Graduate student rates would be capped at 9.25 percent.
http://www.politico.com/story/2013/07/student-loan-rate-cbo-math-94099.html#ixzz2Z3YZyOVb

Looks like it is back to the drawing board on student loan reform.
It sure does Robert. Amazing that our politicians can't seem to get much right, or get anything done.
Kavika
Gotta agree
Sometimes I think that passing something (whether I agree with it or not) would be progress
I fear that this "rules change" if it happens in the Senate will further retard bipartisan cooperation and that will not bode well for "we the people"
I guess grad students are automatically well heeled , in theory . Sounds like this rate differential is discrimination . Right ?
Petey
Not sure about that
Different interest rates for different types of loans and for different situations exist in other areas of the economy so I do not think it is discrimination per se
Why do we have this ball game in the first place?
The rates get reduced and stay reduced until right before the next election to be used as a political ballgame. Who gets the ball? Well it's always the Democrats because they were able to reduce the rates for 2 years and then us it every time as a political weapon to get votes. Doing a favor and promising rate reduction is a whole lot more effective than letting the rates go up to get votes.
Why do we have to do this? Why not give the students an interest rate and stop playing with their futures. When you borrow money for school then you have a rate for the money borrowed and the politicians can't play with that interest rate every two years. Take it out of the political ballgame.
Sixpick
Interest do and should vary according to the economy
I agree though that there should be a ceiling and a floor to the fluctuation and then let it be
The real problem is more the loan principle than the interest rate . The only way to deal with that is to remove the inflationary trend in college costs . That is due to the fact that US colleges sell to a global market of students instead of just the US citizen population .
Petey
Excellent point - the cost of higher education is the real problem not the interest rates, much like the cost of healthcare is a bigger problem whether the government, the insurance company or the individual is paying for it
I agree about the economy, but not to be used as a political football.
They still have guaranteed rates available. They don't have to be variable. That's one thing that played a part in the housing bubble and bust.
Balloon loans also played one of the biggest parts. The biggest part was the loans were given to people who had no jobs, no money, no credit and no intention of paying the loans back.
Take the loans out of Washington. Regulate them of course, but stop using them as candy by the politicians.
Sixpick
If the loans are "taken out of Washington" and administered by private banks the interest rates will go up and down and loans could be more difficult to get which is why the government took such a big role in the first place
Regardless of who administers the loan program, the interest rate should be set at x plus the prime rate with a minimum and maximum rate set.