FirstEnergy Closing Two W. Pa. Coal-Fred Plants
FirstEnergy Corp. announced its third round of coal-fired power plant closings in 18 months on Tuesday, a move that will cost most of the 380 employees at the two affected locations in the Pittsburgh area their jobs and underscores the changing landscape in electricity industry.
The decision to close the Mitchell power station in Union and the Hatfield's Ferry power station in Masontown was announced as FirstEnergy grapples with looming deadlines to upgrade the plants to meet new federal mercury and toxic air pollution standards.
Power generators have had years to bring their coal-fired plants into compliance with the tougher rules, but FirstEnergy Corp., Western Pennsylvania's largest supplier, said that it was too costly to make changes at the two plants. They will close by Oct. 9, the company said.
The Akron-based company is in the process of shutting down 10 coal-fired plants in addition to the two announced Tuesday. The closures amount to more than half of all the company's coal-fired plants.
Electricity prices are so low that the plants won't be able to make money if FirstEnergy spends the $275 million needed to meet new federal mercury and toxic air pollution standards, the company said. The Akron-based company plans to bring its other plants up to code and grow its competitive supply business instead, officials said. They have no immediate plans to join other generating companies competing to build gas-fueled power plants.
We are evaluating that all the time but we haven't seen that perfect site or that perfect situation to invest what would be half a billion dollars to build that, George J. Farah, FirstEnergy's vice president of fossil engineering and construction, said during a stop at the Tribune-Review. We've seen flat demand, and we'd like to see some growth.
The shift is part of long-term trend in which the market factors of depressed electricity demand and growing local shale gas production have pushed change just as much as environmental regulations, experts said. Coal-fired power plants are also some of the world's biggest polluters, contributing to local health and global climate problems.
FirstEnergy has had plenty of time to adjust, and this is likely the culmination of a lot of strategic planning, said Gregory F. Reed, director of the University of Pittsburgh's Power & Energy Initiative. It has a utility business and distribution customers that many other power companies don't have, so it may make business sense to let its competitors fight to build gas plants, Reed said.
They've been very successful in the marketplace, and I think they've just looked at this very strategically to strengthen their consumer base, he said.

Too costly to complete renovations and upgrades to comply with new environmental regulations and too expensive to build new gas fired plants - business realities but little consolation to the hundreds of workers losing their jobs or the towns, cities and counties that will feel the adverse economic effects of these plant closures.
Gunny
My neighbors and I have access to natural gas on the properties and have talked about needing to put gas lights back in the houses, we were joking at the time (I think)
Gunny
I posted the story to highlight the point that the workers (miners) and the towns and counties were going to suffer
I did not intend to debate whether carbon emissions needed to be controlled (which they do) but to some everything is just a political fight
I am glad to you also see the human effect of these closures
flameaway
Always enjoy your hyperbole and over the top suggestions (asbestos that's a good one)
I like to eat and see my neighbors eat, don't you Robert? Now let's make this point clear. Asbestos is out of the question. No more asbestos. If Canada is having a problem with it then they should follow our lead on that. Good suggestion.... eh?
The problem here is improvements can be made to the coal industry but we just can't leap off the side of the cliff and expect to survive. These improvements are going to cost billions of dollars and it is not necessary to accomplish all of them in one swoop.
Using that tactic, we will destroy the coal industry completely actually before its time and destroy the lives of many people along the way unnecessarily. Of course that is the objective and we must understand it for what it is.
E I
Yeah right, that is exactly what he meant
Sixpick
Not sure I totally followed your reasoning but here goes
First, yes I like to eat
Second, the article has nothing to do with asbestos or Canada for that matter
Third, yes the coal industry has been on notice of impending changes to regulations for a while but that does not make the changes any more affordable and when plants are closed rather than retrofitted it is the workers that suffer not the company and also the consumers if the price of energy goes up.
And finally, in my view destroying the coal industry is exactly what the administration has in mind. I seem to recall a comment by the president about bankrupting them (don't remember the exact words)
the war on coal continues.
astounding how electric car owners have no idea where the energy comes from when they plug in.
no doubt their bumper stickers all read obama 2012
E I
What power prices are now and what they might be without coal fired plants is two entirely different numbers.
You are worried about the businesses and I am worried abut the workers two different issues
No one is arguing that the environmental issues are important, but I think the people are important as well.
E I
Nor is any other reasonable person in favor of saving jobs just to save jobs, which is why I understand and support outsourcing and offshoring as well as workforce elimination through automation.
But those affected most by the plant closings are largely ignored in the debate and you are correct that their fate is not your problem and you needn't worry about it.
Some of us do, however, think about the fate of our neighbors and friends.
E I
Unless the money received for rates included enough to cover the entire cost of the upgrades hen it is acceptable (in my view) for a business to decide that it cannot afford the upgrades and decide to exit the business.
I have no disagreements with your view on the environment and our responsibility to it as a society. The only part of your comments that I took issue with was your cavalier dismissal of the plight of the workers being laid off as "that's life".
flameaway
Sorry I missed the fact that you presented the Obama administration policy statement on the issue
flameaway
Well sometimes you need to smack me in the forehead with the phonebook and then start explaining things to me to be sure I am paying attention
E I
It is not about the jobs it is about the people losing them
And whether the plants were closing because of being unprofitable, or because the owners do not want to upgrade the facilities or because suddenly everything ran bullshit (there is plenty of that around) it would still be about the people losing the jobs - not the jobs, not the plants, not the EPA, not Obama, not green energy not anything but the people.
I understand your economic points and concede their validity
I cannot make my point any clearer and I will not elaborate further as the horse has long since died and deserves no more beating
E I
I know you are not that thick
I give not a shit about the specific jobs, but something needs o be done for the people affected by the plant closures.
Keep the plants open, close the plants, change the plants but in whatever situation make sure that the people working the plants have options. That is the point
Is that so hard for you to comprehend?
E I
Glad to see I am not the only one that gets a nasty nip from technology on occasion
:-O)
BadFish
Damn that is disappointing