╌>

The Problem at the Heart of Egypt's Revolutions

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  13 years ago  •  4 comments

The Problem at the Heart of Egypt's Revolutions

morsi-1.jpg CAIRO: Crowd of thousands of supporters of Mohamed Morsi have gathered in Nasr City in the Egyptian capital to protest against his ouster as the countrys president .

This latest revolution in Egypt, the second in the last two years, is a symptom of a deep-rooted problem at the heart of Islam itself: Egypt is on the verge of a civil war to bring a resolution to the never-ending tension between what Islam demands versus what the people really want.
This is the central problem in most Muslim countries: the difficult choice between a civilian, military "infidel" government, and a totalitarian Islamic theocracy. The problem is compounded when most Egyptians consider themselves both Muslim and lovers of democracy, but refuse to see that Islam and freedom cannot co-exist.

How can Islam anywhere produce a democracy when freedom of speech and religion are outlawed, where there is no free and independent judiciary, and equal rights for women, minorities and non-Muslims are legally suppressed?

(Read it all)


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Egypt's dilemma is nothing new, but the good news today is that finally there is an awakening in Egypt regarding the tyranny that Sharia law brings, especially if it is made the basis of a constitution. Despite this awakening, however, not one rebel in Tahrir Square was able openly to carry a sign saying, "Sharia must become null and void." The majority of Egyptians still believe that to say that would be an act of apostasy, punishable by death.

All current surveys still show that the overwhelming majority of Egyptians still support Sharia law, or at least say they do.

This is where the problem lies: the laws of a society are the mirror of its morality. Egyptians cannot make believe that they can have both Sharia and freedom, or that their laws do not have to match their style of government and what they can feel comfortable with. According to Sharia, a Muslim head of state must rule by Islamic law, and must preserve Islam in its original form, or he must be removed from office. Islamic law leaves no choice for any Muslim leader but to accept, at least officially, that Sharia is the law of the land, or else be ousted from office. Sharia also commands Muslims to remove any leader who is not a Muslim. Because of that command, Muslim leaders must play a game of appearing Islamic and anti-West while trying to get along with the rest of the world. It is a game with life and death consequences for them.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

Combine Islam and under-education.

Islam has no fundamental concept of Inalienable Rights as mentioned in the Declaration of Independence. Islam does not permit the individual to enjoy the freedoms of action and association characteristic of the Democracy that so many Western cultures currently enjoy today.

Islam is a religion in name only because of a reference to"Allah"as their Deity. Islam is a totalitarian ideology that rejects Democracy, personal freedom, and every other religion.

The ideals of anti-Semitism and anti-Western Culture run rampant throughout Islam. The Laws of Man are meaningless and have absolutely no relevance in Muslim culture because they are without any direct reference to the Koran or Shariah Law and therefore they have no place in Muslim life.

Islamic law/Shariah Law is completely incompatible with freedom, democracy, and liberty, or any other government where the people have an actual voice in government or the will of the people matters.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

This article nails it.

Egypt is now back to square one; a military dictatorship is, for the moment at least, the only solution that can preserve and sustain a certain level of secularism in the face of the constant Islamic assault that human rights, freedom of religion and democracy. The assault has also been on the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which, on August 5, 1990, was repudiated and superseded by the Organization of Islamic Conference [OIC] in favor of the Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam , which, in article 24, in its entirety, concludes that "All the rights and freedoms stipulated in this Declaration are subject to the Islamic Shari'ah." Article 19(d) also posits that, "There shall be no crime or punishment except as provided for in the Shari'ah."

That says it all.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Egypt is now back to square one; a military dictatorship is, for the moment at least, the only solution that can preserve and sustain a certain level of secularism in the face of the constant Islamic assault that human rights, freedom of religion and democracy.

In most countries of the world, a take-over by the military results in fewer rights and more abuses of civilians. However in the Arab world the opposite is generally true. Ironically, military control usually means a secular government-- and more freedom for minorities (non Muslims, women, and Muslims of minority branches of Islam). Two excellent examples of this: Turkey and Egypt.

 
 

Who is online

CB


79 visitors