╌>

Defending the Coup -- By DAVID BROOKS NY Times, 7/4/2013

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  2 comments

Defending the Coup -- By DAVID BROOKS NY Times, 7/4/2013
The debate on Egypt has been between those who emphasize process and those who emphasize substance.

Those who emphasize process have said that the government of President Mohamed Morsi was freely elected and that its democratic support has been confirmed over and over. The most important thing, they say, is to protect the fragile democratic institutions and to oppose those who would destroy them through armed coup.

Democracy, the argument goes, will eventually calm extremism. Members of the Muslim Brotherhood may come into office with radical beliefs, but then they have to fix potholes and worry about credit ratings and popular opinion. Governing will make them more moderate.

Those who emphasize substance, on the other hand, argue that members of the Muslim Brotherhood are defined by certain beliefs. They reject pluralism, secular democracy and, to some degree, modernity. When you elect fanatics, they continue, you have not advanced democracy. You have empowered people who are going to wind up subverting democracy. The important thing is to get people like that out of power, even if it takes a coup. The goal is to weaken political Islam, by nearly any means.

World events of the past few months have vindicated those who take the substance side of the argument. It has become clear in Egypt, Turkey, Iran, Gaza and elsewhere that radical Islamists are incapable of running a modern government. Many have absolutist, apocalyptic mind-sets. They have a strange fascination with a culture of death. Dying for the sake of God is more sublime than anything, declared one speaker at a pro-Morsi rally in Cairo on Tuesday.

As Adam Garfinkle, the editor of The American Interest, put it in an essay recently , for this sort of person there is no need for causality, since that would imply a diminution of Gods power. This sort of person does not accept the existence of an objective fact separate from how he feels about it.

Islamists might be determined enough to run effective opposition movements and committed enough to provide street-level social services. But they lack the mental equipment to govern. Once in office, they are always going to centralize power and undermine the democracy that elevated them.

Nathan Brown made that point about the Muslim Brotherhood recently in The New Republic : The tight-knit organization built for resilience under authoritarianism made for an inward-looking, even paranoid movement when it tried to refashion itself as a governing party.

Once elected, the Brotherhood subverted judicial review, cracked down on civil society, arrested opposition activists, perverted the constitution-writing process, concentrated power and made democratic deliberations impossible.

Its no use lamenting Morsis bungling because incompetence is built into the intellectual DNA of radical Islam. Weve seen that in Algeria, Iran, Palestine and Egypt: real-world, practical ineptitude that leads to the implosion of the governing apparatus.

The substance people are right. Promoting elections is generally a good thing even when they produce victories for democratic forces we disagree with. But elections are not a good thing when they lead to the elevation of people whose substantive beliefs fall outside the democratic orbit. Its necessary to investigate the core of a partys beliefs, not just accept anybody who happens to emerge from a democratic process.

This weeks military coup may merely bring Egypt back to where it was: a bloated and dysfunctional superstate controlled by a self-serving military elite. But at least radical Islam, the main threat to global peace, has been partially discredited and removed from office.

The Obama administration has not handled this situation particularly well. It has shown undue deference to a self-negating democratic process. The American ambassador to Cairo, Anne Patterson, has done what ambassadors tend to do: She tried to build relationships with whoever is in power. This created the appearance that she is subservient to the Brotherhood. It alienated the Egyptian masses. It meant that the United States looked unprepared for and hostile to the popular movement that has now arisen.

In reality, the U.S. has no ability to influence political events in Egypt in any important way. The only real leverage point is at the level of ideas. Right now, as Walter Russell Mead of Bard College put it , there are large populations across the Middle East who feel intense rage and comprehensive dissatisfaction with the status quo but who have no practical idea how to make things better. The modern thinkers who might be able to tell them have been put in jail or forced into exile. The most important thing outsiders can do is promote those people and defend those people, decade after decade.

Its not that Egypt doesnt have a recipe for a democratic transition. It seems to lack even the basic mental ingredients.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Elliott Abrams writing about the Egyptian coup in National Review online on July 3:

1. The removal of an elected president by the army is a coup, whether we like that president or not. There are cases where a president is removed by the military pursuant to legislative or judicial action, or due to brazen violations of legitimate judicial or legislative action, as happened in Honduras in 2009. The Obama administration wrongly called that a coup, but what happened in Egypt this week clearly was one.

2. It was not, however, something that came out of thin air. It was the product of misconduct on the part of President Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood. He and the MB knew full well that they had lost the support of most Egyptians and that Morsi had been elected in a 5148 vote, not a landslide. Instead of seeing that as reason to rule by compromise and collaboration, they saw it as reason to rush toward seizing more and more power. Egyptians had every reason to fear that the MB was seeking to make its hold on power irreversible, and to act to prevent this.

3. Even if this coup was inevitable due to MB conduct, it would have been better if it had been delayed by six or twelve months. . . . Still, many opponents of the regimeincluding liberals, moderates, Copts, and democratsbelieved that another year of MB rule would have done too much damage to Egypt.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Many Egyptians are unhappy with Obama's support of the Muslim Brotherhood:

BORLXKiCEAA-fhG.jpg:large

 
 

Who is online







102 visitors