Ohio Police Department Using Fake Drug Checkpoints
Police in the Cleveland suburb of Mayfield Heights know they're not allowed to use checkpoints to search drivers and their cars for drugs.
So they're trying the next best thing: fake drug checkpoints.
Police in the city of 19,000 recently posted large yellow signs along Interstate 271 that warned drivers that there was a drug checkpoint ahead, to be prepared to stop and that there was a drug-sniffing police dog in use.
There was no such checkpoint, just police officers waiting to see if any drivers would react suspiciously after seeing the signs.
Authorities say that four people were stopped, with some arrests and drugs seized. They declined to be more specific.
The Plain Dealer in Cleveland reports ( http://bit.ly/12tIqGq ) that some civil rights leaders and at least one person pulled over by police are questioning the tactic, wondering if it could violate the Fourth Amendment against unlawful searches and seizures.
"I don't think it accomplishes any public safety goals," said Terry Gilbert, a prominent Cleveland civil rights attorney. "I don't think it's good to mislead the population for any reason if you're a government agency."
Nick Worner, a spokesman for the Cleveland office of the American Civil Liberties Union, said his office will be looking further into the fake checkpoints to determine whether anyone's rights may be being violated.
Dominic Vitantonio, a Mayfield Heights assistant prosecutor, said the fake checkpoints are legal and a legitimate effort in the war on drugs.
"We should be applauded for doing this," Dominic Vitantonio said. "It's a good thing."
A 2000 U.S. Supreme Court ruling said actual drug checkpoints are not legal and that police can randomly stop cars for just two reasons: to prevent immigrants without legal permission to be in the U.S. and contraband from entering the country and to get drunk drivers off the road.
It's unclear how that ruling would apply to a fake drug checkpoint or whether any other police department in the nation has used similar tactics
http://longisland.news12.com/news/ohio-police-department-using-fake-drug-checkpoints-1.5597743
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

They are not using drug checkpoints, which they are precluded from doing, but if a person acts suspiciously in reaction to a sign which provides false information about a possible drug search do officers then have reasonable suspicionor probable cause to make a stop.
I am sure that we will see this situation adjudicated as time goes on
It is settled law that there are times that police may lie to a suspect, but whether this falls into that area will be an interesting legal debate
Well Robert, this is a first..It's going to get interesting, if and when charges are brought against those that were arrested.
Kavika
I think we will see convictions and then appeals on the 4th amendment question, but how that argument will be decided is still a bit up in the air in my view
At first glance, it seems that the police did nothing wrong and that the suspicious behavior gave them reasonable cause for a stop and search, but I am no an appellate judge so I will wait and see what the courts decide.
It will be interesting Robert. I hope that if they are tried and convicted, that there is some news on it.
Good post.
Kavika
It will be local news around here so I will be on the lookout and try to shre any updates
Thanks Robert. This could get very interesting.
Hey, drug tests for wage slavery violates the 4th too, but no one seems to upset about it. Go figure.
These guys do whatever they can get away with moral or not, legal or not.
Back in the Daze I was riding the mountain roads with a pard in his '52 Chevy PU when the boys in blue pulled us for who the hell knows what. No, I take that back. Louie, name changed to protect the guilty, was a Purveyor of Fine Piffle at the time and the law dawgs were well aware of that fact. They'd been trying unsuccessfully to nail ol Louie for quite some time. Anyhow, back in those days it was proper form to disembark your vehicle and walk back to talk with the law. We both got out of the truck, locked our doors and sauntered back to see what was up with these folks. I leaned against the Black and White and lit a smoke while Louie was arguing with one of our counties finest. In the meantime the other fool went over to Louie's truck and started looking around. He almost skipped back to us with a large and not so affable grin on his mug. "Lookie what I found in your glove box Louie.", he said as he held up a matchbox loaded with Piffle. A matchbox? What, did he think we were from Hotlanta or something? Louie and I both gazed at the teeny stash of green and then at each other with a grin. "I hate to tell you son, but I do believe we locked the truck when we got out." sed ol Louie. The other cop walked over and checked. Sure enough it was tighter than Dick's Hatband. I don't think he was a part of the cunning plan as he came back literally red in the face and apologized profusely. They left us standing chuckling on the two lane ribbon of a county road and headed out to torture other weirdos.
Point being, these guys are mainly little shits who will lie, steal, cheat, hide and deal to get their way. Screw em.
Tex
The article has nothing to do with drug tests
I get it that you do not like drug laws or those that enforce them based on personal interactions with them.
I m going to go out on a limb and opine that you think the false signs are illegal, but how are they violations of the 4t amendment as you suggest
Well, I do disagree with your assessment that drug tests having nothing to do with the so called "war on drugs". In the river of our national consciousness and sit rep it is all related.
Firstly, it's a form of entrapment. Secondly, probable cause resulting from entrapment and trickery seems to negate the 4th. Though I am assuredly not a lawyer, I expect the 4th will be exhibited in some manner once civil suits are brought about. Thirdly, "suspicious behavior" is painted through the perception of the law at the scene, which is suspect at best. Even highly regulated law abiding civilians are prone to nervous or "suspicious" behavior when confronted with force and authority. In other words, in this case, probable cause is fabricated based upon the whim of authority.
jwc2blue
Which is why I said I did not know if this procedure would be considered the same o similar by the courts
If drugs, the sales of drugs, the transport of drugs and the violence associated with those three things were not so devastating, I am sure the war on drugs would never have started but that is not the point
Whether the motorist's reaction to the sign containing false information constitutes reasonable suspicion is the question for the courts to decide is the oint
Tex
I said that drug tests have nothing to do with the article or the action being discussed
Thanks for sharing your opinion and I am sure there are many who agree with you completely and many who disagree just as completely
So we will have to wait for our learned judiciary to decide the matter
You are certainly welcome and no doubt are correct in the assumption of disagreement. That is one of the mighty fine things about the US of A. We are still afforded the right to express our divergent opinionated opinions. May it always be so.
Yup. It's up to the suits now.
best atcha
Tex
And at you
B F
Who are they and how did they target the poor and poorly represented?
Was it an issue of signs indicating drug check points?
I remember those daze, sort of.
They are a bit obscured in a great bilious haze of faulty circuitry, that is for certain sure. The overriding philosophy of "if some's good, more's better" didn't work out all that well for some.
flameaway
Stereotype much?
John
People are largely people and have qualities and faults largely the same and unrelated to any socio-economic group they happen to be part of - good or bad is a function of individual choice in my view
Bullwinkle
I love that perspective thanks for sharing