╌>

Supreme Court rule for couple over baby girl's adoption

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  cm  •  13 years ago  •  13 comments

Supreme Court rule for couple over baby girl's adoption

(Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday threw out a lower court order requiring a South Carolina couple to turn over a young girl they had raised since birth to her biological father simply because he was an American Indian.

By a 5-4 vote, the court ruled in favor of Matt and Melanie Capobianco, who had been caring for the girl they named Veronica until a family court ordered them to turn her over to her biological father Dusten Brown, a member of the Cherokee Nation.

Brown had argued that the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978, intended to curb practices that caused many Native American children to be separated from their families, entitled him to custody of the girl, who was 3/256th Cherokee.

He took custody at the end of 2011 when the girl was just over 2 years old, and South Carolina's highest court later upheld his custody.

But conservative Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the Supreme Court majority, concluded that the law did not bar the termination of Brown's parental rights.

"Under the State Supreme Court's reading," Alito wrote, "a biological Indian father could abandon his child in utero and refuse any support for the birth mother ... and then could play his ICWA trump card at the eleventh hour to override the mother's decision and the child's best interests," Alito wrote. "If this were possible, many prospective adoptive parents would surely pause before adopting any child who might possibly qualify as an Indian under the ICWA."

The Supreme Court did not grant the couple an adoption, but threw out the South Carolina court decisions awarding custody to the father.

The court returned the case to the South Carolina state courts for further proceedings.

The case is Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl et al, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 12-399.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Howard Goller)

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/25/us-usa-court-custody-idUSBRE95O0V420130625


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    13 years ago

This Justice Roberts Supreme Court doing all sorts of good stuff today aren't they?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Yup, there on a roll, man what a horribledecision..5-4 split.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago
So.....everything is still up in the air on this one. All involved have to suffer this one out it seems. The one my heart feels for is the child. I wonder since I don't know, where was the father?
 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

He was in the Army, in Afganastan.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

The full story wasn't shown, but the father was in the Guard and tried to get the mother to marry him so he could get both the baby and mother on military benefits. She wouldn't. She put the baby up for adoption right when the father was shipped overseas again and he couldn't do anything 'til he got back 13 months later. When he got back, he filed for custody, claiming ICWA was not followed as he is Cherokee, making the daughter also Cherokee. TheSC courts agreed and the adoptive parents filed with SCOTUS.

I read the opinion today and am totally flabbergasted that the court ruled the way it did. Alito wrote the opinion - Sotomayer, Kagan, Ginsberg and Scalia dissented. Sotomayer wrote an absolutely beautiful dissent (14 pages) literally slamming the other justices for their decision. As usual, Kennedy and Thomas ruled with Alito.

I'm probably wrong about this, but since the case was remanded back to the lower courts - the lower courts can have the same finding based on the preponderance of evidence in favor of Brown under ICWA. The question then is - now what?

From the NCAI - I think this answers my question -

Thanks CM.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    13 years ago

It is just outrageous that these Justices are keeping this father from his child, They are deciding everyone's future today, their decisions in my opinion is more of a dictatorship system..how many dictators are we gonna have ruling our lives?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I've researched as well 1stwarrior and found you have the facts correct. He wanted to marry the mother and move the wedding date up. She refused and broke off the relationship.

She already had two children and had dated Dusten Brown, the father years earlier and after a brief engagement and becoming pregnant he was served with papers for the adoption just before going overseas in the military. He contacted attorneys but was unable to get anything done.

It appears unfortunately, the new parents of the child have fallen into a depressing trap and will probably have to give the child up. This is all unfortunate, but it appears the father has the desire for his child and the right to having her even without any Cherokee Nation involvement in the case.

The mother obviously didn't want the child as she put her up for adoption. I hope this case is settled expediently for the child's sake and I really don't think the loving people that have raised her during this time have a leg to stand on.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Good morning Bullwinkle,

ICTM carried a five part series on the complete case. The series goes into great detail on the case. After reading the series, and all articles that I could find, IMO the child should be with the father.

After the SCOTUS decision, it's going to end up back with the court in S.C. This has turned into a three ring circus.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    13 years ago

I agree Kavika, the child should be with her father, I understand that she is been given a loving home with her adoptive parents, but with her dad, she is able to learn about her heritage and the rich history of the Cherokee people, it is something to be proud of, so I hope the courts in South Carolina will be wise and grant the father the custody of his child, not that he wouldn't appreciate the care his daughter is been given at this moment, but she needs to learn about her heritage...

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

She wasn't with the adoptive parents that long - she's spent most of her life with her Dad.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Dad didn't relinquish his parental rights and the Cherokee Nation emphasized that he was the father and a tribal member. Momma was just seriously pissed.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Yes, she should learn her heritage CM, and living with her father and the Cherokee people will allow her to do that.

That, and the fact that he is her natural father.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    13 years ago

Ok...Thanks

 
 

Who is online







69 visitors