Detroit Manager Outlines Plans to Cut Pension PLans
Detroit workers not already vested in a city pension would be excluded and many retirees would be moved to federal health-care programs under cost cuts emergency manager Kevyn Orr outlined for union leaders yesterday.
For those covered by a plan, benefits would be frozen and some would be switched to 401(k)-like defined-contribution savings accounts, under Orrs proposal.
He hasnt determined how much to take from future or current retirees, pending an actuarial analysis.
Automatic cost-of-living raises would be eliminated, and worker contributions into the system would rise.
As you might imagine the plan has received less than glowing response from retirees and union officials.
People are angry because its the same old horse crap -- its their way or the
highway, said Ed McNeil, assistant to Al Garrett, president of the American
Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Council 25.The president of the Detroit Fire Fighters Associationsounded a little more positive -
This is reality, were trying to find the best way, if possible, to work together and come to a solution for the city.
What happens next?
Michigan law gives Orr, a bankruptcy lawyer from Washington appointed by Republican Governor Rick Snyder, the authority to rewrite city contracts.
He has called Detroits $5.7 billion in health and pension liabilities an unsustainable burden for a city that has lost a quarter of its residents since 2000.
And creditors?
The sessions with about 125 union leaders followed Orrs June 14 meeting with more than 100 creditors and his suspension of payments on some Detroit debt.
Orr proposed a financial overhaul that would provide no more than 10 cents on the dollar for $2 billion of unsecured debt, including more than $1 billion tied to pensions, as well as reducing obligations to retirees.
Bankruptcy might be a better deal for city workers and retirees, said Henry Gaffney, president of Amalgamated Transit Union Local 26, which represents bus drivers.
The worst part of the plan would be the denial of pensions to employees with less than 10 years of service, he said.
A huge budget obstacle to overcome for a city with deteriorating tax revenue bases and a declining population
Wages, benefits and pensions took 41 percent of city revenue this fiscal year,
according to a report from Orr. It showed that benefit and pension costs per
employee had increased to $24,000 from $18,000 in 2000.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-20/detroit-emergency-manager-orders-probe-of-benefit-programs-1-.html
Tags
Who is online
69 visitors

There seems to be no really "good" solution to this mess
Hopefully changes will made in such a way as to mitigate the impact on retirees and to allow for "changes" to take effect for current employees in a smooth manner
No one will be 100% happy with the outcome as retirees, current employees and creditors of the city will all take a haircut to some degree.
If there was indeed culpable fraud or malfeasance in the investment process of the funds, perhaps some of the money can be recovered from those responsible
Logic seems to support that upwardly spiraling pension and benefit costs cannot be sustained with a declining tax base and that the city and unions representing workers will need to work together to come up with a new benefit package, which likely will include a 401(k) type plan rather than a pension program.
That this is will be messy is inevitable