Why a Health Insurance Penalty May Look Tempting
OFTEN, when the government wants you to do something, it makes you pay if you dont. That would seem to be the case with Obamacare, which penalizes companies for not providing health care. But in that penalty, there could be a paradoxical result: dropping health coverage could save companies a lot of money.
Once new health insurance exchanges are up and running in October, companies with 50 or more full-time employees will face a choice: Provide affordable care to all full-time employees, or pay a penalty. But that penalty is only $2,000 a person, excluding the first 30 employees. With an employers contribution to family health coverage now averaging $11,429 a year, taking that penalty would seem to yield big savings.
Yet there may be costs in employee satisfaction, especially if companies dont raise pay enough to keep workers whole when they buy insurance on the exchanges.
No one wants to drop health insurance and have unhappy employees, says Rick Wald, who heads Deloittes employer health care consulting practice.
Few experts see immediate, big changes to existing employer-sponsored coverage. But that may change in time. A generation ago, defined-benefit pensions were prevalent. Not so today.
So why did the government set the penalty at $2,000?
Policy experts dont agree on the rationale, and the White House didnt respond to requests for comment. Perhaps the intent was to start a gradual shift from employer-sponsored coverage to the new exchanges. Or maybe the low amount was a compromise needed to pass the law.
Whatever the reason, the government is about to conduct a huge experiment in corporate decision-making.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/23/business/why-a-health-insurance-penalty-may-look-tempting.html?_r=0
Sources: 2012 Employer Health Benefits survey from the Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Educational Trust; the Affordable Care Act
Additional commentary on the issue from the HuffPo
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/08/small-business-obamacare-penalty_n_3037749.html
Tags
Who is online
68 visitors

Small business owners will have to make a choice
$11,429
Employer portion of family health benefit, average current cost
$2,000
Employer penalty for not providing benefits under Obamacare
E I
Interesting perspective as always
Thanks for sharing
Roy
The company I worked for before I retired, discussed in 2010 the option of giving U.S. employees up to $XXXX annually to buy their own insurance but the idea was tabled at the time
As I talk with my former team members, I find that the discussion comes up now and again of late
Cost sharing on the premium increased in the 15 years that I worked their from 90%/10% to 70%/30% (employer/employee) and deductibles increased as well; but it was excellent insurance and most employees took advantage of it.
Overall to me PPACA has some good and some bad - and doesn't make things worse but doesn't really address the main problem of cost in any meaningful way. One of my least favorite things in PPACA in fact is it guarantees pharmaceuticals, hospitals, doctors and insurance full retail for everything that was part of lobbying for this bill.
A lot of small business doesn't pay for health care now - so from their 30K foot view it will now cost them 2K a year not to provide it along with all the other preposterous taxes and regulations business has now. They'll be ticked.
For Democrats PPACA will be a disaster because people who don't vote will be happy with it and people who do won't. Democrats think they'll get those non-voters to vote but it hasn't worked for the last 50 years and I don't see it working now.
We missed it by a light year when we didn't do single payer.
!! OK did not know that.
Most business I do know about that are 50+ do provide health care. I'm wondering after PPACA if the share the business wants the employee to pay will go up.
I know a few people who opt out of employer paid health care because they can't afford the 250-300 dollar a month family rate which of course is a great deal, but money's tight on 40K a year with a family I get that. PPACA might drive the person back to their employer plan which though a bit harsh is probably a good thing people should have coverage. Also it might be cheaper for the family at this point to go to the exchange and buy their own instead of use the employer. Nice for the employer!
Mark
You make a key point, because as I understand it if an employer offers an "affordable" health insurance option (less than 9.5% of the gross salary I think, but I might have that percentage wrong) and the employee opts out then the employee will not be eligible for tax credit assistance to buy private insurance through the exchange.
Is the 9.5% what the employee pays?
So I'm doing some math - 9.5% of 50K is 4,750 or about 400 a month. To me this would be a penalty for the employee since they're on the hook for the employer's health care which will cost them more than the full cost of the exchange. A family of 4 at 50K a year probably has a pretty good subsidy from the government for PPACA and I can very easily envision an employer requiring 400 a month for insurance that honestly's probably costing them 11-1200 a month at least.
The only advantage I can see here is the employer's insurance is probably better. The "silver" plan which fulfills the requirement on the exchange is a 70-30. Really not that good the only thing good about it to me is it's way better than nothing.
Mark
Exactly the way I saw it as well
Like I said I might be off on that percentage but I am sure that someone will throw the correct percentage in if I am
$400 per month from an employee for their share of the premium in a company plan sounds about right, perhaps some even a little higher