╌>

(R)Evolutionary Food for Thought

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  paul  •  13 years ago  •  5 comments

(R)Evolutionary Food for Thought

A Fascinating New Theory About the Human Mind, Evolution and Mortality

Why have other species failed to evolve human-like intelligence? The answer may lie in our conception of mortality.

...............................

But the second part of Dannys ideathat the realization of our own mortality might have been a barrier to the emergence of a humanlike mind until our species was finally able to deny that realizationwas unique; I found nothing like it in anything I read. I wrote the letter to Nature , and it appeared in August of 2009. The relevant sentences from the letter are reproduced below:

Among key features of human uniqueness are full self-awareness and theory of mind, which enables inter-subjectivityan understanding of the intentionality of others. These attributes may have been positively selected because of their benefits to interpersonal communication, cooperative breeding, language and other critical human activities. However, the late Danny Brower, a geneticist from the University of Arizona, suggested to me that the real question is why they should have emerged in only one species, despite millions of years of opportunity. Here, I attempt to communicate Browers concept. He explained that with full self-awareness and inter-subjectivity would also come awareness of death and mortality. Thus, far from being useful, the resulting overwhelming fear would be a dead-end evolutionary barrier, curbing activities and cognitive functions necessary for survival and reproductive fitness. Brower suggested that, although many species manifest features of self-awareness (including orangutans, chimpanzees, orcas, dolphins, elephants and perhaps magpies), the transition to a fully human-like phenotype was blocked for tens of millions of years of mammalian (and perhaps avian) evolution. In his view, the only way these properties could become positively selected was if they emerged simultaneously with neural mechanisms for denying mortality. Although aspects such as denial of death and awareness of mortality have been discussed as contributing to human culture and behaviour, to my knowledge Browers concept of a long-standing evolutionary barrier had not previously been entertained. Browers contrarian view could help modify and reinvigorate ongoing debates about the origins of human uniqueness and inter-subjectivity. It could also steer discussions of other uniquely human universals, such as the ability to hold false beliefs, existential angst, theories of after-life, religiosity, severity of grieving, importance of death rituals, risk-taking behaviour, panic attacks, suicide and martyrdom. If this logic is correct, many warm-blooded species may have previously achieved complete self-awareness and inter-subjectivity, but then failed to survive because of the extremely negative immediate consequences. Perhaps we should be looking for the mechanisms (or loss of mechanisms) that allow us to delude ourselves and others about reality, even while realizing that both we and others are capable of such delusions and false beliefs.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Is it possible that a paradox has led to our uniquely human experience? That a realization of mortality and subsequent denial of it was the required formulafor our divergence seems plausible.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Wonder how this would fit in with Julian Jaynes theory?

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Steve, I must read more on Julian Jaynes , but to start with, just a tidbit that I noticed.....

Bicameralism

From the link,

In ancient times, Jaynes noted, gods were generally much more numerous and much more anthropomorphic than in modern times, and speculates that this was because each bicameral person had their own "god" who reflected their own desires and experiences. [ 3 ] He also noted that in ancient societies the corpses of the dead were often treated as though still alive (being seated, dressed and even fed) and argued that the dead bodies were presumed to be still living and the source of auditory hallucinations (see ancestor worship ). [ 2 ] This adaptation to the village communities of 100 individuals or more formed the core of religion.

This seems a form of denial of mortality. I will get back to you after further research.This article that I postedappears to gomuch further back in time to selection by genetics, and Jaynes' work delves intomore recent developments by neurological adaptation to existential/survival/societal pressures. So, at first glance, these two theories may not be in collision, and Jaynes' theories explain theascent from an alreadycognitive and introspectivehuman mind to the "modern", even more cognitive and introspective human mind.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Well, it has been a long time since I read The Origin of Consciousness. This could have been the mechanism that led to the breakdown of the bicameral mind. Of course, my question has always been, how do we know other animals aren't self aware?

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago
Of course, my question has always been, how do we know other animals aren't self aware?

An excellent question indeed, but first, from the same link above....

Gregory Cochran , a physicist and adjunct professor of anthropology at the University of Utah, wrote: "Genes affecting personality, reproductive strategies, cognition, are all able to change significantly over few-millennia time scales if the environment favors such change and this includes the new environments we have made for ourselves, things like new ways of making a living and new social structures. ... There is evidence that such change has occurred. ... On first reading, Breakdown seemed one of the craziest books ever written, but Jaynes may have been on to something." [ 23 ]

So, if Jaynes' theory of bicameralism has merit, and if what Gregory Cochran says above also has merit, aaaannnd if the theory in the posted article (simultaneous realization and denial of mortality) has merit, then all appears to blend smoothly into a grand hybrid theory,what I will call the Brower-Jaynes Ultimate Attainment of Modern Human Consciousness Theory.100.gif

Now, to address your profoundly pertinent question, I found this paragraph from the article to bethe most explanatory regarding Brower's theory....

The next mental step beyond the basic awareness of ones own personhood that many of the species mentioned above seem to possess could be awareness of the personhood of othersin other words, knowing that others of your own kind are also equally self-aware. But Danny argued that gaining this useful ability would also result in understanding the deaths of others of your own kindand, consequently , realizing ones own individual mortality. And he suggested that this all-encompassing, persistent, terror-filled realization would cause an individual who first made that critical step to lose out in the struggle to secure a mate and pass his or her genes to the next generationin other words, such an individual would reach an evolutionary dead end. Danny suggested that we humans were the only species to finally get past this long-standing barrier. And he posited that we did this by simultaneously evolving mechanisms to deny our mortality

It has been theorized that the human development of communication by language, and the abstract and complex thought that it encourages, has given we humans "the edge". It could be that other animals are as "conscious" as we are, and communicate by telepathy through a medium humans cannot measure. I won't rule that out, as there is so much to the unknown.

 
 

Who is online








107 visitors