╌>

NSA Spying on American Citizens -- Time to Re-Write the Patriot Act? (Re-write of Original Post)

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  26 comments

NSA Spying on American Citizens -- Time to Re-Write the Patriot Act? (Re-write of Original Post)

Given the potential for abuse of power, including but not limited to political expediency, is it time to re-write and/or amend the Patriot Act ti include the following provisions?

1) No NSA (nor any other Federal, state or local government agency) act of surveillance shall occur without a writ of "probable cause" which shall be evaluated by the FISA court and, which shall continuously be subject to scrutiny by a neutral oversight body

2) Where expediency/exigent circumstances necessarily delay the presentation of said writ, the writ shall be subsequently forthcoming within a reasonable period of time as determine by the oversight body.

3) Any/all NSA et al information gathered on individuals/entities that does not meet "probable cause" standards -- if/when so determined by the oversight body, shall be expunged from all NSA et al government data bases/records for all time, and, any/all references to such expunged information shall be inadmissible in any/all subsequent actions.

4) AT NO TIME SHALL THE NSA, et al government agencies, its employees, designees, etc., local, state or Federal, PLACE ANY INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, etc., on the hard drives or any/all other devices of any private citizen, business, etc., under penalty of commensurate breach-of-privacy laws.

5) Any/all NSA et al-obtained information previously gathered via acts of "domestic spying" on private citizens, businesses and other entities not meeting "probable cause" standards, shall be permanently expunged by systematic shredding/deletion CONDUCTED IN THE PRESENCE OF THE OVERSIGHT BODY WHICH SHALL VERIFY THE PROCESS DURING AND UPON COMPLETION OF THE PROCESS. All affected entities shall be apprised of the expunging and further apprised that the expunged information can never be admissible in conjunction with any/all adverse actions.

National Security is crucial and necessary but it must be implemented with protocols that do not violate or bypass American citizens Constitutional protections particulary with regard to "probable cause" standards.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Enough!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

This is the mistake, you presume (actually assume is probably more accurate because you know what they say about assumptions) that the information is private.

I'm guessing this may be tongue-in-cheek as in, "when one assumes, he makes an ASS of U and ME."

But

PRESUMPTION -

an act or instance of taking something to be true or adopting a particular attitude toward something, esp. at the start of a chain of argument or action

ASSUMPTION -

a thing that is accepted as true or as certain to happen, without proof

I believe the First and Fourth Amendments enable me and my fellow citizens to PRESUME.

But I'll listen to counter-points.

 
 
 
Teko
Freshman Silent
link   Teko    13 years ago

I just cannot understand the hoopla surrounding this at all. After 911, is it not an automatic assumption that this kind of thing would go on? I think there needs to be oversight precautions in place to make sure it is not abused but other than that, I just cannot understand the outrage. This bothers me none! I just cannot believe that in the day and age we live in and the tech we use on a daily basis, people still believe we have ANY privacy anyways.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If there's no guarantee of privacy afforded to the public, the let's require all PUBLIC OFFICIALS to wear a wire at all times, record all their conversations, post their Internet activity on-line, record all of their phone conversations and post those on-line too.

After all, THEY ARE PART OF THE PUBLIC SPACE BY VIRTUE OF BEING ELECTED THUS.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

just not released to the public.

That makes it de facto private.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Do you honestly think that ALL matters of government should be public. Lets start publishing troop movements of combat operations, just to make sure it's all public.

Matters of National Security should obviously not be available to the public. But matters that DO NOT AFFECT NATIONAL SECURITY SHOULD NOT BE AVAILABLE TO THE GOVERNMENT; that's why there's probable cause law.

probable cause

n. sufficient reason based upon known facts to believe a crime has been committed or that certain property is connected with a crime.

Probable cause must exist for a law enforcement officer to make an arrest without a warrant, search without a warrant, or seize property in the belief the items were evidence of a crime.

While some cases are easy (pistols and illicit drugs in plain sight, gunshots, a suspect running from a liquor store with a clerk screaming "help"), actions "typical" of drug dealers, burglars, prostitutes, thieves, or people with guilt "written across their faces," are more difficult to categorize.

"Probable cause" is often subjective, but if the police officer's belief or even hunch was correct, finding stolen goods, the hidden weapon or drugs may be claimed as self-fulfilling proof of probable cause. Technically, probable cause has to exist prior to arrest, search or seizure.

See also: Bill of Rights search search and seizure

Consistency, my friend. Being an elected official in my opinion, in-and-of-itself constitutes "probable cause" given the track record. So, let the public have access to government transactions/conversations/internet activity of all elected officials that do not have national security implications. If my elected officials are selling out my ass to a lobby/corporate interest, I WANT TO KNOW ABOUT IT!

As for "One thing though, the public announcement of this program will more than likely end it."

Don't bet on it; compromising a political opponent/"opposition research" is still a useful by-product of sifting/mining personal information surreptitiously.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Because there is no 4th amendment protection, probable cause is of no relevance. Again, you don't have to like it, but that is the legal reality.

EI,

It's not a 4th Amendment issue until personal information that is mined summarily and arbitrarily is used to blackmail or otherwise incriminate an individual when it was obtained in the absence of "probable cause." It's the potential ABUSES of the program that are problematic.

Warrantless wiretapping and data mining, etc. under Bush WERE ILLEGAL -- UNTIL CONGRESS CHANGED THE LAW TO MAKE THEM LEGAL. Because something is "legal" does not make ethical or moral. Certain insidious laws in totalitarian states are "LEGAL" by definition! That doesn't "justify" them in the eyes of humanity.

The United States has gone to war over that fact from time-to-time.

This ENTIRE PROGRAM is about National Security. The entire phone metadata program is about tracking communications patterns. It's NOT about the individual, it's about the pattern.

That's the OFFICIAL purpose -- the potential abuses need to be addressed. The program can easily be a wolf in sheep's clothing. I don't believe anyone objects to the program implemented as advertised; objections are in conjunction with potential abuses.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Do politicians carry cell phones? I know mine acts like a GPS device. Were their records somehow separated from the rest of us. Doubt it.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

So they are separate? Maybe the Secret Service etc. may have a copies, but the phone company will too. Which will be sent to the NSA via meta-request. To separate the records would compromise any investigation. IMO.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

EI,

RE:

In Smith v. Maryland, the Supreme Court held that a pen register is not a search because the " petitioner voluntarily conveyed numerical information to the telephone company. " Since the defendant had disclosed the dialed numbers to the telephone company so they could connect his call, he did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the numbers he dialed . The court did not distinguish between disclosing the numbers to a human operator or just the automatic equipment used by the telephone company.

In my opinion, data mining does constitute a search; voluntary disclosure of information required by an ISP for services is not the same as mining data by a third party in the absence of "probable cause." And ISPs like Microsoft, Facebook, et al assure client-privacy and deny complicity with the NSA, but, somewhere along the line, some party or parties either in collusion or, individually, violate rights-of-privacy when personal information ends up in a government data base in the absence of "probable cause."

But I'm willing to listen to counter-points.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The GPS feature can be disabled by the user.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Does that mean that it shouldn't be reexamined, possibly not, but there are many things that should be continuously reexamined, but even that brings up another issue. If one is going to show passion to reexamine this particular court case, that now gives society the opportunity to reexamine another one, one that you probably would be on the OTHER side of the discussion, that being Roe v Wade.

Be careful what you wish for might be the guiding principle here, because you just might get it.

Given the current shit storm re:the NSA, I think the "Court of Public Opinion" will determine re-examination; and as always, the same with Roe v Wade.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Public opinion isn't something that should define the law

But in some cases, we cannot ignore "of the people, by the people, for the people" -- not to imply the people are necessarily wise.

And judges are either appointed by politicians or voted into office -- manifestations, good or bad, of the people (and or their panderers).

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

No doubt A Mac, but every time the phone pings a tower it creates metadata. Like a trail of ping crumbspennies.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The big question is, what cases.

And as I said, most of the outrage is coming from a select few, public opinion is generally supportive of it.

The issue may be raised as a political one in the 2014 mid-terms although it's a can-of-worms for both parties; I wouldn't be surprised if a bi-partisan ass-covering piece of legislation modifies the Patriot act to more or less reflect my suggested changes.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

EI,

WE DON'T ACTUALLY KNOW WHAT THE NSA GETS

Which is my concern primarily.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It won't be an issue then, both parties have major elements in support of this program, and 'fringe' elements against it.

You may well be correct; but I'll put down a two-dollar bet on my horse since the way the media might handle this could mean the horseshit will hit the fan and scare the rest of the shit out of both parties.

The Republicans may have this round, but then, there are these the Democrats could run with

Creating Secret Laws .

Violation of the Posse Comitatus Act .

Spying on American Citizens, Without a Court-Ordered Warrant, in Vi... .

Directing Telecommunications Companies to Create an Illegal and Unc... .

Announcing the Intent to Violate Laws with Signing Statements .

I think the 2014 mid-terms have the potential to look like anything but "off-year."

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Why not? It's considered metadata isn't it? As A Mac pointed out the GPS feature can be turned off, but the signal locator feature is how the phone works within the tower networks. I know the detail has not been made public, but it's not content of the call, it's how the call was routed.

Maybe I'm fishing here, at least, for a connection of our public officials to the electorate being coughed up by the phone company. Because to not include all phone metadata for all users weakens an NSA investigation IMO.

I believe that a terrorist can be elected to public office. Next local election look at the names on the campaign signs. Not just the Smith and Jones ones. This is the melting pot.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I assume you are aware of this, but in case not

641A is located in the SBC Communications building at 611 Folsom Street, San Francisco , three floors of which were occupied by AT&T before SBC purchased AT&T. [ 1 ]

The room was referred to in internal AT&T documents as the SG3 [Study Group 3] Secure Room. It is fed by fiber optic lines from beam splitters installed in fiber optic trunks carrying Internet backbone traffic and, as analyzed by J. Scott Marcus, a former CTO for GTE and a former adviser to the FCC, has access to all Internet traffic that passes through the building, and therefore "the capability to enable surveillance and analysis of internet content on a massive scale, including both overseas and purely domestic traffic. "

Former director of the NSAs World Geopolitical and Military Analysis Reporting Group, William Binney, has estimated that 10 to 20 such facilities have been installed throughout the United States.

The room measures about 24 by 48 feet (7.3 by 15 m) and contains several racks of equipment, including a Narus STA 6400, a device designed to intercept and analyze Internet communications at very high speeds.

The very existence of the room was revealed by a former AT&T technician, Mark Klein , and was the subject of a 2006 class action lawsuit by the Electronic Frontier Foundation against AT&T. Klein claims he was told that similar black rooms are operated at other facilities around the country.

Room 641A and the controversies surrounding it were subjects of an episode of Frontline , the current affairs documentary program on PBS . It was originally broadcast on May 15, 2007. It was also featured on PBS's NOW on March 14, 2008. The room was also covered in the PBS Nova episode "The Spy Factory".

Lawsuit

Basic diagram of how the alleged wiretapping was accomplished. From EFF court filings
More complicated diagram of how it allegedly worked. From EFF court filings. [ 3 ] See bottom of the file page for enlarged and rotated version .

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) filed a class-action lawsuit against AT&T on January 31, 2006, accusing the telecommunication company of violating the law and the privacy of its customers by collaborating with the National Security Agency (NSA) in a massive, illegal program to wiretap and data-mine Americans' communications.

On July 20, 2006, a federal judge denied the government's and AT&T's motions to dismiss the case, chiefly on the ground of the States Secrets Privilege , allowing the lawsuit to go forward. On August 15, 2007, the case was heard by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals .

An additional case by the EFF was created on September 18, 2008, titled Jewel v. NSA .

BUT SUBSEQUENTLY

Congress gives Immunity to Telecoms who spied on us.

| June 20, 2008 08:15 AM

Yesterday House Democrats and Republicans effectively struck a deal to provide what amounts to legal immunity to the phone companies that took part in President Bushs program of eavesdropping. Today the parties will vote on the compromise bill. The New York Times has details below on the compromise. The AP will have updates of the voting here.

After months of wrangling, Democratic and Republican leaders in Congress struck a deal on Thursday to overhaul the rules on the governments wiretapping powers and provide what amounts to legal immunity to the phone companies that took part in President Bushs program of eavesdropping without warrants after the Sept. 11 attacks.

The deal, expanding the governments powers to spy on terrorism suspects in some major respects, would strengthen the ability of intelligence officials to eavesdrop on foreign targets. It would also allow them to conduct emergency wiretaps without court orders on American targets for a week if it is determined that important national security information would otherwise be lost. If approved, as appears likely, the agreement would be the most significant revision of surveillance law in 30 years.

Salons Glenn Greenwald posted the amount of money each of the major telecoms involved spent on lobbyists to curry a favorable outcome for this legislation. Read an excerpt below:

Just in the first three months of 2008, recent lobbyist disclosure statements reveal that AT&T spent $5.2 million in lobbyist fees (putting it well ahead of its 2007 pace, when it spent just over $17 million). In the first quarter of 2008, Verizon spent $4.8 million on lobbyist fees, while Comcast spent $2.6 million. So in the first three months of this year, those three telecoms which would be among the biggest beneficiaries of telecom amnesty (right after the White House) spent a combined total of almost $13 million on lobbyists. Theyre on pace to spend more than $50 million on lobbying this year just those three companies.

This is bound to be something the media -- both cable and MSM run with. It's too fucking juicy for them to pass up (IMO).

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Right on.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

I'm losing track of the thread. Sorry, I just think its tough to follow in this format. Maybe I'll get better.

My question to EI is since when doesn't the NSA investigate? An algorithm is a method of parsing data for clues, not just patterns. I thought that is what the NSA did, but some frame it as the "Intelligence gathering" bucket just to confuse the issue. It's all the same bird dog, looking to flush the brush for terroristic game.

I also think that location data whether GPS or tower pings is meta. Data that will indicate usage is good for the corporation to use and improve the network. And also track Boston bombers etc. We cannot discuss what is not there without knowing, but we can discuss business needs and that can and should be sent to the NSA/FBI and is metadata.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

All of the commentary herein is of interest and of value. But the purpose of my article is to address the NSA/Government practices of FILE SIFTING AND DATA MINING IN A SUMMARY AND ARBITRARY FASHION WITHOUT REGARD TO "PROBABLE CAUSE."

I'm additionally concerned with the logistical possibility of the PLANTING OF "EVIDENCE" FOR POLITICAL PURPOSES.

Data mining can be misused, and can also unintentionally produce results which appear significant but which do not actually predict future behavior and cannot be reproduced on a new sample of data.

Privacy concerns and ethics

Some people believe that data mining itself is ethically neutral. While the term "data mining" has no ethical implications, it is often associated with the mining of information in relation to peoples' behavior (ethical and otherwise).

To be precise, data mining is a statistical method that is applied to a set of information (i.e. a data set). Associating these data sets with people is an extreme narrowing of the types of data that are available. Examples could range from a set of crash test data for passenger vehicles, to the performance of a group of stocks.

These types of data sets make up a great proportion of the information available to be acted on by data mining methods, and rarely have ethical concerns associated with them. However, the ways in which data mining can be used can in some cases and contexts raise questions regarding privacy, legality, and ethics. In particular, data mining government or commercial data sets for national security or law enforcement purposes, such as in the Total Information Awareness Program or in ADVISE , has raised privacy concerns.

Data mining requires data preparation which can uncover information or patterns which may compromise confidentiality and privacy obligations.

And

I Am Worried. You Should Be Too.

We shouldnt have to wait for an abuse of power to know that the NSAs snooping has gone too far.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Does it matter if it is a third party that plants said evidence or if it's the government that plants said evidence?

I have no high expectations regarding ethical behavior on the part of corporations, criminals or other individuals.

BUT I DO EXPECT MY GOVERNMENT TO BE HONEST.

Naive fool that I am.

And if a non-government individual/entity "frames me/sets me up," it would be some government agency/law/judiciary, etc., I'd likely depend on to investigate and adjudicate and hopefully vindicate me.

If the government itself were the perpetrator, in the vernacular -- "I'd be fucked!"

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

These programs (and more importantly the capability) to plant data on peoples machines has been around for more than a decade, if not longer (though the network performance hasn't really been there for a good part of that). Has there been any cases of this happening?

Has there really been any cases where this has even been suspected?

I can opt not to accept cookies and other third party information, detect malware, viruses, etc. . I can install security software to thwart hackers but I can't prevent the NSA from gaining access to my ISP's servers and, to my devices.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But from a legal perspective, nobody has yet to come up with an argument (other than their own personal feelings) that would constitute a legal basis of this assertion (again, ignoring PRISM).

That's why it's called "SECRET." It's occurrences are known because of leaks -- but only generically -- that's how spying is designed to work.

SPYING -- secretly collecting information

_______________________________________________

Going out to mow the lawn then watch the Phillies.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Liability aside, if a computer is hacked by collusion with or, via the bypassing of the ISP protocols by government -- in the absence of "probable cause," it needs to be addressed by Congress.

Tomorrow my friend; I enjoy our dialogues.

 
 

Who is online





RU4Real


86 visitors