Two Internal Revenue Service employees in the agency's Cincinnati office told congressional investigators that IRS officials in Washington helped direct the probe of tea-party groups that began in 2010.
Transcripts of the interviews, viewed Wednesday by The Wall Street Journal, appear to contradict earlier statements by top IRS officials, who have blamed lower-level workers in Cincinnati.
Elizabeth Hofacre said her office in Cincinnati sought help from IRS officials in the Washington unit that oversees tax-exempt organizations after she started getting the tea-party cases in April 2010. Ms. Hofacre said Carter Hull, an IRS lawyer in Washington, closely oversaw her work and suggested some of the questions asked applicants.
"I was essentially a front person, because I had no autonomy or no authority to act on [applications] without Carter Hull's influence or input," she said, according to the transcripts.
Mr. Hull could not be reached for comment.
The interviews provide new clues to the puzzle slowly being pieced together in several congressional probes and a criminal investigation by the Justice Department. Investigators want to know exactly how the IRS initiated extra scrutiny to tea-party and other conservative grass roots organizations that were seeking tax-exempt status.
The transcripts don't suggest that Obama administration officials at the Treasury or the White House knew of or were involved in the targeting. Many questions remain unanswered, including who ordered the targeting.
The interview transcripts suggest it began with a search for tea-party groups by name among applications from groups seeking tax-exempt status. The Cincinnati employee who conducted the search, Gary Muthert, said he started gathering applications in March 2010, at the request of an unidentified local manager, who allegedly told him that "Washington, D.C., wanted some cases," according to the transcripts. Mr. Muthert first heard of tea-party applications from another Cincinnati employee.
The cases were handed off to Ms. Hofacre the following month, according to the interviews, which were conducted jointly by the House Oversight & Government Reform Committee and the House Ways and Means Committee. Both Republican and Democratic investigators participated in the interviews.
Ms. Hofacre said she was outraged last month when IRS higher-ups, including Lois Lerner, then the head of the IRS tax-exempt division, blamed the problem on employees in Cincinnati. "I was furious," Ms. Hofacre told interviewers. "It looked like Lois Lerner was putting it on us."
Mr. Muthert, Ms. Hofacre and Ms. Lerner didn't immediately respond to requests for comment. The IRS didn't respond to a request for comment.
When the controversy erupted in May, Ms. Lerner portrayed the targeting as the result of decisions by IRS employees in Cincinnati, who "decided to centralize [tea-party cases] so we'd have consistency," she said during a May 10 conference call with reporters.
"The problem here was that in some cases they added actual case names to the list," Ms. Lerner continued. "They added tea party and patriot to the list of cases that should be centralized." She described the actions as "absolutely inappropriate" and said the Cincinnati employees were guilty of an "error in judgment."
Other IRS officials also blamed Cincinnati employees. At a recent congressional hearing, ousted acting Commissioner Steven Miller said: "People in Cincinnati decided, let's start grouping these cases; let's centralize these cases."
Mr. Miller's attorney, William Burck, said his client first learned of a spreadsheet that was used to target tea-party groups in early May 2012 after an internal review he had requested. "Upon learning the results of that review, Mr. Miller immediately put in place remedial measures to make sure the inappropriate criteria would not be used again," Mr. Burck said.
The inspector general for the IRS, J. Russell George, also focused on mistakes in the Cincinnati office. He testified before a congressional panel this week that "only first-line management in Cincinnatiapproved references to the Tea Party" in a document that listed criteria employees used in selecting applications for extra scrutiny. Mr. George blamed "insufficient oversight" by managers in Washington.
The statements by Mr. Muthert and Ms. Hofacre paint a more complicated picture.
In March 2010, Mr. Muthert was among the first IRS employees to start selecting and setting aside the tea-party applications for extra scrutiny, according to the transcripts.
In his interview with congressional investigators, he said a local managerwhose name was redacted in the transcriptsasked him to find all the tea-party applications in the office's files, both pending and closed. The manager asked him to use the phrase "tea party" to conduct the search.
Around the same time, the local manager "said Washington, D.C., wanted seven" cases, Mr. Muthert said in the transcript. That month, he said, he "batched up" seven of the cases for "EO Technical," a unit of the Exempt Organizations Division in Washington, then headed by Ms. Lerner, according to his interview.
Around May of 2010, Mr. Muthert said, another local official asked him to locate a couple more applications to send to Washington. Over the next two months, Mr. Muthert said, he located about 40 tea-party cases after expanding his search to include the terms "patriot" and "9/12."
Ms. Hofacre said in her interview that she was in charge of the tea-party cases from the end of April until October. She was told by a Cincinnati employee, who wasn't identified in the transcripts, to get in touch with the Exempt Organizations Technical unit in Washington, for guidance on the roughly 40 to 60 cases she was handling.
Ms. Hofacre said Mr. Hull, the IRS attorney in Washington, emailed her letters that he had already sent to two tea-party applicants. She was instructed to use those letters as a "foundation to prepare and review my cases and prepare my letters" to applicants, she said. She said she found the intervention by Mr. Hull "demeaning," according to the transcripts.
Mr. Hull also suggested questions to applicants, she said, and she was told to send him all the responses.
"All I remember saying and thinking is, 'This is ridiculous,'" she said. "Because at the same time, you are getting calls from irate taxpayers. And I see their point. Even if a decision isn't favorable, they deserve some kind of treatment and they deserve, you know, timeliness, andthese applications and their responses were just being sent up there [to Washington] and I am not sure what was happening."
At another point during the interview she complained she was "being micromanaged to death, and it was just really frustrating." In part because of her experience, she asked for and was given a transfer that she said amounted to a promotion in the fall of 2010.
An IRS inspector general's report last month found the IRS had used inappropriate criteria to select applications for extra review and left those criteria to stay in place for more than 18 months, resulting in substantial delays in processing certain applications.

The church organizations I was once familiar with broke so many tax exempt laws by preaching politics, enforcing the voting of certain candidates and gathering money for those causes, that I figure if any group needs to have the screws put to them is the conservative tea party, patriot, republican christian right. They know it and that is why they are so freaked out about it. I really don't see the problem with the shit finally hitting their fan for a change. It's a shame that someone is getting charged with foul play when it's finally really just FAIR play from what I've seen.
How about unions and other Dem water drawers?
If what you say is true, why doesn't Obama defend it instead of running from it.
What Enron and the IRS Have in Common
Ethical meltdowns are rarely the work of a few rogue workers. They take their cues from toxic leadership..
By STEVEN LAW
Excerpts:
Any good CEO will tell you that ethical meltdowns like the IRS political-targeting scandal are rarely the work of a few rogue employees. Such messes are the result of a toxic culture that has been allowed to fester.
When I was chief of staff at the Labor Department, we investigated the ethical and financial disintegration of Enron in connection with the collapse of its pension funds in 2001. What we found was a small circle of certifiably bad actors who acted without regard for the law or for anyone else. Surrounding this inner circle was a culture that gave these employees tacit permission to run roughshod over others and break the law.
While lower-level Enron employees did their jobs honorably, senior management cultivated a malignant esprit de corps that corroded the company's ethics. The C-Suite view was that no one was smarter, faster or more aggressive than these executives. Mortals couldn't possibly understand what they did. That belief created its own closed-system logic, leading to deceptive accounting schemes, self-dealing and, ultimately, a battery of criminal convictions for Enron's top brass.
What does Enron's collapse have to tell us about the shocking revelations of IRS political targeting?
Plenty. IRS senior managers like acting Commissioner Steven Miller insist that the illicit behavior was the work of a handful of rogue employees. The trouble is that even though we are starting to learn who those employees are and who supervised them, we still don't know what orders they were acting on, why no one stopped them and why they thought it was appropriate to selectively harass private citizens on the basis of their using such dangerous labels as "Tea Party," "liberty" and "patriot."
These IRS employees believed that they had implicit consent to ideologically profile nonprofit advocacy groups. Where did that come from? Lois Lernerthe IRS official who headed the division overseeing tax-exempt groups and who is now on administrative leavecertainly didn't elucidate matters when she exercised her right against self-incrimination rather than testify before Congress on May 22.
What the Enron scandal teaches is that such implicit permission can be communicated by a toxic culture fostered by the company's top brass.
Consider the tone that has been set by the person at the very top of the government the IRS serves. President Obama is the first president since Nixon to refer to political opponents as "enemies," in October 2010, apologizing only after a week of intense criticism. Around the same time, he assailed conservative advocacy groups as a "threat to democracy." As the nation's top law enforcer, Mr. Obama singled out groups such as Americans for Prosperity by name and suggested they could be taking illegal foreign funds. That's toxic culture from the C-Suite.
Next, at least 10 Democratic senators publicly pressured the IRS to do precisely what it is now being excoriated for: harassing center-right groups for conducting the same spirited advocacy that environmental groups and labor unions have done for years. I know something about this: A month before the 2010 election, Sen. Dick Durbin sent a letter urging the IRS to investigate the advocacy group I head, Crossroads GPS. Why us and not scores of liberal groups that do exactly what we do? Mr. Durbin claims he singled us out because we were raising so much money.
Now that we see how ugly ideological profiling by the IRS looks, some of these senators are in full damage control.
More:
According to the "right wing" he ran from questions about being a Muslim, being born in the United States and being the anti-christ. There is a whole slew of other things including what elementary school he attended, that THEY WOULD REALLY LIKE SOME ANSWERS FOR!!! They accuse him of having elementary school children shot and then accuse him of trying to take away all our guns. They blame him for tornadoes and bad lettuce. Really would it matter to you if he did address it? NO, you've made up your mind, you don't care what he says you would twist it so you hear what you want. And obviously you think he has WAY more power than he does. It's rather flattering really.