╌>

Penalties for politicians

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  13 years ago  •  7 comments

Penalties for politicians

We entrust an inordinate amount of power to people who don't feel any pain when we fall down.

As scandals explode across Washington -- from the IRS scandals , to the Benghazi scandal , to the HHS donations scandal , to Pigford and more -- one thing that I've noticed is that the people involved don't seem to suffer much. There are consequences, but not for them. Likewise, Rep. Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y., left office in disgrace, but wound up with surprisingly lucrative consulting gigs.

This reminds me of something writer Robert Heinlein once said: "Any government will work if authority and responsibility are equal and coordinate. This does not ensure 'good' government, it simply ensures that it will work. But such governments are rare most people want to run things, but want no part of the blame. This used to be called the 'backseat driver' syndrome."

Government officials are happy making and executing plans that affect the lives of millions, but when things go wrong, well ... they're willing to accept the responsibility, but they're not willing to take the blame. What's the difference? People who are to blame lose their jobs. People who are "responsible," do not. The blame, such as it is, winds up deflected on to The System, or something else suitably abstract.

But when you cut the linkage between outcomes and experience, you make learning much more difficult. When you were a toddler learning to walk, you fell down a lot. This was unpleasant: shocking, at least, and often painful. Thus, you learned to fall down a lot less often.

But imagine if falling down didn't hurt. You wouldn't have learned not to fall, or at least, you would have accumulated a lot more bruises along the way.

Given the low penalties for failure it faces, our political class is one for whom falling down is usually painless and even -- given the surprisingly common tendency of people who have presided over debacles to be given promotions rather than the boot -- actually pleasurable. The leaders move society's arms and legs, but we're the ones who collect the bruises.

The problem is that they don't have, in President Obama's words, " skin in the game ." When it comes to actual wrongdoing, they're shielded by doctrines of "absolute immunity" (for the president) and "qualified immunity" (for lesser officials). This means that the president can't be sued for anything he does as president, while lower-ranking officials can't be sued so long as they can show that they were acting in a "good faith" belief that they were following the law.

Such defenses aren't available to the rest of us. And they're not even the product of legislation passed by Congress after considered judgment -- they're judicially created. (Judges gave themselves absolute immunity, too, for good measure.)

Then, of course, there's the unfortunate fact that the worse the economy does, the more important the government becomes. As Tim Noah pointed out back when the financial crisis was new, "On Wall Street, financial crisis destroys jobs. Here in Washington, it creates them. The rest is just details."

Some incentive system. And yet they want us to trust them to "fix the economy." My worry is that their idea of "fixed" may not be the same as mine.

I'd favor some changes that put accountability back in. First, I'd get rid of judicially created immunities. The Constitution itself creates only one kind of immunity, for members of Congress in speech and debate. (Perhaps unsurprisingly, courts have interpreted this grant of immunity, explicitly in the Constitution, more narrowly than the judicially created ones).

I'd also cut all payments to members of Congress whenever they haven't passed a budget. If they can't take care of that basic responsibility, why should they get paid? Likewise, I'd ban presidential travel when there's not a budget. He can do his job from the White House.

I'm willing to consider other changes: Term limits that kick in whenever there's a deficit for more than two years in a row. Limitations on civil-service protections to allow wronged citizens to get offending bureaucrats fired. Pay cuts for elected officials whenever inflation or unemployment are above a threshold.

But the real lesson is this: We entrust an inordinate amount of power to people who don't feel any pain when we fall down. The best solution of all is to take a lot of that power back. When the power is in your hands, it's in the hands of someone who feels it when you fall down. When it's in their hands, it's your pain, their gain. That's no way to run a country.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2013/05/27/irs-benghazi-scandal-politicians-column/2363901/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

This needs to happen. I especially like the idea of pay cuts whenever unemployment goes above a certain level.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

I'm getting ready to start being furloughed every monday for the rest of the Fiscal Year. Because the President and Congress couldn't get their act together. Specifically means that I will lose 20% of my weekly salary every week for the rest of the Fiscal Year. And yet, as the author states, those in Congress and the White House will not feel this themselves-except if we decide not to re-elect them. But the President is kind of a lame duck as he has no more elections on his horizon. I firmly believe that all members of the government should be required to share the pain-to include their staffs (that will get this stuff fixed pretty quickly)

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Again 96?

You actually want to hold them accountable for what they do and do not do. Are you daft man?

In truth many good ideas, I would like permanent term limits or the right of recall.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

nothing to worry about, obama said he was outraged, and would bring the guilty to justice. holder said he would investigate.

yup, lib wonderland, nothing to worry about.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I agree, Spikegary-- I think that to serve as a congressman or senator, they should spend one week in a homeless shelter... And yes, if they are going to vote for furloughs, then THEY need them too. Just like they need to pay for their own healthcare and postage. Smile.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I will settle for holding them accountable only for what they do....wait a minute....they don't do anything, you ARE a tricky one Luther. lol

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

hey libs, you know the obama revenuer shullman, who lied to congress? well, he said he visited obama over 100 times, but never discussed discrimination against conservatives. guess how many times his predicessor visited bush?.....once.

 
 

Who is online








94 visitors