PRESIDENT OBAMAS speech on national security last week was a dense thicket of self-justifying argument, but its central message was perfectly clear: Please dont worry, liberals. Im not George W. Bush.
You can see why his supporters might be getting nervous on that front. The continuities between Obama and Bush on national security have always been there for those with eyes to see, but much more attention has been paid to them of late to the expansive drone campaign that has targeted American citizens for execution without trial, to an anti-leaks campaign that has flirted with criminalizing investigative reporting, and to the perpetual postponement of supposed administration priorities like shuttering the prison at Guantnamo.
Against this backdrop, the presidents rhetoric last week was calculated to reassure and soothe. The promises he made in 2008, when he campaigned as a critic of wartime overreach, were revived, reasserted, amplified. He would push anew to close Gitmo ... phase out indefinite detention ... put limits on drone strikes ... safeguard a free press ... even wind down the war on terror.
But of course the year is no longer 2008, and Obama has been the decider for more than four years now. Which meant that his address had an air of self-critique thats rare in presidential rhetoric. In the words of Esquires Tom Junod , one of the most perceptive writers on Obamas drone policy, the speech didnt just speak to Americans in the language of moral struggle. It tried to make the president himself representative of moral struggle, by turning personal, almost confessional, in its weighing of doubt and its admission of second thoughts.
This willingness to grapple with moral complexity has always been one of the things that Obamas admirers love about him, and even liberals who feel disappointed with his national security record still seem grateful for the change from George W. Bush. If we have to have an imperial president, their attitude seems to be, better to have one who shows some anguish over the difficult trade-offs that perpetual war poses to a free society (as The New Yorkers Jane Mayer put it on Friday), rather than falling back on the secrecy and winking smugness of the past.
I am not particularly nostalgic for the Bush era either. But Obamas Reinhold Niebuhr act comes with potential costs of its own. While the last president exuded a cowboyish certainty, this president is constantly examining his conscience in public but if their policies are basically the same, the latter is no less of a performance. And there are ways in which it may be a more fundamentally dishonest one, because it perpetually promises harmonies that cant be achieved and policy shifts that wont actually be delivered.
Thats a cynical reading on Obamas speech, but it feels like the right one. Listened to or skimmed, the address seemed to promise real limits on presidential power, a real horizon for the war on terror. But when parsed carefully, its not clear how much practical effect its promises will have.
For instance, the president insisted that history will cast a harsh judgment on indefinite detention but proposed no actual plan to deal with Gitmo detainees who (in his own words) we know have participated in dangerous plots or attacks but who cannot be prosecuted. He promised that drone attacks would be carried out only amid near-certainty that no civilians will be killed or injured but also suggested, in defiance of much evidence, that this standard is already being met. He pledged to support efforts to ultimately repeal the post-9/11 authorization for the use of military force but offered no timetable to contradict the recent testimony from a Defense Department official projecting another 10 to 20 years of military activity.
Over all, as the Brookings Institutions Benjamin Wittes put it , the speech seemed written to align Obama as publicly as possible with the critics of the positions his administration is taking without undermining his administrations operational flexibility in actual fact.
There are obviously good reasons to preserve this flexibility. The problem is that by making it sound as if American policy is about to change more than it actually will, the presidents rhetoric risks coming across as a bait and switch on his supporters at home, but more important, on audiences across the Muslim world.
There, this White Houses foreign policy, in many ways reasonably successful , has met with its biggest disappointments. Far from abating, anti-Americanism has hardened in many Muslim countries, which presumably reflects disillusionment with the gap between candidate Obamas promises and President Obamas policies.
There is no good reason to overpromise yet again. Where the United States can step back from a wartime footing, we absolutely should. But where we dont actually intend to, we should be forthright about it rather than pretending that change is perpetually just around the corner, and behaving as though our choices are justified by how much anguish we express while making them.

Republican lawmakers roundly criticized President Barack Obama s war-on-terror reset, saying Sunday that it makes America appear weak at a time when intense security threats remain.
At a time we need resolve the most, were sounding retreat, South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham , a Republican, said Sunday on Fox News. Ive never been more worried about our national security.
--- Rep. Michael McCaul (R., Texas), chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee, said he found many parts of Mr. Obamas speech disturbing for many reasons. ---
Mr. McCaul said that while he agrees that core al-Qaida has successfully been denigrated tremendously, he said the terrorist group has evolved into a franchise, global movement, if you will, that inspires and also is very tactical.
The Texas Republican also took issue with Mr. Obamas call to close the military prison at Guantanamo Bay, which houses 166 detainees. He said that returning some to Yemen poses a problem because we know one-quarter to one-third of these guys return to the battlefield. Bringing the detainees to the U.S. also carries big risks, he said, adding, name me one American city that would like to host these guys, these terrorists in their country. I think the answer is zero.
Democratic lawmakers sprung the presidents defense Sunday, arguing that no American wants the country to remain in a perpetual state of war.
More:
The title of the seeded article is a complete train wreck. It should have caused the editor a major migraine.
How does a "journalist" get this shit published ???
and not be gibberish !
I titled the seed based on the conclusion in the final paragraph. Here is the complete quote:
My title is a fairer and fullersummary of the op ed than the actual title which is the editor's very brief summary.
The Times is an ultraliberal paper and is very strict with their op ed writers.
William Kristol was released because he would not agree to edits and other writers have complained about the excessive editing.
The seed article contradicts both the Times' laudatory editorial on Obama's speech and Maureen Dowd's exhuberant praise of same.
Douthat is evidently able to pass muster with his couching of criticism in ambiguity. You have to read between the lines.
In a letter to the Times , Netanyahus senior adviser Ron Dermer in response to the papers request that Netanyahu write an op-ed wrote that the prime minister would respectfully decline. Dermer made clear that this had much to do with the fact that 19 of the papers 20 op-ed pieces on Israel since September were negative.
William Kristol was fired after a year for being critical of the Times. Others have complained of oppressive editing and restrictions.
When a Times article appears elsewhere that is because it is syndicated by the Times. The columnist does not do his own syndication.