╌>

Comparative Medical Stats -- Pre-Obamacare

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  5 comments

Comparative Medical Stats -- Pre-Obamacare

A recent "Investor's Business Daily" article provided very interesting statistics from a survey by the United Nations International Health Organization.

Percentage of men and women who survived a cancer five years after diagnosis: U.S. 65% England 46% Canada 42%

Percentage of patients diagnosed with diabetes who received treatment within six months: U.S. 93% England 15% Canada 43%

Percentage of seniors needing hip replacement who received it within six months: U.S. 90% England 15% Canada 43%

Percentage referred to a medical specialist who see one within one month: U.S. 77% England 40% Canada 43%

Number of MRI scanners (a prime diagnostic tool) per million people: U.S. 71 England 14 Canada 18

Percentage of seniors (65+), with low income, who say they are in "excellent health": U.S. 12% England 2% Canada 6%


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

We have heard so much from Michael Moore and others about how American medical care is so deficient compared to Canada's and the UK's single-payer plans.

These stats puit things in perspective.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Simple!

Obamacare will move us in the direction of the medically inferior nations. Note the problems in Massachusetts Romneycare:

The reality is it performed very poorly, said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, a former Congressional Budget Office director and president of the American Action Forum. Hes one of the most vocal critics of the plan. A huge mark against it is it didnt control health care costs at all.

Health care costs per capita were 27 percent higher in Massachusetts than in the rest of the country in 2004, two years before the state plan was signed, Holtz-Eakin says. By 2009, it was 30 percent higher than the national average.

The laws failure to rein in health care costs is widely acknowledged by nonpartisan analysts, as well as conservative critics. But theres more material for critics to work with if either party wanted to use it. For example, emergency room use has gone up, not down undermining the laws effort to get that problem under control by expanding coverage.

State health policy officials issued a report last month showing a 6 percent increase in emergency room use from 2006 to 2010, the first four years when the law was in effect. That figure has confounded proponents of the law, who hoped emergency room care would plummet when residents had access to insurance and primary-care doctors.

Detractors in the Bay State also say the law has done little to dent the surging demand seen by the states largest safety-net hospitals.

Its getting harder for Massachusetts residents to see a doctor, too. A report released last month by the Massachusetts Medical Society found that only half of the states primary-care providers are accepting new patients, down from 70 percent in 2007. And the average wait time to see a doctor in family medicine is 45 days up from 34 days in 2007.

To Joshua Archambault, a health care expert at the right-leaning Pioneer Institute, the laws greatest failures are its unfulfilled promises for small businesses. Its framers, he noted, promised to revolutionize the way small businesses purchased insurance, make it cheaper.

That simply has not happened, he said.

Read more:
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Sure he did, but what has that to do with logic, facts, or understanding the realities of our medical system?

Fact.... The VAs administrative cost to operate are less than 5% their budget.

Fact.... Medical insurance companies administrative costs range between 25% and 30% of their costs.

I agree that companies deserve to make a profit, but when does profit become greed? Profit, ethics and the Hippocratic oath are at odds with each other when it comes to the American health care system.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

You should realize, first, that the WHO stats are from the 1990s and, second, that WHO is a UN organization and such are heavily biased against the US. Here is a summary of the report criticisms:

The WHO rankings have been subject to criticism concerning their methodology, scientificity, and usefulness. Dr Philip Musgrove wrote that the rankings are meaningless because they oversimplify: "numbers confer a spurious precision". [ 3 ]

Journalist John Stossel notes that the use of life expectancy figures is misleading and the life expectancy in the United States is held down by homicides , accidents , poor diet, and lack of exercise. When controlled for these facts, Stossel claims that American life expectancy is actually one of the highest in the world. [ 4 ] A publication by the Pacific Research Institute in 2006 claims to have found that Americans outlive people in every other Western country, when controlled for homicides and car accidents. [ 5 ] Stossel also criticizes the ranking for favoring socialized healthcare, noting that "a country with high-quality care overall but 'unequal distribution' would rank below a country with lower quality care but equal distribution." [ 4 ]

Glen Whitman claims that "it looks an awful lot like someone cherry-picked the results to make the U.S.'s relative performance look worse than it is." He also notes that the rankings favor countries where individuals or families spend little of their income directly on health care. [7] In an article in The American Spectator , Whitman notes how the rankings favor government intervention, which has nothing to do with quality of care.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Yup! And I regret he was not elected more now than inlast November.

Romney's view was that healthcare should be a state obligaton, not a Federal one. Different states have different needs and capabilities.

 
 

Who is online





92 visitors