╌>

Some unions now angry about health care overhaul

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Some unions now angry about health care overhaul
<:article>
3ac32f89-63e7-40ef-9548-2c9adf5182ce_preview.jpg
5/24/2013 4:39:18 PM
(AP) Some unions now angry about health care overhaul
By SAM HANANEL
Associated Press
WASHINGTON
Some labor unions that enthusiastically backed President Barack Obama's health care overhaul are now frustrated and angry, fearful that it will jeopardize benefits for millions of their members.

Union leaders warn that unless the problem is fixed, there could be consequences for Democrats facing re-election next year.

"It makes an untruth out of what the president said _ that if you like your insurance, you could keep it," said Joe Hansen, president of the United Food and Commercial Workers International Union. "That is not going to be true for millions of workers now."

The problem lies in the unique multiemployer health plans that cover unionized workers in retail, construction, transportation and other industries with seasonal or temporary employment. Known as Taft-Hartley plans, they are jointly administered by unions and smaller employers that pool resources to offer more than 20 million workers and family members continuous coverage, even during times of unemployment.

The union plans were already more costly to run than traditional single-employer health plans.

But Obama's Affordable Care Act has added to that cost _ for the unions' and other plans _ by requiring health plans to cover dependents up to age 26, eliminate annual or lifetime coverage limits and extend coverage to people with pre-existing conditions.

"We're concerned that employers will be increasingly tempted to drop coverage through our plans and let our members fend for themselves on the health exchanges," said David Treanor, director of health care initiatives at the Operating Engineers union.

Workers seeking coverage in the state-based marketplaces, known as exchanges, can qualify for subsidies, determined by a sliding scale based on income. By contrast, the new law does not allow workers in the union plans to receive similar subsidies.

Bob Laszewski, a health care industry consultant, said the real fear among unions is that "a lot of these labor contracts are very expensive, and now employers are going to have an alternative to very expensive labor health benefits."

"If the workers can get benefits that are as good through Obamacare in the exchanges, then why do you need the union?" Laszewski said. "In my mind, what the unions are fearing is that workers for the first time can get very good health benefits for a subsidized cost someplace other than the employer."

However, Laszewski said it was unlikely employers would drop the union plans immediately because they are subject to ongoing collective bargaining agreements.

Labor unions have been among the president's closest allies, spending millions of dollars to help him win re-election and help Democrats keep their majority in the Senate. The wrangling over health care comes as unions have continued to see steady declines in membership and attacks on public employee unions in state legislatures around the country. The Obama administration walks a fine line between defending the president's signature legislative achievement and not angering a powerful constituency as it looks ahead to the 2014 elections.

Harold Schaitberger, president of the International Association of Firefighters, said unions have spent more than a year trying to get a regulatory fix that would allow low-income workers in union plans to receive subsidies too. But labor leaders say they have been told it won't happen. And new legislation is unlikely anytime soon.

Both Hanson and Schaitberger said the frustration could spill over into the 2014 election cycle if union concerns aren't addressed.

"It started out with some anxiety, and I think it's translated into more anger," Schaitberger said.

Sabrina Siddiqui, a Treasury Department spokeswoman, declined to discuss the specifics of any negotiations between the administration and union officials. But she said the law helps bring down costs and improve quality of care.

Katie Mahoney, executive director of health policy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, said employers were concerned about possible increases in health care costs and would do what was needed to keep their businesses running and retain worker talent. The Chamber has not taken a position on the union concerns, but Mahoney said it was highly unlikely that the administration would consider subsidies for workers in the union plans.

"They are not going to offset the expense of added mandates under the health care law, which employers and unions are going to pay for," Mahoney said.

Unions say their health care plans in many cases offer better coverage with broader doctors' networks and lower premiums than what would be available in the exchanges, particularly when it comes to part-time workers.

"It's not favoritism. We want to be treated fairly," said Hansen, whose union has about 800,000 of its 1.3 million members covered under Taft-Hartley policies. "We would expect more help from this administration."

Unions backed the health care legislation because they expected it to curb inflation in health coverage, reduce the number of uninsured Americans and level the playing field for companies that were already providing quality benefits. While unions knew there were lingering issues after the law passed, they believed those could be fixed through rulemaking.

But last month, the union representing roofers issued a statement calling for "repeal or complete reform" of the health care law. Kinsey Robinson, president of the United Union of Roofers, Waterproofers and Allied Workers, complained that labor's concerns over the health care law "have not been addressed, or in some instances, totally ignored."

"In the rush to achieve its passage, many of the act's provisions were not fully conceived, resulting in unintended consequences that are inconsistent with the promise that those who were satisfied with their employer-sponsored coverage could keep it," Robinson said.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Do ALL Unions have to comply with PPACA as of January 2014?

From the HHS website: ( )
Q: How does this policy affect plans that are negotiated by unions collectively bargained arrangements?

A: Health plans subject to collective bargaining agreements are generally able to maintain their grandfathered status through the end of the agreement. The law and regulations also include a special rule for collectively bargained plans that gives additional flexibility to change insurers during the collective bargaining agreement in effect on the date that the Affordable Care Act was signed. After that, collective bargaining agreements are subject to the same rules as other health plans.

Take it from a union guy who was DIRECTLY INVOLVED IN THE NEGOTIATION A NUMBER OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENTS, THE UNIONS KNEW THIS WAS THE REALITY! If management is refusing to agree to union contract provision requests that will allow the continuation and/or upgrading of health benefits, it's MANAGEMENT and NOT THE PPACA that's responsible!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Are you saying that, if the union's present agreement with managementmakes Obamacare costly for its members, it is management's obligation to change the agreemnt so it assumes those additional costs?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Are you saying that, if the union's present agreement with managementmakes Obamacare costly for its members, it is management's obligation to change the agreemnt so it assumes those additional costs?

You know I'm not saying that. I'm saying that when employee benefits are part of a collective bargaining agreement, when that agreement expires, any/all provisions are subject to negotiations between labor and management AS ALWAYS.

And the union leaderships know this.

PPACA can not force any individual to change his/her health insurance coverage nor choice of providers; neither can it supersede a ratified collective bargaining agreement. My guess is, if a particular union leader/negotiator is dealing with a management that wants to be difficult, he/she may be covering his own ass by blaming Obama for "deceiving" re:PPACA.

But just as the PPACA cannot supersede a negotiated contract, neither can a negotiated contract supersede law; by that I mean, whatever health insurance benefits are agreed to going forward, certain aspects of PPACA must be adhered to by whichever insurer is involved.

Rights and Protections

Insurance Choices

Insurance Costs

65 or Older

Employers

If you need help dealing with your insurance, finding insurance, or getting answers to questions about how the health care system works, visit the Insurance Basics section .

 
 

Who is online






79 visitors