McCain Bill Would Create 'A La Carte' Cable Pricing - USA TODAY
Bill would encourage programmers and distributors to unbundle their channels.
(Photo: Rob Schumacher, The Arizona Republic)
Online music retailers usually don't force consumers to buy an entire album to get a favorite song .
Many consumers wonder why satellite and cable operators can't do something similar and allow them to purchase TV service by the channel instead of a bundle of dozens or even hundreds of networks, many of which they'll never watch.
The idea of "a la carte" cable and satellite television has been around for years. But Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., has jump-started a new national conversation with a bill he introduced in Congress this month that would use regulatory incentives to encourage programmers and distributors to unbundle their channels and offer a la carte programming.
McCain immediately picked up support from watchdog groups such as the Consumers Union and others who see his legislation as a way to shake up the status quo while technological innovations such as Internet TV break into the mainstream video market.
Ever-rising cable prices also are fueling the calls for a la carte . According to a Federal Communications Commission survey, rates for expanded basic cable, a popular cable tier, grew an average of 6.1 percent a year between 1995 and 2011. The average monthly price for the service is $54.46.
"I believe the consumers are at a tipping point when it comes to their monthly pay-TV bill," McCain told a Senate subcommittee last week. "In my view, the a la carte option is a non-regulatory and consumer-friendly way to provide consumers with the freedom to lower their bills and pay only for what they watch."
But while the concept is popular with many cable customers, and technology and other market forces appear headed in that direction, most observers doubt that even a senator with the national stature of McCain, a one-time presidential nominee, can bend the entrenched Washington lobbies of the cable industry, the broadcasters and the programmers to his will.
Cable lobbyists argue that a la carte pricing is not financially feasible, likely would mean the end of many channels that are not popular enough to survive without it, and probably wouldn't even save viewers much money, either. Hilary Shelton, director of the NAACP's Washington bureau, has blasted the a la carte cable idea on the grounds it would economically hurt minorities and "kill diversity in programming."
Industry leaders also argue that such issues might be better left to the free market to sort out, pointing to the ongoing revolution in video technology that gives consumers a variety of new viewing options such as online video, Netflix, Hulu, iTunes and digital video recorders and allows them to watch their favorite shows and movies on their schedules. A traditional TV set no longer is even necessary. Many young people are increasingly relying on their iPads, smartphones and laptop computers to watch video.
"These are big issues, but is anything going to happen? No," said A. Michael Noll, a University of Southern California professor emeritus and expert on telecommunications policy and TV technology. "The cable companies have tremendous lobbying power more power than John McCain."
Long shot to become law
In a recent interview with The Arizona Republic , even McCain acknowledged that his bill is a long shot to become law this year.
"I'd be surprised (if it passes), because the cable companies and the satellite companies are such a powerful special interest," McCain said. "But we'll keep trying."
It's unclear whether the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, which has jurisdiction over telecommunications issues, even intends to return to the a la carte programming issue in a serious way.
But McCain, a longtime champion of a la carte cable, was allowed to make his case last Tuesday before its Subcommittee on Communications, Technology and the Internet during a hearing on the "State of Video." In his remarks, McCain compared the bundling of programming in cable and satellite packages to forcing customers to pay for the entire menu at a restaurant in order to get what they want to eat.
"Basically, I support a la carte, and I believe most Americans do, for the basic reason that consumers shouldn't have to pay for television channels they don't watch and have no interest in watching," said McCain, a former Commerce Committee chairman who no longer sits on the panel.
Link to article to discuss Savings questions and Supporters who want to try it.
Tags
Who is online
79 visitors

always a good idea to impose more regulations on private industry.
mcshame, its time to retire.