╌>

Sometimes very smart people do very dumb things

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  13 years ago  •  8 comments

Sometimes very smart people do very dumb things

Stephen Hawking and the Israel Boycott

There's an old joke about the definition of chutzpa. A boy murders his parents and pleas to the judge: "Have pity on me Im an orphan!"

Sadly, that comic story can be applied this week to Stephen Hawking, the brilliant Cambridge physicist who announced he was pulling out of the "Facing Tomorrow" conference in Israel next month, "based on advice from Palestinian academics that he should respect the boycott" of Israel. For such a clever man, his recent actions are shockingly foolish and short-sighted.

Short-sighted because, given Israel's central position in scientific and technological fields, to boycott the Jewish state would mean giving up on some of the most important advancements of recent years.

  • Stephen Hawking himself, who has suffered from motor neuron disease for most of his 71 years, communicates using a mechanical voice system run by the Intel Core i7 Processor developed by the Israeli division of Intel.
  • As a partical physicist, he is intimately involved in the most significant development in modern times: the discovery of the Higgs-Boson particle, found last year using Israeli-developed particle detectors .
  • Last year, Hawking accepted a prestigious physics award worth $3 million awarded by Yuri Milner, a major investor in Israeli high-tech.

Clearly, Prof. Hawking is not about to take out his Intel voice chip, return $3 million, and cease engaging in scientific debate. With so many areas of his life impacted and improved by Israeli dynamism, his refusal to visit the Jewish state comes across as a whole lotta chutzpa.

Double Standard

If Hawking wants to boycott a nation for perceived human rights outrages, he is targeting the wrong country.

In a week when the world's newspapers were filled with gruesome descriptions of profound human rights violations, it's ironic that Prof. Hawking would choose to target Israel for approbation:

  • Civil war is raging in Syria , with the Assad regime using chemical weapons against civilians
  • Nigeria is massacring Islamist opponents of the government
  • China is enforcing its brutal one-child policy through forced abortions
  • Saudi Arabia is executing political prisoners and homosexuals

Of course, Israel is not be above criticism, but to single it out for special treatment is to hold it to a biased double-standard that is required of no other country in the world. To single out Israel, a liberal democracy with an open press, transparent judiciary, universal suffrage, and enshrined equal rights for all as a country not only to be criticized, but utterly avoided is total chutzpa.

Dr. Hawking, whose academic research is world-class, must also realize the key to bettering the world lies in fostering communication, not in shutting it down. By turning his back on all of Israel, he's sending a reactionary and hate-filled message at odds with the extensive academic collaboration that's marked his entire career. Chutzpa!

Hawkings cancellation was a major embarrassment to Cambridge University.

Indeed, serious academics, such as Sari Nusseibeh, the Palestinian President of Al-Quds University, deplore academic boycotts. Dr. Nusseibeh has pioneered joint projects with Hebrew University in Jerusalem and Brandeis University near Boston.

Hawkings cancellation was such an embarrassment to his employer, Cambridge University, that the school spokesman tried to claim it was due to health reasons and not as a boycott of Israel. The university was then forced to backtrack, after Hawking's office made perfectly clear that the decision was due to the boycott.

Wrong Side of History

Amazingly, the conference that Hawking is boycotting is designed to promote the very sort of tolerant, open world for which he surely yearns.

Held under the auspices of Israeli President Shimon Peres, the annual Facing Tomorrow conference brings together a diverse group of 5,000 world leaders and intellectuals for discussions on an array of pressing world including geopolitics, economics, environment and culture. Peres, a Nobel Prize laureate and Israels elder statesman, is using his considerable political capital to address some of the planets most pressing issues. To boycott this effort is not reasoned criticism but rather pure chutzpa an attempt to destroy an Israeli initiative not on its merits, but simply because it originates in the Jewish state.

Click here to receive Aish.com's free weekly email.

As a theoretical physicist, Hawking surely knows that his field was shaped by unsuccessful attempts to silence Jews in the past.

In the 1930s, Jewish scientists in Germany including Albert Einstein found themselves edged out of traditional academic fields and into burgeoning scientific areas such as particle physics. Einstein and Enrico Fermi (who left Europe to save his Jewish wife) came to the United States, and built much of the foundation of modern theoretical physics.

This latest boycott attempt to silence Jews has a long and infamous history. Hawkings synergy with this movement to delegitimize the existence of the Jewish state is destined to prove on the wrong side of history.

http://www.aish.com/jw/me/Stephen-Hawking-and-the-Israel-Boycott.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

If he wanted to TRULY boycott Israel, he would give up all the things that made it possible for him to succeed and flourish. This is truly the gold standard of hypocrisy.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

Drop Hawkings and wheelchair into Gaza for a week and see if his opinion changes.

Has he lost his appreciation for the fact that Muslim countries provide little to the advancement of science and society?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

This just is another example that demonstrates the fact that intelligence, even high intelligence, is amoral. A highly intelligent person can be good, evil or in-between.

Hitler, Stalin, Muhammad, bin Ladinand Pol Pot were also intelligent.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Two days in a row we agree, and rather eloquently stated to boot. The final paragraph sums it up nicely.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

But,but,but,but,...he's a GENIUS; surely he's correct!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

A reminder that great ability in one arena is not a predictor of universal genius

Exactly.

I think you just hit the nail with your head (to coin a phrase). Expertise in one area does not necessarily mean tht person is a genius in other areas...

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

For sure, but that doesn't stop the masses from hanging on the words of famous people, regardless of their knowledge.

Bruce Springsteen, Bono and Roger Waters are just 3 right off the bat. They've made 9 figures in their industry, and they think that the microphone also works for any other opinion that they might like to advance. People hang on the words of these people, and will allow it to color their opinions.

Pathetic...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

But some are still going:

Most recently, 2012 saw Israel host to Madonna, Lady Gaga, Metallica, Rihanna, Chris Cornell, Linkin Park, and the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

For some artists, resisting the pressure to divest from Israel means simply not responding to the blogs and online petitions. Others have gone a step further by vocally defending their choice. Elton John, whose 2010 concert came in the wake of the Gaza flotilla incident, affirmed on stage to his adoring audience that music is the wrong place for playing politics.

Musicians spread love and peace, bringing people together, he said. Thats what we do. We dont cherry-pick our conscience.

Johns statement was both one of support for Israelis and a jibe aimed at several popular musicians who had recently canceled tour dates in Israel, such as Santana, the Pixies, and Elvis Costello. Costello, announcing his decision to cancel on his official website, said his decision to pull out was a matter of instinct and conscience.

Like John, others in the music world have answered protests by citing the unique ability of art to unify people across class and culture. Sharon Osborne said in a video released to reporters ahead of a 2010 concert that she and Ozzy were proud to be playing in Israel.

Music goes beyond politics because it is the international language of the world, she said.

Jethro Tull frontman Ian Anderson, in response to calls for the band to cancel its 2010 Israel concert series, wrote on the bands website that being told to boycott Israel serves to strengthen my resolve that some degree of peace and understanding will result from my and other artists professional and humble efforts in such places.

(Link)

Sure, they may influence some gullible people. But if you look at public opinion polls , support for Israel is very high. (And in Congress there is strong support for Israel on both sides of the aisle-- and this includes both prominent Liberals as well as Conservatives).

 
 

Who is online





89 visitors