╌>

The Constitution Should Never be Viewed as Somehow an Impediment to Justice.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  19 comments

The Constitution Should Never be Viewed as Somehow an Impediment to Justice.

A main clause of the Fourteenth Amendment states:

Section. 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

This has nothing to do with innocence or guilt or even incontrovertible evidence established prior to indictment -- it has to do with our law and our integrity as a country. Individuals are charged, not charged, tried or not brought to trial, found innocent or, found guilty and convicted and punished based on our system of laws and protocol.

Suspending the Constitution or "re-writing" the law to appease outrage, even when the outrage is warranted, puts all American citizens potentially at risk of being "innocent-until-charged".

The Constitution should never be viewed as somehow an impediment to justice. That would make us the very antithesis of what we (proudly) are as a nation.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Constitution should never be viewed as somehow an impediment to justice. That would make us the very antithesis of what we (proudly) are as a nation.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Not sure what you are saying A.Mac, in this post you are quite imprecise. I too thought that a citizen of the USA could not be an "enemy combatant."

I was wrong.

Should this person been deemed an enemy combatant?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Totally unworkable. They accuse bin laden of a crime, did he get "due process?" Completely, utterly, unworkable.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Not sure what you are saying A.Mac, in this post you are quite imprecise. I too thought that a citizen of the USA could not be an "enemy combatant."

I'm saying that because the Boston Marathon bombers are not participants in a declared war and are American citizens, the must be afforded rights under the Equal Protection Clause.

Enemy combatant is a term historically referring to members of the armed forces of the state with which another state is at war.

bin Laden was not an American citizen.

______________________________

Good to see you Terry.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Enemy combatant status has not been established.

From the link posted by wmolaw

Capturing and detaining a U.S. citizen, or any other human being, is not an activity DoD takes lightly. As in other armed conflicts in which our Nation has been engaged, the detention of enemy combatants serves a vitally important protective function. Equally important, however, the deliberate, conscientious, and humane manner in which we designate and detain enemy combatants reflects our values and character as a Nation. We are committed to defending the United States in accordance with our constitutional responsibilities, while preserving the constitutional rights of United States citizens.

The Marathon Bombings, in my opinion, in no way constitutes an "armed conflict" as in a declared war, which, the so-called "War on Terror" is not. Further, civilian police personnel and the FBI, not the American Military pursued the (alleged) perpetrators, killed one and captured the other, thus ending the event.

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

We touched on this briefly earlier today, and I do agree with the statement that this man should be tried on the basis of his status here in the states and not as a war criminal or enemy combatant. The term enemy combat though even in Iraq and Afghanistan has a lot of shades of gray with it. In the most recent conflicts there really hasn't been any uniformed combatants to place this monicker on which led to some of the scandals you may have read about when dealing with detainees. Because they are not uniformed (No rank and serial number and such) they did not fall under the military code of conduct for POW's. Now days we identify them by acts of aggression, ie. does he have a weapon and if he does is he trying to kill me or is he placing a bomb?, thats pretty much how they are identified in country and are then treated as a combatant.

may have digressed from point, which was lots of gray when using the term -enemy combatant- with non uniformed personnel.

Hope that made sense. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dustin Klinko
Freshman Silent
link   Dustin Klinko    13 years ago

Michael pretty much hit the nail on the head. I mean in Afghanistan right now it's hostile intent hostile act that makes them an enemy combatant. If they have a weapon but they aren't doing anything that would suggest hostile intent then they are fine. If they have a weapon and they are pointing it at you well that's a different story. If they are actually shooting at you then you are totally within your rights to shoot back. Point is the guy is an American whether we like it or not he does deserve a trial. He can't be considered an enemy combatant he was a US citizen. It would be a different story if he wasn't an American and he had ties to a foreign government.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

I think that is more probable than you think, Massachusetts has no death penalty. When they mirandized him he became a citizen again.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Gets a bit complex there Randy. If the Federal Government claims jurisdiction because it's an act of terrorism (possibly because of the weapon used), he would appear in the US District Court, and the deaths caused would be Federal crimes. If not, he has then been accused of several murders in the State of Massachusetts, a State crime. His lawyers might argue that the Federal Government has no jurisdiction over the murders and try to have it transferred to the State court. I doubt that Massachusetts Attorney General would try to assume jurisdiction in such a matter, though. That's for the same reason that the defendant's lawyers would try to get it transferred. Conviction in the State court would mean several life sentences. Conviction for the same acts in the Federal court would get him a needle in the arm.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Yep, that's what I thought likely. The bombs make the murders a Federal crime, and that means the death penalty. If, by some method, he manages to beat that, the State still has the murder of the police officer waiting for him.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Doesn't the fact that one of the victims was a Chinese citizen keep this in Federal Court?

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

Slayer of Trolls, your wisdom is fearsome, your skills masterful, I salute you. (Spoken in a stereotypical Asian voice)

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

It seems that at times our Constitution has become a manuscript of convenience for some. Like the truth, bent to fit a particular situation.

He is a citizen and should be tried as such.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

how can we possibly declare war when we refuse to use the word?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

how can we possibly declare war when we refuse to use the word?

Possibly you'll explain that with specifics; otherwise it's a quip and quite oblique.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

shall not be infringed

No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State depriveanyperson of life, liberty, or property

Exactly my point; it can't be both ways. If one believes that the 2nd Amendment cannot be abrogated based on any extenuating circumstances, then it logically follows that neither can the 5th and 14th Amendments.

Interesting how many right-wing legislators and 2nd Amendment strict-constructionist defenders are hypocrites in their disparate positions on these Amendments.

Thanks, Mike for showing the parallels and divergences via your examples.

However, YOU OMITTED SOME KEY 14th Amendment WORDS there is a caveat you may have missed.

Section. 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Individuals who violate laws and who are convicted via due process provisions of law, depending on which law(s) are violated, as the penalties of law dictate, can be deprived of, life, liberty, and/or property.

Thus, the Constitution contains a proviso that may indeed LEGALLY AND PROPERLY abrogate or INFRINGE UPON certain rights.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

This young man definitely belongs in the court system here in the U.S., even as a registered alien, naturalized citizen or whatever, he had a responsibility to respect the laws of this country and the state of Massachusetts, and he should be tried in civilian court for the crimes he perpetrated.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

"generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties"

~bho

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties"

~bho

Another disjointed comment, and what does it mean in the context of this thread? It's a perfect example of the phrase, "A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing."

Try putting your quips in context if for no other reason, to show that you can provide both heat and LIGHT!

The quote that you and other righties love to cite out of context doesn't indicate whether or not Obama believes that "the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties". He said that the Warren court interpreted the Constitution as if it were a charter of negative liberties. Because he used the phrase "at least as it's been interpreted" a case could be made that he personally doesn't hold that conviction.


Bowers v DeVito -- on the phrase "charter of negative rights".

"There is a constitutional right not to be murdered by a state officer, for the state violates the Fourteenth Amendment when its officer, acting under color of state law, deprives a person of life without due process of law."
Brazier v. Cherry, 293 F.2d 401, 404-05 (5th Cir. 1961).
"But there is no constitutional right to be protected by the state against being murdered by criminals or madmen. It is monstrous if the state fails to protect its residents against such predators but it does not violate the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment or, we suppose, any other provision of the Constitution. The Constitution is a charter of negative liberties; it tells the state to let people alone; it does not require the federal government or the state to provide services, even so elementary a service as maintaining law and order."
Stop being a "parrot" and defend your positions by explaining them then defending them.
 
 

Who is online









133 visitors