╌>

The Art of Compromise

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  broliver-thesquirrel-stagnasty  •  13 years ago  •  12 comments

The Art of Compromise

Now that we have entered into this bold new age of bipartisan cooperation (snicker), I think that it is time to reflect on just how we arrived at this point in history.

In 1787 there was a meeting in Philadelphia- the Constitutional Convention was called because the country, organized under the Articles of Confederation in 1777, was bankrupt.

Go here for more info on this. http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/convention1787.html

Two plans emerged and, over the course of the summer through much debate and argument, what we now know of as the Constitution of the United States of America was arrived at and signed by 39 of the 55 delegates to the convention. The wheels of time have proven the majority of that document to have been substantially resilient and up to the task of being the framework for laws of governing the country. (Boy that sentence sounds a bit pretentious, does it not?)

The important thing here is to realize the delegates may have had opinions about the different things that were debated, some even thought that they were exceeding their mandated task (which was to fix the Articles of Confederation), but in the end they came up with a plan on paper that the majority of them could sign.

I am sure that granting the status of 3/5 of a person for black men stuck in the craw of both the southern and the northern delegates, albeit for differing reasons.

I am sure that the larger population centers wanted representation to only be based on population, the smaller states wanted representation to be based equally between the states.

I am sure the anti-federalists wanted the central government to be subservient to the states in all matters, while the federalists wanted a strong central government with veto power over the laws of the states.

But even though they had to swallow their bile and vote for something that, to one section or the other, may have seemed to have been antithetical, they did.

Know what? The earth did not stop rotating on its axis because they compromised. I think these people, the Founding Fathers, had deep and dearly held beliefs that many would have thought insurmountable. But they compromised nonetheless.

What happened? People did not start running rampant and behaving in a scurrilous fashion. These specters of modern politics did not occur because they were (and still are) just that, specters. Ghosts, allusion to illusion used to make people feel in a certain way. Because if you have someone telling you the world is going to end, you will go to extremes that you might not otherwise to stop that from occurring.

(So, what the hell is your point? I've been reading for the last 450+ words, when are you going to get to the point?)

It is hard, when indoctrinated by life to viewing the world from one perspective, to lift ones-self out of that perspective and to truly see things another way. It is difficult to shed the doctrines learned from a lifetime of experience and self-preservation. It may even be impossible to do. Regardless of your point of view, sometimes the things that need to be done rise to the level of revulsion, but we have to do them because there is no other choice. (Like last year when Paulson had to bail out the banks.)

In 1787 a group of people got together in Philadelphia because the Articles of Confederation were insufficient for holding the United States together. Through a long, hot and sticky summer they debated until they had a fix for the problems that affected the United States. None of them got everything they wanted, some of them even left early in opposition to the document that was emerging. But we got something out of the deal that would at least see us along for a little bit.

The lesson that I take from all of this is that sometimes you just have to do the unpleasant thing. It seems that we are at such a point in our nation when we have to do something that is unpalatable to most people. We would rather not plunge more and more into debt as a nation, but the alternative in humanitarian terms and effects on the ecocnomy seem even more reprehensible.

The Republican mantra of cut taxes/regulation so the people can have their money just met the human vices of gluttony and greed. They have wandered from their path of conservative values and increased the size of government while effectively decresing the funding for the same, The Democratic mantra (ironically assigned to them by the Republicans, Dem's can't seem to get the whole "on message" thing down, the republicans had to self destruct before they came up with "change", which the Repub's immediately co-opted but I blather) of tax and spend just met the reality of a shrinking tax base and growing unemployment.

The truth is anybody can lead when times are booming, and the hard times to lead are, well, the hard times.

So suck it up and go on, get out there and compromise, because I don't want to listen to you complain, and quite frankly, we owe to our nation a great debt which will not be repaid by sniping at one another from entrenched positions waiting for the next election cycle so we can show everybody all the bad things that the "other guys" have done. In short, grow up.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

What more can one say?

I remember a 60-Minutes piece years ago just as John Boehner was set to become speaker of the house, and he couldn't even say the word "compromise". Look no further than that to understand why congress is so dysfunctional.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Some of you may remember this article from the other site. Dusted it off and brought it back to life, still seems appropriate, as do some of the responses, of which this is one:

The mind it starts, the eyes are shut, to walk about, to willingly not see...

The brain awake, in fear it's hate, comes to slake the knife of ignorance.

Slice the mind willingly offered up, Bludgeon that which protests or does not agree...

_______

Wonderful..... Just wonderful. /s/

B.S.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Why don't you go take a trip on Neale Osborn's thread on "Compromise".

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Looking at the time stamp you would be correct.

I find debate on these sites somewhat akin to trying to thread a needle with a sledgehammer. Under most conditions it is like what they say in Vegas..... "Trying to make your point the hard way!"

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

"the new age of bipartisan cooperation (snicker)" - is it a dream? I think we have lost the ability to see beyond the end of our noses, Brolly, and beyond the end of our political ambitions. I wonder what it will take for today's politicians and citizens to reignite purposeful discourse and the art and skill of compromise! We obviously haven't arrived that point yet. Excellent post!

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

PersonallyI think the current lack of cooperation (or compromise) can be traced back to Mr. Gingrich in the mid-nineties when the GOP went after Clinton via Whitewater. Now it is on steroids and beyond the pale.

Nice article.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Does it really matter where we started to demonize the other side? I stand in stupefied amazement of the discord eating the country, promulgated by the various factions wanting control and power. Here is a reply that I gave on the original article .


The fact is, the attacks come as fast and furious from all parties involved. If you poke around a bit on my homepage, you will find that I am not religious and I don't hold to party politics of any stripe. I am libertarian in that I think the government should be kept out of personal issues but be the insurer of the rights of the individual.

I also think that institutions larger than the individual should neccesarily be regulated due to the innate ability of an institution, be it company, club, or religion, to gain and manipulate political and economic power. To this end, I feel we need a Federal government to maintain rights and enforce regulations over the country as a whole instead of a smattering of regulations and piecemeal enforcement.

We have strayed from the original purpose of our government. When the Constitutional Convention met in 1787, the Articles of Confederation were nearer to breaking the country up than holding it together. The states were arguing among themselves and the delegates to the Continental Congress realized that action was required to keep the fledgeling nation from fracturing and imploding from within. The States were not voluntarily paying the Congress to pay off the Debts incurred by the Revolutionary War and the Congress had no means to compell them. So amidst this backdrop of hodge podge democratic structures they called the convention in 1787 to "fix" the Articles of Confederation.

I see the same fracturing going on today. I see states passing laws to thumb their noses at the federal government, weaselworded so as to bring a definite "State Right" by the letter of the Constitution while ignoring the broader implications that such a law would have on the "spirit" of the constitution. I see talking heads exhorting the present administration to fail in its endeavors to help the American people, not out of a wish for good, (I am not even going to go into how the govts efforts failing could somehow be good for the people or the country) but out of the prospect of retaining power. But I see equal moral corruptness from the other side of the aisle, rushing to get all of their goodies in the stimulus package.

But what really bothers me is the tone and tenor of the political conversation in america today. We have our differences in ideology, and that is fine. I t is when both sides cannot admit that there might be a kernal of reason, goodness or truth to the other sides positions, well that is when to consider the systems as broken. Not necessarily the government and the laws, but the structure which the parties have imposed on that system is what is wrong. The underlying structure is solid and strong, the facade which these parties have imposed upon it is what is the weakness.

Strip away the facade, break the barriers to cooperation by saying enough to the politicains and pundits who are only existing to lust after power as a way to money. Remove the false dichotomous thinking of both parties and put the true good, not the good that somebody tells you but the good that you feel deep down inyour soul to be right. Cut out the yammering from the right and left and delve deeply into the issues, aware at all times that the sources of information could and probably do have a vested interest in your seeing things "Their way."

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

No in truth it matters not the who or the when, I myself would rather it died a natural death and the sooner the better as far as I am concerned.

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

The crux of the matter lies right where you have written it, Brolly:

We have our differences in ideology, and that is fine. I t is when both sides cannot admit that there might be a kernal of reason, goodness or truth to the other sides positions, well that is when to consider the systems as broken

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Now that was well and nicely said.

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

Thank you, luther! Unless you weren't referring to my comment or the quote I was referring to!

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

It is kind of hard to hold one's breath, Troll - I think many of us have been holding it a long time! I fear we are going to go deeper into the mire before there is a chance of reason and rationality surfacing again.Frown.gif

 
 

Who is online







122 visitors