╌>

US justices struggle in weighing American Indian adoption case

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  1stwarrior  •  13 years ago  •  2 comments

US justices struggle in weighing American Indian adoption case

http://news.msn.com/us/us-justices-struggle-in-weighing-american-indian-adoption-case

What's so hard 'bout this case? Follow the law as written - no questions needed.

A father is trying to take custody of his daughter, now 3 years old, even though she was legally adopted when the child's mother gave her up for adoption.

WASHINGTON U.S. Supreme Court justices appeared conflicted on Tuesday as they debated the delicate question of whether an American Indian father could take custody of his child from a couple who legally adopted her.

The nine-member court has to determine whether the Indian Child Welfare Act, a law passed in 1978 to prevent Indian families from being torn apart by government welfare agencies, allows Dusten Brown custody of his child, even though he had at one point said he would give up his parental rights.

Several justices, including Chief Justice John Roberts, who has two adopted children, appeared sympathetic to the South Carolina couple who adopted the girl, Veronica, who is now three.

But at least two members of the court, Justice Antonin Scalia and Justice Sonia Sotomayor, indicated some support for Brown, and others appeared unsure how to proceed. Justice Clarence Thomas, who took custody of a grandnephew in 1997, did not speak during the argument.

Brown, a member of the Cherokee Nation, a federally recognized American Indian tribe, and a soldier at Fort Sill, Okla., invoked the federal law when the child's mother, Christina Maldonado, gave Veronica up for adoption.

The adoptive parents, Matt and Melanie Capobianco, a Boeing technician and developmental psychologist who live in Charleston, S.C., had custody of Veronica from just after her birth in September 2009. Brown took custody in December 2011 after a South Carolina court ruled in his favor.

In reviewing the case, the justices struggled openly with how to apply the federal law, which did not appear to have anticipated the type of dispute before the court.

Justice Anthony Kennedy summed up the atmosphere in the courtroom when he noted that custody cases are the "hardest problems for judges."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

I really have a hard time believing the attorney for the foster parents actually said - "The adoptive parents' lawyer, Lisa Blatt, sought to take advantage of that sense of unease in an impassioned closing argument. She said a ruling in favor of the biological father would mean the court is "basically relegating the child to a piece of property with a sign that says: 'Indian, keep off. Do not disturb.'"

That's what we've heard for over 300 years -"If it's Indian, take it - they don't need it." Ahhhh - memories of the ol' boarding school days.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Sounds to me like we have conflicting laws here. One supporting the adoptive parents' rights and one supporting Native American rights (but that law was never intended to apply to adoption, but rather to GOVERNMENT intervention in Native American families). I wouldn't want to be a SCOTUS Justice on this one.

 
 

Who is online







122 visitors