Bombs at the Boston Marathon … if an Act of Terror, Here's My Thoughts
Terrorism is defined as " the use of violence and intimidation in the pursuit of political aims." When it is perpetrated in the name of religion it is not only insidious, it is the ultimate hypocrisy as well. For the sake of irony, assuming the explosions at the Boston Marathon were the actions of religious-political extremists, I preface my commentary with a biblical rationale for what I admit in advance, is barbaric but possibly necessary and long overdue.
Ecclesiates 9:10
Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might.
THE GRID
Forget tough talk and rhetoric -- heres my idea of an actual although ugly plan for fighting terrorism (assuming the recent bombing at Boston Marathon is terror-related and Mid-East in origin).
In military or police operations, the rules of engagement (ROE) determine when, where and how force shall be used. Such rules are both general and specific, and there have been large variations between cultures throughout history; typically ROE are only fully known to the force that intends to use them. (Wikipedia)
The so-called War on Terror has been primarily though not entirely reactionary to incidents perpetrated against civilization by Islamofascists whose ROE include the unconscionable murdering of innocent civilians and, their use of hostages and human shields. Much of the so-called War on Terror has been the use of fear and propaganda to create windfall opportunities for war-profiteers; there were and may still be more private contractors in Iraq than military personnel. And the war in Iraq had nothing to do with pursuing Al Qaeda (until the resultant area destabilization brought the terrorists there).
By terrorist design, all nations, cultures and individuals are fair game, thus leaving potential target populations with a serious dilemma, namely; If innocent individuals will be harmed by terrorists in order to achieve their objectives, to protect ourselves, at some point, in retaliation for terror incidents, wont we possibly need to choose between our innocent citizens or theirs? By theirs I mean those innocent civilians living within geographical proximity to terrorist-sympathizer countries. But In this group I do NOT include civilians who willingly harbor or subsidize terrorists as "innocent". Innocent
means innocent. Literally.
Dilemma is defined as a situation requiring a choice between two evils; any embarrassing or perplexing situation; a difficult choice.
Given this dilemma, I offer the following as a DETERRENT TO TERRORISM, ONE I HOPE WE WILL NEVER NEED TO IMPLEMENT!
As follows:
1) The United States and our allies should State clearly and regularly to the world, the rules of engagement that have been set by the terrorists, and not the so-called civilized word.
2) The United States and our allies should Create a GRID, one that graphically divides the Middle East (primary home of Islamofascism) into blocks and
clearly and regularly make its existence known to the world.
3) The United States and our allies should Encourage any/all citizens of the Middle East having knowledge of terrorist individuals, camps, enterprises, etc., to hand them out (as opposed, for instance, to electing them to government office as in Lebanon and Palestine).
4) After an extensive world-wide campaign to publicize the GRID, The United States and our allies should declare that any and all acts of terror deemed to have originated directly or indirectly from within the GRID or its sphere of influence, will result in one or more blocks of the grid being rendered uninhabitable (with no stated specifics).
5) Regularly and through extensive means of communications, the United States and its allies and any/all other interested nations should offer a willingness to attempt to end terrorism diplomatically without implementing these ROE. And not everything should constitute a diplomatic option. Ideas such as the forced or negotiated imposition of any, single religion/ideology upon the world would constitute a deal breaker.
Am I aware of the ugliness of my ROE and "The Grid" proposal? indeed I am. But my GRID strategy is primarily directed towards (among others), the tough-talking, indignant man-on-the-street and neo-conservative politicians, who want to send everyones kid to war but their own; and the so-called "war-on-terror" to which they nebulously refer with neither candor nor specificity, seems to go nowhere in particular because as a "war," it is unconventional and being waged against a psychotic-ideology.
Let's minimize the rhetoric and put the "hammer" on the table for all to see.
AND NOT BE AFRAID TO USE IT.
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

NOTE: I have in mind, another possible suspect(s) but I will not state it. In the event it is advanced by a law enforcement/reliable source, I will indicate that it had crossed my mind and the reason why.
"patriot" "grudge"
You're in my ballpark with those but that's as far as I'll go.
AND NOT BE AFRAID TO USE IT.
And therein lies the problem since we have over the years been in some sort of position where we should have used a scorched earth response and did not have the nerve to pull the trigger. (Think 9/11 here.) The world knows that we have become, or always have been, a paper tiger with no teeth and so the beat goes on. In order for this to come to fruition supposed innocent civilians will die. The world does not want a repeat of the WWII carnage and we are terrified of world opinion. That in essence is what is going to have to happen in order to restore world order.
If we had to fight WWII like that we would have lost for sure. I can just see myself standing in front of a Banzai charge waving a red flag. Is it any wonder that we have not won a decisive war since.
Jason,
My plan is clear to a point and intentionally nebulous for the purpose of generating fear and speculation in potential victims; "rendering a part of the grid uninhabitable" does two things
1) It creates great apprehension among all in the terrorist-sympathizing areas of the world (primarily the Middle East)
2) It is plausible logistically and warns that "any/all" acts deemed as "acts of terror" could result in retaliatory mayhem; it is intentionally nebulous enough to incentivize handing over known or suspected terrorists where they live and/or wield influence.
And again, for the record, I don't dismiss the possibility of another perpetrator altogether.
The "GRID" is intended to incentivize those citizens who might otherwise be reluctant to hand over terrorists "responsible parties." Of course it evokes action by forcing people to choose between one fear (that of terrorists) and another (that of the consequences of ignoring the "GRID").
And so if the citizens knowing just who the "responsible parties" are refuse to cooperate do we then classify them as "enemy combatants" and, if we do, what then?
What I asking in my simple way here is just when do you pull the trigger and what will you accomplish? Where does the "Good Cop" end and the "Bad Cop" begin in the world of public opinion?
There's no way of identifying for certain who knows the "responsible parties." The "GRID" presumes that the fear of "rendering inhabitable", blocks in that grid, might generate some handovers.
The "GRID" does not concern itself with world opinion, rather, it attempts to make the world safer by (hopefully) making life more threatening to terrorists by giving "innocent" (or otherwise) civilians a choice between being courageous or finding their neighborhoods "uninhabitable."
Note I did not stipulate "killing" anyone. How many million gallons of i.e. cat urine does it take to clear an area? How many areas have to be cleared until lots of displaced "innocents" decide to discuss "options," options like starting to turn in bad guys?
My gut tells me this isn't Islamic terrorists. I fear it may be someone opposed to gun control who wants to "prove" that you don't need guns to cause mayhem and death. I pray I am wrong. Under the circumstances, it is more likely North Korea who is responsible. (Do they have a history of terrorism? Maybe they're just learning it)
Let's not forget that this race is historically run on "Patriots Day" - which is today.
My biggest fear is that the current Administration will use this as an excuse to implement further restrictions on the freedoms of the American people.
That's exactly my "other" possible perpetrator. The Marathon was a sponsor for a fund raiser for the victims of Newtown!
Such as? If it is an "anti gun control" act of terror, who then threatens our freedoms?
My "plan" is tongue-in-cheek" but every "shooting" war displaces people (if not kills them). Early in the article I used the word "dilemma" and I also explained that the terrorists ROE created that dilemma. I also stated that the GRID is "barbaric".
Realistically, the actions of a couple or a dozen people should not affect the rest of us. Whoever did this is sick and twisted. But I know that the day is coming when we're going to hear the words Martial Law, and it's going to be bad.
"At least two American lawmakers have stated on the record that, in their opinion, Section 1031 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2012 legalizes or authorizes martial law in the United States. Senator Mark Udall stated "These provisions raise serious questions as to who we are as a society and what our Constitution seeks to protect...Section 1031 essentially repeals the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878 by authorizing the U.S. military to perform law enforcement functions on American soil." [
Is the timing a coincidence or something more sinister?
Based SPECIFICALLY on what?
Wayne LaPierre?
Martial Law for specific areas. But all encompassing Martial Law for the entire country. Will never happen as there just isn't enough military to pull that off. We would then be looking at what happens when illegal orders are given that can not be enforced.
Based on Nothing and everything. Just a feeling I have. The general discontent of the American Citizens, the vitriol of the gun control crowd (both sides), the rhetoric by republicans about killing Americans on American soil, the extension of the Patriot Act, the use of drones over this country. Everything's going to hell in a hand basket and I feel as though we're living in a powder keg waiting for it to explode. Again, just a feeling. Nothing concrete but enough harsh words on the left and the right for violence to break out. Kent State times a million.
Well, we agree that the rhetoric from both sides cannot lead to anything positive.
Peace to you, Boudicea; I hope you are wrong.
I hope so, too, Mac
Sure did open Pandora's Box here A Mac! Pretty much underscores just how much undercurrent there truly is though doesn't it??
If it had not have been me, someone else for sure would have gotten the ball rolling. As a retired newspaper editor and editorial writer, it just comes naturally.
Considering the divergence of thoughts here it is interesting to follow!
First it was a Texas ADA then the Sheriff and his wife now other events possibly tied to...
Are there similarities--Patriot's Day(3rd Monday in April),Tax Day(4/15), Oklahoma City bombing(4/19), Waco(4/19)?
We do that A. Macarthur and we might as well burn the Constitution, tear up the American Flag, and destroy our entire system of government as we would be going against everything America is supposed to stand for. Human rights if even the United States wont mostly respect them this would create a very bad precedent in the world. You can indeed only deal with violent extremist with the sword as it is kill or be killed but we need not intentionally kill those around them. This is Old Testament mentality an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth and this very concept is the reason why we as humanity are still killing each other in the name of so called justice. It is not justice though but vengeance.
I will end with Biblical verses in which you began with a biblical verse
Matthew Chapter 5 vs. 38-47 KJV
"38 Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: 39 But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also. 40 And if any man will sue thee at the law, and take away thy coat, let him have thy cloke also. 41 And whosoever shall compel thee to go a mile, go with him twain. 42 Give to him that asketh thee, and from him that would borrow of thee turn not thou away.
43 Ye have heard that it hath been said, Thou shalt love thy neighbour, and hate thine enemy. 44 But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you; 45 That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust. 46 For if ye love them which love you, what reward have ye? do not even the publicans the same? 47 And if ye salute your brethren only, what do ye more than others ? do not even the publicans so?"
I am no longer a person of faith but many of the principles of Christ in the New Testament are still good principles to follow in my opinion. In other words if one wants to look at this from a Christian perspective this idea is not Christ like. Perhaps this principle is indeed almost impossible to actually obtain but should we not strive for it. I am not a pacifist there is a time for war and self protection, but we should keep this principle in the back of our minds even in such a time. If we do not I fear humanity is destined for self destruction.
Just a note. Though gov officials have been careful not to call these bombings terrorist acts, the media has already decided they are. WTF? I hate the media. Facts don't seem to matter to them
You either failed to note the various caveats I included in my article, the assertions that the idea is "barbaric," the fact that I did not advocate killing anyone and/or a subsequent comment that the article is tongue-in-cheek.
But my article does pose the rhetorical question of how to deal with terrorists who wage unconventional war with extreme ROE.
When I advocate rendering areas "uninhabitable," I don't mean by bombing or burning or shooting. I used the example of millions of gallons of i.e. cat urine as another tongue-in-cheek way of forcing those out of an area until a number of residents of a number of uninhabitable areas begin to realize that their are non-violent ways to wreak havoc and motivate the outing of terrorists.
Turning the other cheek won't thwart terrorists; making life miserable for the heretofore unwilling to out them just might.
I am aware you were being rhetorical I was simply stating if we were to put these rhetorical ideas into practice we would be going against our Nation's deepest principles and against anything remotely Christian. I am all for making extremist very uncomfortable but I don't want to starve their children and punish their wives for the sins of the terrorist. I just think there is a better way.
Use a weapon of mass destruction outside of war it is a terrorist act, use it within war it is an act of war. No matter the purpose of planting the explosives it is an act of terrorism. Perhaps it is a weapon of mass destruction on a small scale but the concept is the same to cause mass casualties and terrorize people.
Mickey - even if it WAS the US govt behind it we would never know. So....
Gotta hand it to ya, A Mac... between your post & TF's, you guys have drawn more cockroaches out of the NTwoodwork than there are shoes to whack 'em. Fess up... did you two collaborate on this?
Gotta love this Internet thing-- nobody actually knows jack shit at this point, but everybody & his half-wit brother's got some halfass axe to grind. It's Muslim terrorist gun-control anti-gun-control government martial-law black-helicopter jihadist Waco-sympathizin' gay-rights NWO Zionists, fer sure... an' if it ain't, we oughta just kill all the suspicious-lookin' muhfuggahs anyway, just so 'they' know we mean business...
In truth it was an electrical fire. This is what happens when folks jump to conclusions.
Yeah and all the news outlets around the world decided to join us ...
As for "axes to grind," have you heard about 9-11 and Oklahoma City, the Underwear Bomber, the Show Bomber and a bunch of other such stunts?
My rant is anything but run-of-the-mill; it addresses the dilemma the civilized world faces because of acts of terrorism. Got anything to add on the topic or do you just want to critique human reactions to tragedy?
And yet, no one seems to have one to advance.
As for religious doctrine and how it may apply take your pick:
There was a fire, and in the first press conference the commisioner said it was an explosion and were treating as related, but in a later press conference, they walked that back and aren't sure if it was related or even an intentional event.
Two fires and two explosions on the same street, 100 yards apart. Shrapnel.
Speculation is only natural particularly in the world-as-we-know-it.
You mentioned NK, for whatever reason that was one of my initial thoughts only because of the current posturing. maybe they wanted to do something that inflicted pain without being blamed for it. Has anyone heard of a group claiming responsibility?
Me personally, im all in for carpet bombing cities. This "lets help every one we end up attacking back to their feet" is getting old and making America look weak. Maybe its time that we started going hard, old testament kinda. The problem isnt with the people its with the ideology. If you make the repercussions to believing in this stupid thought process so unimaginable, people will stop believing.
Guess we will need lame joke free zones too
Thats why I spit on your chicken.
I have said this in the past but it bears repeating: If we had been forced to fight WWII using the current ROEs where you can go to war but under no circumstances are you allowed to bring harm to your enemy, we would have lost that war.
The JFK library is rather far away that is what is being discussed. I should have mentioned that.
Thank you for the clarification.
Actually AM, I hadn't thought of your post as particularlya "rant" at all... Your basic idea goes back at least as far as Roman times, when they made it clear to everybody that 'you don't fuck w/ the Empire'. My 'rant' after 9-11 was to take out a couple square blocks & 4000 people every 24 hours until they handed over bin Laden & friends... I think a million gallons of cat piss (I'd toss in some pig shit for good measure) is really pretty civilized.
Of course 'all the news outlets around the world decided to join...'-- An axe-murderer sells newpapers.
As of last nite (and today as well), nobody knew/knows diddley-squat; in two articles on NT, the short list included: Taliban, al Queda, domestic terrorists, lone-wolf nutballs, anti-gun-control radicals, and of course an FBI/CIA-initiated civilian attack to pave the way for martial law... Human reactions to tragedy are naturally grief, sorrow, anger & frustration-- resulting in eleventeen different versions of "Here's my Boogeyman, who's yours?" hence, "halfass axe to grind".
Agreed, swamijim sez, and I am only human. But I did not say who is responsible for this tragedy, I made it clear from the opening of my article that I was hypothesizing one possible scenario
If God involved Himself in the day-to-day crap, this and other incidents where bad things happen to good people would be cut off before they materialized.
If I may please allow me to also hypothesize that under NO circumstances will the investigators find either someone from the Nation of Islam or an agent of the Coocoo bird of the north, responsible. Although from where I sit it would not make too much difference anyway because the American People have had their collectives nerves pulled. Just look around you at the ongoing crap being pulled off against this country and its people and our only response has been to talk the problem to death.Leaves me with the unanswered question of: Just when s too much too much for modern America?Have a nice day.
Let's try to keep the politics out of this for as long as we can shall we?
Remember Oklahoma City..... everyone was sure it was a Islamic attack. Let the FBI do it's work and lets keep the finger pointing to a minimum.
Our politics have created the "terrorists" that we fight.
So in essence here you are saying that we are to blame for the indiscriminate killing of our people and we are getting what we deserve, right?
It is our greed for resources to exploit that causes us to appropriate said resources for ourselves.
How's all of the petro dollars that we are getting from Iraq working out for you?
How about the profits from the trillions of dollars worth of precious metals we discovered in Afghanistan which Karzai sold secretly to the Russians and China. Doesn't carrying around all of that ill gotten booty weigh your conscience down just a tad?
As from all of the evidence currently available --
Calling it for what it is -- a terrorist act -- is the easy part. Whether or not it is foriegn or domestic is still to be determined, but Obama cannot even refer to it as a terrorist act.
So, even though I like your idea, the one man who could actually implement it does not even have the stones to call a terrorist act a terrorist act .
Simply another instance of an out of time dinosaur who has lived too long. Knowing this we should never have insinuated our noses into WWII but because we did This will be the results. I paid too high a price then in brothers and body parts to blindly accept that we no matter what are the bad guys of the world. Somebody once said to me that I no longer belonged here and should simply move on. I'm beginning to believe that he was right. I no longer belong here for this is not the America that I fought and bled for. Be well and thanks for the history lesson.
flameaway , Look at the plight of the "Native Americans"? I am full blooded Tsalagi, Cherokee, I'll save you the time looking it up, born on the res and I can tell you from experience just what the White Man is capable of doing.I have more than paid my dues and truly do not need lessons in ethics. Look to your own history.
A timely editorial may be deemed "premature" or, "too little too late." Either way, it's what the First Amendment allows and what the public seems to prefer.
Badfish, agreed!
Did you see the word "IF" in my headline; did you read the various self- deprecating comments within the article, the word "dilemma?"
After 9-11, we don't need a few more days to speculate based on the past being prologue. The article is tongue-in-cheek third time I've explained that.
it's an editorial one of thousands world-wide.
flameaway The fact that the American People continue to re-elect the same scoundrels to lead us knowing that they are at fault is what I find offensive. We have the ability as a people to change and yet we seemingly don't have the will. We have become what we fought that hellacious war to stop, the aggressor as opposed to the defender. We as a nation are captives to what Ike warned us about so many years ago and that is the Industrial/Military complex. The difference now is that it is an all powerful Industrial/Military/Financial Complex which is in itself governed by those same scoundrels that we keep electing to Congress and yes The White House, too. The question then is; what are we going to do about it? At my age where this adventure is almost over--not too much. That then lies with the younger generations to make right. We got here, in a word because of "Deregulation"in order for order to come out of this chaos business regulations are going to have to be re-imposed.
No apology is necessary nor are reminders required
since those of us who took bullets have very visual reminders of the cost of being free. In fact I feel that I must apologize to you for flaming you as I did.
As long as there are masses that vote their race, religion, gender and special interests EXCLUSIVELY, as a nation, we get the much of the crap we deserve.
A. Macarthur Point well taken. I rest my case concerning the free will of the people!
flameaway Thank you. I hope that the people can indeed get and stay riled up.
Peace = nvwatohiyadv
Looks difficult but it is what it is in any language!
The pictures by the way are a long time hobby no longer practiced. Another of the joys of growing older.
Indeed, you hit the nail on the head, Mac!
As much as I would like to see something like this happen I don't see how it could really work. Really these ppl that we are fighting are just crazy and to be honest they will point out anyone and say they are terrorists. You can't kill an idea either even in a low tech country like afghanistan the people are brainwashed. Most of the people don't care about whats going on in the world they have their mud hut their poppi and their 5 wives and fifteen kids to take care off. They could care less if anything else is going on in the world. They honestly just want to be left alone. They don't care where they get their money from as long as they have enough to feed themselves and their family.