╌>

Update: Did Bullying Cause Brianna's Death? Yes, but not at school...

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dowser  •  13 years ago  •  30 comments

Update:  Did Bullying Cause Brianna's Death?  Yes, but not at school...

6922_discussions.png A 13-year old girl at my son's middle school committed suicide Friday night. She had many friends at her school, and was loved by many of her fellow students.

My son is, naturally, VERY upset. He didn't know Brianna well, but he liked her.

Brianna's friends have said, (which I do not know is true or not), that Brianna went home from school on Friday, and got into an argument with her mother. When the argument was over, Brianna found a gun and shot herself in the head.

She may have been bullied at school, since her Facebook page discusses, "What kind of bullying is the most popular at your school?"

I have no facts, but my son says that she was a well-liked person.

Her friends at school read her last post on Facebook, that said she was killing herself because she couldn't please her mother. She wasn't as pretty, as smart, as whatever, as her younger brother or other family members.

Poor child. She was just another girl, another casualty. A pretty young girl who liked puppies. A girl who was a friend to everyone she met.

Who bullied Brianna-- Her peers at school? Her mother? We may never know, but here is another senseless tragedy.

Much will be made that she shot herself, that her parent(s) kept a gun in the house. But that's not what this article is about. Please do not use Brianna's death as a means to prove a political point-- as that is disrespectful of her. Or, if you do wish to discuss this in a larger political context-- take it outside, please.

I ask that you say a prayer, or send loving thoughts, to Brianna's friends and family--

Thank you for your thoughtful consideration!

Links:

Brianna's Facebook page

Brianna's Rememberance page

Update: We attended visitation this evening at the funeral home. The place was jammed, of course. Standing in line to get in, my family was standing behind a group of women and their girls, who were friends of Brianna. The women were joking and laughing, not so quietly, but not raucously, while her friends cried. One of the girls made a comment about how sad she was, as she wiped tears from her face.

The mother said to her friends, "That's just my unattractive younger daughter." And laughed it off.

I was stunned. These women were close friends of Brianna's mother. They showed not one iota of concern for the girl, OR for Brianna.

Then, we saw the mother's best friend. I knew her, shockingly enough. We worked together for about 6 years. She got tired of her husband, divorced him, and moved to California, taking her daughter with her, but leaving her son. For a long time, all she has really cared about was partying.

She bought a brand new expensive cell phone, then would sit in the office and fuss about having no money to buy food for her, "stinking kids". She came to work in new outfits all the time, had an expensive cell phone, and would send her kids to her ex's house to spend the night without clothes-- to make HIM buy them clothes.

Yes, I had to be nice, because we were former co-workers, etc. But, all she could talk about was her birthday, which is tomorrow, wasn't going to be much fun without Brianna's mother. She didn't even know the girl's name-- her mother's best friend didn't even know her name? WHAT???

What is wrong with these women?

Am I weird? My son and step-daughter represent the best things to happen to me in my life! Since when did selfishness become the norm? Even at the height of my step-daughter hating me, I would have NEVER said anything like that, even joking!

Magnum, with his clear eye, said they reminded him of bar-flies...

I am absolutely without words as to how this makes me feel. I do not know the family dynamics, or what went on, and I certainly know nothing of this girl. But, she was a math scholar, and she ran track. She was a pretty girl, and was obviously well-liked by her classmates.

How could anyone NOT cherish this dear girl? Is THIS part of why she felt the only way to go was out?

I just don't understand...

Brianna's obituary


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Thank you for your kind thoughts about Brianna. Peep helped me with the article, but he wanted to say how very sad he is at her death.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

The burning question to me is What made her so miserable that she felt the only way out was to take her own life?

There is no obit yet, in the paper... When there is, I'll post a link to it.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Dowser, first off I'm very sorry to hear of this young girls death. Te question that your asking, ''why''. We may never know the answer to that question. This is a very serious problem thoughout the U.S. and in Indian Country it is an epidemic, that everyone is trying to deal with. I hope that we can find an answer and not have to read stories like this one again.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Dear Kavika, I hope that we can get a handle on this somehow... I, too, have the same hopes.

We are going to the visitation tomorrow night. I hope that we can be of comfort to someone...

Take care, my dear friend. I love you very much!

 
 
 
GeeGee64
Freshman Silent
link   GeeGee64    13 years ago
((((Peep)))) I am so sorry about your friend. There are no words that can bring sense to this tragedy.There must have been demons in Brianna's life that she was unable to deal with. No one knows what really went on behind the closed doors of her home.Grieve for your friend, Peep. Then honor her by being the very best friend you can be to others. Be kind, be open, be understanding to those who are different, weird, unique. You would be amazed the difference it makes in a lonely person's life when someone takes the time to say hello - to acknowledge them - to recognize them as a fellow human life form.You are so lucky to have a mother who will help you get through this very difficult time. Talk to her. Tell her your thoughts and fears. She will listen and hold you close.Blessed be, son of my friend Dowser.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

I hope so, too.

13 years old... What a shame! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Thanks so much-- I'll read your message to Peep.

Peep heard your message, got a hug, and says thank you so much.

It's hard for him... Thank you, dear friend!

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

Neither bullying nor trouble at home caused her suicide. Depression did. I say this as someone who has suffered from depression my entire life.

Either bullying or trouble at home could have been the trigger, but they were not the cause. They are not an explanation even. People who are not suffering from depression have the emotionalresilienceto weather those storms. People with depression don't. Their thinking is radically altered. Things that seem trivial to others will feel overwhelming to those who are depressed. In fact, simply getting out of bed in the morning can feel overwhelming. That is the nature of the disease.

My heart hurts for this girl who was not longing for death but simply wanted the pain to stop. I hurt too for your son. I remember my teen years and how each death impacts deeply, even when we did not know the person well.

I have to leave now to go to store for dinner. More later.Frown.gif

 
 
 
Alan Curtis Montgomery
Freshman Silent
link   Alan Curtis Montgomery    13 years ago

Thanks Dowser for this article to honor another young person lost to suicide. I feel so sorry for what kids have to go to today, it is even more then what I went through over a decade ago. Bullying very well could have caused her to feel so hurt she did not want to live anymore. As could have untreated or not properly treated mental illness. Then again it could have been a momentary lapse into extreme despair in which she shot herself before she even had time to think about it. It has to be very hard on her loved ones and friends to lose someone close to them. I wish her family and friends healing and hope more people will begin to take bullying and suicide seriously. I made a recent video on the topic of suicide and seeded an article about bullying recently I hope they somehow encourage others to get involved trying to solve these problems.

Such a sad story and so tragic she thought suicide was a rational option to dealing with her pain. I know in a sense what she was feeling as I have been that much in despair before where I too considered suicide. I am glad I got psychological help before I actually attempted it. She was far too young to die and it did not have to be if perhaps someone could have reached out to her. Her mom, her friends, her teachers someone and then perhaps have gotten proper mental health treatment. There is no easy solution though in preventing suicide it like many things requires looking at many factors.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Alan, I understand, and want to thank you so much for your thoughtful, kind, and loving comment! Thank you!

The only time I felt like that was after my father died. I really thought about buying an old pair of football cleats, the metal ones, and waiting for thunderstorm. Then, I wanted to go out on a golf course in the storm, and raise an umbrella. Obviously, I was a chicken...

I got counseling and it helped.

I need to go and find your other article. Thank you, again, for your kindness, and your wonderful comment, that discusses the issue so well.

Whatever we can do, we need to desperately do something for the Native Americans, who have an unusually high incidence of suicide among young people. HOW HORRIBLE.

My son is very worried about several other classmates that have threatened suicide or talked of it. He has offered his friendship to these kids, and I hope that being with someone who is kind will help them-- he is very good with other kids. He wants to be an archaeologist, but he really has a gift for understanding children in trouble.

Thank you, again!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Oh, Loretta-- your posting is so kind about this girl, and you are so very right! I will look forward to your additional comments, and share them with Peep. He knows he is not at fault, but I think he still is very sad, and very worried about some of his other friends.

Thank you!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Kavika, I can't help thinking more about what you said about the suicide rate among young people is epidemic on the reservations. What can we do to help?

This bothers me on so many levels!!! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Dearest Augur-- I will pass this on to him this afternoon! I know that he will be touched and pleased by your message.

We are going to the visitation tonight, briefly.

Thank you so much for your help! Emotional support is the best we can do for each other... Smile.gif

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Another tragedy in what seems at times like an endless series of tragedies.

 
 
 
Strangerthanfiction
Freshman Silent
link   Strangerthanfiction    13 years ago

I am so sorry to hear this. You couldn't pay me to be a teenager again. You hear too many of these stories recently and it breaks my heart. take care...

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Oh Dowser, I am so sorry to hear this story. Please give Peep a hug. Something similar happened in my community last month. A lovely 14 year old girl hung herself and nobody knows why. There was no report of it in any newspaper, and the kids at school were only told that she had died and were offered counselling.

I think that the school was afraid that if they made a big deal out of it that the kids would start to glamorize tragedies like these. I just don't know what this world is coming to. Our children don't seem to understand the finality of death, the aftermath for those left behind. Perspective seems to be reserved for us older folks.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Dowser, they areattacking the problem of suicide on the rez with many different programs. I'm hopeful that they will find the answer.

Give Peep a hug for me Dowser.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

I hope so, too-- so very much!

I certainly will! We are going to the funeral home for visitation in a bit...

Thank you, my dear friend! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Peeps says Thank you and he will pass the message on to his friends at school. He is pretty much speechless, right now...

Thank you, dear friend!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

That is what we're thinking, too-- too much at once! I'm waiting for the 3rd shoe to drop...

Thanks, dear luther-- I really appreciate your kindness!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Me, either! Once was enough!

Thank you so much for your kind comment! Take care of you, too!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

That is the truth! I'm so sorry about the girl in you community. It is such a tragedy!

Thank you so much for your kindness and sympathy for Peep-- He really appreciates it! He is just very upset right now...

This, + Boston, + N. Korea, and he's worried... We're talking about it all, which is something...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

More information today-- as listed above...

17.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    13 years ago

Thanks so much-- it is hard for him, but he said that he was going to tell his friends at school exactly what you told him-- A life well-lived is the best way to keep Brianna's memory alive.

Poor little thing-- I feel so sorry about what her life must have been like... Frown.gif

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

I thought about suicide a lot when I was a teen. Times were simpler then and still those thoughts hung heavy in my mind. I can't imagine the black despair that surrounds a teen trying to navigate the far more complicated world of today.

When depressed, there is a feeling of helplessness and hopelessness. Nothing will ever change. Why stick around? That is the disease talking, and it feels so right. It is terrifying to think nothing will ever change when something bad is happening (like bullying or abuse), but depression distorts time. The only time that exists is the present.

I know a woman who attempted suicide. She was chronically depressed and on the phone to her mother. She told her mother she was thinking about suicide again but not to worry."I'm leaving right now to go see my therapist." Instead of leaving, she swallowed a bottle of pills. Her husband found her hours later. She survived, but the doctors were surprised. She later told me it was as if someone else took over her body and pushed her aside. The other person took the pills while she was screaming "No. I don't want to die." That's all she remembered until she woke up in ICU.

This is why I said the events of this girl's life did not take her life. The disease did. Depression is a lethal disease that we need to educate the public about, especially teens and children. We are so vulnerable at that age without the life experience to even begin to combat thisscourge. And yes, children can also beafflictedand try suicide.

What her survivors need is a lot of comforting and the knowledge it was not their fault. While it is possible they could have stopped her temporarily if they knew, it isn't their fault they did not know. Suicidal people are very secretive because they do not want to be stopped. Some are quite happy in advance because they've made their decision, arranged their affairs and have spent quality time with those they love. The feeling that the pain will soon stop causes the elation. Of course, others are more impulsive. Either way, they don't share their plans usually. Depression is a lonely disease. It brings the feeling of being unloved and unlovable no matter how many people love them and want to be with them.

I hope the emotional firestorm has lessened a bit today. It won't leave for a long while, unfortunately. Not only was she too young to die, her friends are too young to bear this burden. I hope they have a counselor to talk to about it. Talking helps. If we can share our thoughts with a sympathetic person, we know we are not facing it alone.

(((((Hugs across the miles)))) Wish I was there to help shoulder the burden.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The original article was sad, but the update almost made me sick. How can people be so callous? It reminds me of a job I once had. It was a small engineering office, about 15 employees. The owner and I got along great, but his VP was a weaselly prick who did very little but eat into your budget to support his bloated salary. I could never figure out why an intelligent guy like the boss would have ever kept this idiot around. Not only did he not assist in projects, but he would insist on attending important meetings in place of the designers in charge of the projects, and he would return with useless information because he didn't even know what kinds of questions needed to be asked, so he was actually a detriment. He knew I couldn't stand him from the day we met - my first day on the job, I went to grab a cup of coffee and he purposely stepped in front of me to pour the last of the pot into his cup, smiled at me and walked away. It was the equivalent of pissing on his turf.

Anyways - long story short, the owner dies (at 50) of mysterious causes after returning from vacation abroad. While he was jaundiced and deteriorating in his deathbed at the hospital, I overheard the VP along with the secretary and the boss's own brother (a dick-head cheapskate client), laughing it up over some conversation about power of attorney for the dyingboss. I wanted to puke at such tasteless demenor. The boss died, the VP immediatelybecamepresident and started driving the boss's companyvehicle and making all kinds of changes around the office that would have had the boss spinning in his grave. Not surprisingly, I wasfired as part of the "reorganization". From what I understand, the company has been floundering ever since. I wouldn't be at all surprised to find out some day that the boss was a victim of foul play.

 
 

Who is online







112 visitors