Austerity Economics, Democrat-Style "Obama Does Social Security and Medicare"
With Barack Obama putting his plan to cut Social Security and Medicare expenditures into writing in his Federal budget proposal the ability of those who voted for him to credibly deny his years of publicly stating he would do so disappeared. The pathetic pleas from liberals and progressives who only a few short months ago were assuring the unwashed masses Mr. Obama was on the cusp of a liberal renaissance if only doubters would join them in granting him another term are today as empty as their assurances were then. And Mr. Obamas self sacrifice of voluntarily giving up 5% of his own $400,000 per year salary in solidarity with seniors present and future who will see their Social Security payments reduced calls into question his intelligence if sincerethe difference between the rich (Mr. Obama) voluntarily giving up a fraction of their yacht allowance versus millions of seniors choosing between eating and living indoors is fundamental.
Those whose politics begin and end with rolling off the couch every few years to vote could in theory be forgiven for perceiving a yawning chasm between the Republican and Democrat candidates. Marketing firms were paid a lot of money to create that illusion. And Mr. Obama almost certainly has the political calculus correct that the bourgeois commentariat, a/k/a/ the left, will whimper in protest for a few days, weeks at most, before falling in line for Hillary or whatever militaristic, corporatist abomination the Democrats put forward in the next Presidential election. Early reports even have liberal pundits sticking with the line Mr. Obama is only posturing with the proposals, despite his near decade prior explaining why he believes Social Security and Medicare must be cut to be saved. However, this is truly a let them eat cake moment. Mr. Obamas policies will needlessly, and in economic terms gratuitously, hurt a lot of peopleoverwhelmingly those who self-identify as the Democrats political base. And lest there be confusion over the matter, in his first term Mr. Obama fully restored the fortunes of Americas ruling class at several trillion dollars of public expense before proposing these cuts.
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

I encourage you to read the entire article. It is long but worth it.
Cynical maybe, but true nonetheless. Just as only Nixon could go to China, only a democrat can get away with the changes the Wall St. folks insist upon without raising too much of a ruckus. The republicans are wrong that he is an evil socialist just as the democrats are wrong that he is some great liberal savior. He is just as he was put there to be, protector of Wall St. In that, he has done an excellent job.
Apparently Obama wants this as well. I just have to wonder how many republican economic policies Obama must champion before those who call themselves liberal start to go "uh, now wait just a minute."
Why? It's just another example of conservative bitching and moaning.
If you cannot take power and enforce an agenda then disparage and critique the "enemy".
If you are a Con then you should be celebrating ideas that promote that ideology...but nooooo! Let's take the negative path instead.
Which proves you did not click the link, or else you would know that it comes from Counterpunch, an Independent Progressive site.
RFA, I understand where you're coming from. Every year when I receive my SS statement, I can't help but fret about how muchjuicier my own personal portfolio would be had I been allowed to use that money myself. But the reality is that most folks do not have the same level of self-restraint that you and I have to plan for the future. These folks will not have this money as income at retirement. And YES, it WILL be OUR problem as they will then be cared for through other programs such as welfare, food stamps, and whatever else is out there. For this reason, I see SS as a necessary evil, though it hurts me financially on a personal basis.
Better that folks have a retirement income that we all contribute to rather than be on programs that are funded only by a few of us. Just my opinion, but at least (hopefully) you and I will get our share of SS when the time comes.
EI, I'm not sure but figured you might know; if the cap was raised above $113,000, am I correct in assuming that all it would do is raise the benefits for those making over $113,000?
10 Things Everyone Should Know About Social Security
As usual, in the discussion of social security cuts, we don't bother to bring up another issue - Supplemental Security Income. As you know, if you don't work, you don't earn enough credits to qualify for Social Security retirement income. So what happens then? You qualify for Supplemental Security Income - which is not part of the Social Security Act, and which is paid from general tax revenues - not Social Security taxes. If we don't start creating more jobs, the reduction in Social Security benefits is going to look miniscule compared to the increases we will see in Supplemental Security Income payments.
If you were born after 1929, you must have 10 years of work (years which qualify for the full 4 credits) to earn enough credits to be eligible for Social Security retirement or disability benefits. But now, with 101 million working age Americans not having a job, or having only a part-time job, we may be looking at a much larger problem than simply cutting existing Social Security benefits. We only have 2.7 working Americans for each Social Security recipient. Obviously this is unsustainable.
And just for fun, I give you a quote from FDR about Social Security:
We put those payroll contributions there so as to give the contributors a legal, moral, and political right to collect their pensions. With those taxes in there, no damn politician can ever scrap my social security program.
So what have we done? Created additional programs where you don't NEED to work, you don't NEED to make "contributions" and in short, you don't even NEED the Social Security program in order to be pretty much guaranteed some type of entitlement benefits (SSI) from the government. So, in that way, Obama isn't hurting anyone. He can always rob Peter to pay Paul.
Well....this is the reason I was banned from NV. I made the argument that anyone working for 45 years and only had Social Security to live on had not done anything to improve their lives.
All hell broke loose on me to think anyone should do anything to improve their lives and no one could afford to put a little back to add to their Social Security benefits.
Actually the underlying reason was I hadn't developed that collective mentality but instead was thinking out of the box as an individual.
Even when I accepted the fact not everyone, which was contrary to my original statement, could take the blame for some had extenuating circumstances that would prevent them from obtaining these goals, I was still criticized for even suggesting someone should not put all their faith in the government to take care of them and do everything for them.
The idea of someone doing all they could to improve their lives was incomprehensible.
Understanding the benefits of Social Security for all the other benefits it offers other than just a retirement income, inflation factors, income increase or decrease, disability, other responsibilities that hit you right in the face and make it impossible to accomplish these goals and expressing this understanding I used an example to why I thought you should wake up every morning and think what could you do to improve your and your future.
All I received was sarcasm and condemnation from the people who were on the vine at that time.
I just couldn't say anything without Cartoonthenews, who was able to post live links the very first day he joined from attacking me. Were any of you able to do that?
I figured that was Tyler posing as Cartoonthenews. He, Patango and David Blickenstaff told everyone in their responses to me for everyone to mark my comments as inflammatory and the next day Cartoonthenews, oh I mean Tyler banned me for spamming. The fact was I never spammed. Well you may understand. 1.5 years on vine, over 6100 comments, never suspended or warned. You figure. That's why I say "Banned for Nothing".
I know this is off topic at this point, but it does have a meaningful relationship to the main topic. Don't depend on Social Security as your sole source of income during your retirement years unless you have no ability or choice in the matter.
Let me say I understand not everyone can do this, but if you are working and paying taxes on your income, you are already paying a tax rate for Social Security and Medicare of 7.65 percent. Of this,the Social Security portion is 6.20 percent on earnings up to the applicable taxable maximum amount. The Medicare portion (HI) is 1.45 percent on all earnings.
We expect your income to go up when you consider all aspects of inflation. For example a 1964 Roosevelt dime is worth approximately $2.30 today just in the weight of the coin. Gas was 20 cents when I was a teenager.
Although some will tell you gold and silver go up and down as well and this is true, the fact is the only thing you can pretty much depend on is the value of the dollar will go down as it has gone down by 25% in the last 10 years.
Now the question is where is all that money we've been putting into the government's pocket?
Well....they put it in the General Fund and wrote IOU's on it. Well it's still there. Yea.... why don't you just give me your money and I promise to take care of you when you get old?
Well, if they had just used the money for the purpose it should have been designed for then we'd be in pretty good shape, maybe.
But as it is now we do have to increase the economy by receiving more taxes to pay all you old folks. I never grow old of course.
If you just put 1% of your income into the most secure investments averaging 3% which historically are more than that over 45 years over and above what you are putting into SS and Medicare and make it to retirement you could receive something over and above what you are going to receive on SS along. In time you could increase your percentage of deposit hopefully and have a significant increase in additional retirement income. Basically, don't put all your security in Social Security as your sole retirement plan.
You would still receive that pitiful Social Security check and also receive the additional check. With some tax changes to make it feasible to do this I think more people would realize Social Security is a Ponzi scheme and many never receive a dime from it.
In fact at least 10 to 12 percent never reach retirement age. Where's that money? Well it is used to support a system that is flawed not in its concept but by government policies over the years.
I do not promote getting rid of Social Security. I promote supplementing it individually. Then I think when people see the effects of compound interest when they reach retirement they will understand even if they die that day they still have money to leave behind to their heirs.
Of course with the present tax hungry leaders we have now the possibility may exist the government takes it anyway.
Interesting links:
Interesting...
Opting Out In Texas: Three Counties Leave The Social Security System
A specific example of smaller local units of government choosing to opt out of Social Security to design their own pension plans occurred in 1981, when Congress still allowed government units to make that choice. The three Texas gulf coast counties of Brazoria, Galveston, and Matagorda selected a private investment firm to manage their employees retirement plans with a guaranteed annual return of 6.5 percent.
By 1996 the results were in, and county employees retirement benefits were triple what would have been paid by Social Security for a worker who earned $20,000 per year and over five times the Social Security benefits for a worker whose pay was $50,000 (see Chart 4, next page). Congress closed the local government opt-out window in 1983 with major Social Security reform legislation that raised taxes and effectively reduced benefits by raising the eligible retirement age after 2015.
Now who is doing a better job of managing our money?
Wise words no matter what one's ideology. You got banned for that? Glad I left NV in the dust.
Hope you're doing well today EI.
If I have a mortgage.....what do I have? I have collateral? Now if I have a credit card with a balance on it, what do I have? An IOU like the government has for money borrowed from Social Security. Now which would we prefer to have? One says you can come and get my house if I don't pay for it and the other says.....good luck. LOL Or I could give you an IOU payable with Confederate Dollars. That is what the government's IOU's are to Social Security, payable in Confederate Dollars.
And Bill Clinton kept the public debt down by using Intragovernmental holdings which he borrowed from Social Security, producing more of those IOU's payable in Confederate Dollars.
Besides that Congress and the President can do whatever they want to do with Social Security regardless of what we want. They can even stop paying it if they want. They have a moral obligation, but not legal obligation to pay anything.
Tell me which one you think has worked, one that has no money but IOU's worth as much as a pile of Confederate Money that has to be paid by borrowing more money from in or out of the country by actual borrowing, reducing benefits, increasing taxes and isn't going to be sustainable as it presently exist without doing some or all of the above. I agree with you on growing the economy as one alternative, but it ain't happening.
How Three Texas Counties Created Personal Social Security Accounts and Prospered
Across the country, state and local governments are facing huge unfunded liabilities for their employee pension plans. And then theres Social Security.
But three neighboring Texas counties, which opted out of Social Security 30 years ago by creating personal retirement accounts, have avoided a fiscal train wreck while providing retirees with even more retirement income.
Galveston, Matagorda and Brazoria County employees, many of them union members, have seen their retirement savings grow every year, even during the Great Recession. If state and local governmentsand Congressare really looking for a path to long-term sustainable entitlement reform, they might start with what is referred to as the Alternate Plan.
Most proposals for creating a defined-contribution alternative to a state pension plan or Social Security use an IRA or 401(k) model. That is what the Utah legislature passed for new state employees beginning in July.
Under that model, the employees money, along with any employer contribution, goes into a personal account that invests in a limited number of approved options. Those accounts usually follow the stock market, in good times and in bad. Its those bad times, like the one the country recently went through, that critics point to when opposing personal retirement accounts.
But the Alternate Plan takes a different approach, one I call a banking model. Employee and employer contributions are actively managed by a financial plannerin this case, First Financial Benefits, Inc., of Houston, which both originated the plan and has managed it since inception.
The contributions are pooled, like bank deposits, and top-rated financial institutions bid on the money. Those institutions guarantee an interest rate that wont go below a base level, and could go higher if the market does well. Over the last decade, the accounts have earned between 3.75 percent and 5.75 percent every year, with an average of around 5 percent. The 1990s often saw even higher interest rates, 6.5 to 7 percent. Thus, when the market goes up, employees make more; and when the market goes down, employees still make something.
Like Social Security, employees contribute 6.2 percent of their income, with the county matching the contribution (Galveston has chosen to provide a slightly larger share). Once the county makes its contribution, its financial obligation is done. So there are no long-term unfunded liabilities.
But not all of that money goes into an employees retirement account. When financial planner Rick Gornto devised the Alternate Plan in 1981, he wanted it to be a complete substitute for Social Security. And Social Security isnt just a retirement fund; its social insurance that provides a death benefita whopping $255survivors insurance, and a disability benefit.
Part of the employer contribution in the Alternate Plan goes toward a term life insurance policy, which pays four times the employees salary tax free, up to a maximum of $215,000. Thats nearly 850 times Social Securitys death benefit.
More importantly, if a worker participating in Social Security dies before retirement, he loses his contribution (though part of that money might go to surviving children, if any, or a spouse who didnt work and therefore didnt establish his or her own benefits). But a worker in the Alternate Plan owns his account, so the entire account belongs to the estate. There is also, among other benefits, a disability benefit that pays immediately upon injury, rather than waiting six months, plus other restrictions, as under Social Security.
And those who retire under the Galveston model do much better than Social Security. For example:
What the Alternate Plan has demonstrated over 30 years is that personal retirement accounts work, with many retirees making more than twice what they would have made under Social Security. And that model could work for the roughly 25 percent of public employeesabout 6 million peoplewho are part of state and local government retirement plans. It could also serve as a model for reforming Social Security.
State and local governments that are currently outside of Social Security are giving serious consideration to shifting to a defined-contribution plan, as Utah has recently done. They should look into the Galveston model. As Texas Governor Rick Perry boasts of those three Texas counties, Employees in those private plans, having exercised their liberty at Washingtons sufferance, are reaping the benefits.
...
If Clinton balanced the budget then the national debt would not have continually gone up.
The Myth of the Clinton Surplus
Year
Ending
$133.29 billion
This is the link to the numbers above about the Myth of the Clinton Surplus.
This is information I can not verify below as I can't put my hands on the information I have somewhere.
Clinton ran deficits throught all 8 years of his term, and one can go to the US Treasury Department and looking through the history of the total outstanding debt through Clintons term.
Every year Clinton was in office, the total national debt continued to climb.
How Clinton managed to claim a surplus was that while the general operating budgets ran deficits but Clinton borrowed from numerous off budget funds to make the on budget fund a surplus.
For example, in 2000, Clinton claimed a $230B surplus, but Clinton borrowed
$152.3B from Social Security
$30.9B from Civil Service Retirement Fund
$18.5B from Federal Supplementary Medical insurance Trust Fund
$15.0B from Federal Hospital Insurance Trust Fund
$9.0B from the Federal Unemployment Trust Fund
$8.2B from Military Retirement Fund
$3.8B from Transportation Trust Funds
$1.8B from Employee Life Insurance & Retirement fund
$7.0B from others
Total borrowed from off budget funds $246.5B, meaning that his $230B surplus is actually a $16.5B deficit.
($246.5B borrowed - $230B claimed surplus = $16.5B actual deficit).
If there is ever a true surplus, then the national debt will go down.
the national debt did not go down one year during the Clinton administration.
The Texas plan may not be compared to Social Security but it certainly should be looked into more as a growing method of providing income for those in retirement without having a program that is completely bankrupt and has a bunch of IOUs, funded as by the working on a pay as you go and borrow all you need to meet your obligation.
It is a much more sensible alternative method than giving your money to Washington and expecting them to make wise decisions with it.
When a person on the Texas plan makes say $35,000 a year and passes away his beneficiaries will receive tax free $140,000 up front and still have all the money and interest this man and the county has put into the plan. The life insurance part is 4 times the employee's income.
I don't think Social Security has anything to compare with that. In fact if he has no widow or children and passes away at 55 the government keeps every dime his employer and he have put into Social Security.
The plan also includes a disability benefit. I don't know if it is an actual policy based on his pay or something else. I don't even know how much the benefit is or anything else about it. That would be a big factor.
Too many American's have grown use to the idea Social Security is their retirement fund and that's why so many have lost or had the habit of saving for the future.
Too many have put their futures in the hands of those least likely to be looking out for their better interest.
EI..... I sold insurance for quite a few years. I'm very familiar with all types of insurance.
I do know that if a person gets on disability they don't receive benefits on an insurance policy from the government. That was my point when I mentioned the disability benefit.
Big government people just can't get a grasp on anything but big government even when it screws them 98% of the time. That's what I meant as several other articles compared the ideas promoted by these three Texas counties as being a not so bad idea, including Politifact.
One thing we do agree on is we desperately need a growing economy. We just have different ideas of how to accomplish it. And we agree somewhat on parts of that as well.
I wonder how many would even pay payroll taxes if it was voluntary like a 401k or any other investment tool.
the mods and author of this article may decide if my post is out of place and may delete it if they choose. you simply reiterated mu h of what i said and ignored the main point. cutting social security nefits becomes completely irrelevant if it can be defacto replaced by the completely socialistic SSI benefits which are set benefits and not based on how much one has earned over their lifetimes. it is the great equalizer, in effect. there are no restrictions on who gets what. i believe the president is positioning the country for the day when the social securitymoney is gone and everybody gets SSI only IF they have not made personal choices which resulted in private pension money. if they have, they will get nothing. redistribution of personal wealth on yet another level. therefore, it is quite relevant to this discussion.
Just an FYI, Sixpick, but the "trust fund" has never been permitted to hold any assets except government IOUs (actually government bonds). That's the law. When the Social Security Act was taken to the SCOTUS to determine whether it was Constitutional, part of the decision was that SS was a TAX and not an insurance program. Thus, it has to be paid from tax revenues and/or cashing in those government IOUs in years when there is a short-fall.
The Trust Fund is managed by the Department of the Treasury , and overseen by a six-member Board. As payroll tax income comes into the Treasury each day, it is required by law to be invested in " securities guaranteed as to both principal and interest by the Federal government." This used to be ordinary, marketable Treasury notes whose value changed depending on demand in the secondary market. Therefore, Treasury created "special issue" securities that guarantee amount of the principal and interest no matter when they are redeemed, regardless of market conditions. Unlike Treasuries, they are only available to the trust funds. Benefits are paid out of the redemption of these "special issue" securities.
The payroll tax income itself goes into the General Fund. For this reason, some critics say the "special issue" securities are "nothing more than IOUs." That's because future benefits will have to come from "taxes that are being used today to pay for other government programs.
In 2010, the Obama tax cuts , reduced the OASDI payroll taxes by 2%, while extending the Bush tax cuts . In fact, that was the first year that Social Security income was not enough to cover benefits. The fund only received $637 billion from payroll taxes, but paid out $702 billion in benefits. However, its other income, from investments and taxes on the benefits, more than covered its costs. Nevertheless, the fund took out $2 billion from the General Fund.
In 2011, the situation worsened. The Fund's total costs were $736.1 billion, including $725 directly paid in benefits. However, its income from taxes and investments was only $702.4 billion. The Fund required $102.1 billion from the General Fund, making it the first year the Fund contributed to the budget deficit .
Yes, socialistic:
The question may arise concerning what is welfare state, and the simple answer is that welfare state is a government that provides for the total well-being of its citizens and is akin to socialism . However, very few true welfare states exist. The United States is a good example of this as it provides some social insurance or entitlement programs to its citizens but does not espouse socialism
Welfare programs available in the United States include: Medicaid, Food Stamps, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Housing and Urban Development (HUD) programs, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), Head Start, Work Study, and Medicare.
There's no need to take "ideology" out of anything. SSI is a socialistic program and it is growing exponentially. When the SS Trust Fund is depleted the option for American citizens will be SSI which allots benefits equally amongst those who have no personal assets.
I never said the US is a socialist state. I proved with a definition that Supplemental Security Income is a socialist program. Big difference there.
And if we cut SSI out of the budget it would help to fix the deficit, as would each and every $44 BILLION a year expenditure.
And if you think I'm not correct in supposing that Obama's plan is to eventually see Social Security replaced with the more socalistic SSI program, please feel free to read this:
And your continuing rants about all the libertarians has stopped pissing me off. Now I simply find it funny that a simple philosophy of liberty scares you so much.
Yea.....I use to know a fellow like that. He would go by lunch for everyone and you had to give him the exact amount. If for some reason your meal was only $5.00 and you only had a $10.00 bill don't expect to get any change back. I guess they figured the future politicians were going to be just as untrustworthy as them.
Yes the Congress was controlled by the Republicans thru out Clinton's second term. Not that they are any better or any less crooked.