╌>

10 Facts Obama Doesn't Want You to Know About His Social Security Slashing Budget Plan

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  13 years ago  •  2 comments

10 Facts Obama Doesn't Want You to Know About His Social Security Slashing Budget Plan

http://www.alternet.org/10-facts-obama-doesnt-want-you-know-about-his-social-security-slashing-budget-plan

1. Ofcourseits a benefit cut.

Chained-CPI defenders say its not a benefit cut, just a slowdown in the rate of the benefits plannedincreases. Thats a silly semantic game unworthy of serious leaders or analysts. The Social Security benefit, as laid out on the Social Security Administrations website, includes adjustments designed to keep pace with the rising cost of living.

Those adjustments arent a benefitincrease.Theyre designed to prevent the benefit from beingdecreasedas a result of inflation. If you lower that adjustment, youre cutting benefits. Period.

2. Ofcourseits a tax hike.

Same goes for the tax impact of the chained CPI. Our tax brackets were designed to make sure that taxes didnt go up inadvertently because inflation kicked them into a higher tax bracket. That was done to make sure that people who werent earning more in real dollars which includes many (if not most) of the 99 percent werent hit with an unearned tax hike.

The President has repeatedly promised that there will be no middle-class tax hikes while hes President.

If you substitute the chained CPI for the current formula, as the President has proposed, people will be kicked into higher tax brackets earlier. Then theyll pay more in taxes, even if theyre not making any more real money.

Thats a tax hike.

3. And its a tax hike for everybody but the wealthy.

In fact, its a tax hike on all but the highest levels of income. The richest earnings wont be affected because theyrealreadyin the highest tax bracket.

Got it? So its a tax hike on everybody except the richest among us. (Actually, its a tax hike for them too, but only on their lower levels of income. The richer you are, the less youll see in a tax-rate increase.)

4. You could save much more money in other, better ways.

The White House has said the chained CPI will save $122 billion in benefits over ten years. Leaving aside the fact that Social Security doesnt affect the deficit (which well discuss shortly), heres whatisntbeing done:

Close capital gains loopholes: $174 billion.
End the Bush tax cuts at Obamas original $250,000 level, rather than the compromise $400,000 number: $183 billion.
Cut overseas military bases by 20 percent: $200 billion.
Negotiate with drug companies: $220 billion.
Enact Defense-friendly Pentagon cuts: $519 billion.
End corporate tax loopholes(without being revenue neutral, as the Presidents proposing): $1.24 trillion.
Enact a financial transaction taxon the folks who ruined our economy: $1.8 trillion.

Faced with those numbers, the chained-CPI benefit cut is well, embarrassing. (Details, and additional alternate deficit reducers, here .)

5. The White Houses proposed bump disproves its own argument.

The Administrations been claiming that the chained CPI is merely a technical adjustment designed to make cost-of-living increases more accurate. But its just introduced an adjustment for seniors who live longer in order to offset the impact of its reduction over time.

But if the chained CPI really measured inflation more accurately, it wouldnt affect real benefits any more after twenty or thirty years than it did after the first year. Confusing? We explain here . (With pictures and everything.)

Bottom line? They know its a benefit cut.

6. Its political suicide for Democrats.

The polls are clear on that question. Voters over fifty hate the chained CPI. It doesnt matter whether theyre Democrats, Republicans, or independents. They hate it.

And older Americans are more likely to vote than other voters (who also hate it, according to earlier polls.)

It took the Republicans all of fifteen minutes to portray this move, which theyve supported for a long time, as a shocking attack on seniors. Theyre ready to run a reply of their successful 2010 strategy, when they ran to the left of Dems with a Seniors Bill of Rights and recaptured the House.

7. The Social Security cut doesnt reduce the deficit.

Social Security doesnt contribute to the deficit, since its funded separately. In fact, itsforbidden by lawfrom contributing to the deficit.

It doesnt even belong in these negotiations.

8. That tax hike on everybody except the wealthy will help a little. But

On the other hand, theyll be hitting everybody except millionaires and billionaires with tax increases that grow with every passing year.

If regressive taxation is something you believe in, then I guess thats something. Except for our next embarrassing fact

9. The deficits already shrinking rapidly.

The deficit is already shrinking and rapidly, in the words of those radical lefties at Goldman Sachs .

The deficit isnt our most urgent economic problem. Its not even close. We desperately need jobs, real wage growth, consumer confidence, financial security for the elderly and disabled (which meansincreasingSocial Security)

Sure, deficits need to be addressed after the economys been righted, but right now theyre nowhere near the top of the list.

In fact, theres an extremely good chance that the cuts in the Presidents budget will make the deficit worse, as austerity cuts have in Europe. The Republican budget would certainly have that effect, since its cuts are far more severe.

10. It doesnt matter if the GOP asked you to do this.

It doesnt matter if the GOP asked the White House to call for this benefit cut and middle-class tax hike,as White House Press Secretary Jay Carney is now saying . The Presidents been floating the idea for years. He and his appointees have defended it publicly.

And now the President has officially included it in his budget.

The Republican budget didnotinclude it.

And now theyre using it against the President and his Party. That should surprise no one. To paraphrase the question asked by generations of American mothers: If the Republicans asked you to jump off a bridge ?

The chained CPI is the wrong answer to the wrong problem at the wrong time. Its time for the White House to recognize that, cut its losses, and ditch this turkey of an idea. In the meantime Democrats need to walk away from it fast, before they pay a high price for it at the polls.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The really sad part is that it doesn't really matter that this is political suicide for Democrats. The duopoly is strong and people in this country are too unorganized, too stupid, or both to vote any other way.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It's a trap! Obama knows the Republican House will never agree to any budget that raises taxes on the rich. He'll sucker them into rejecting it then remind everyone he tried to compromise while the Republicans wouldn't budge. Then, down the road, he'll take everything off the table and urge the electorate to settle everything by giving the Democrats and Pelosi the House in 2014.

In the meantime, the Sequester has begun to kill jobs and unemployment benefits et al and the victims will blame the Republicans for that too.

Democrats need to walk away from it fast, before they pay a high price for it at the polls.

Looks like you've fallen for the ploy. Between the above, the 91% of Americans who want gun safety reform and immigration reform and the passage of jobs bills and higher taxes for the rich, it's a perfect storm for the Democrats. Toss in a few million gallons of tar sands sludge in residential areas and see ya' later Boehner and Tea Party boys and girls.

 
 

Who is online







112 visitors