Elsevier: All your data belongs to us
A distinct sense of dj vu kicked in Tuesday afternoon as I read a series of outraged tweets decrying the news that Elsevier, the giant publisher of scientific journals, was buying Mendeley, a cloud-based social media research platform popular with academics for such tasks as organizing citations and managing access to articles.
The aggrieved tone was almost exactly the same as the backlash that erupted a few weeks ago when Amazon bought GoodReads at the time, the largest independent reader community on the Web.
The issues at hand arent identical. In the Elsevier case, many of the academics who are most upset are strong believers in the principle of open access to scientific information, and they see Elsevier as their blood enemy. An excellent summary of the argument against Elsevier can be found at the Cost of Knowledge but the gist is simple: Elsevier extracts huge profits from a business in which the vast majority of creative work is contributed on a voluntary basis by academics. The company then turns around and uses a portion of those profits to lobby for even tighter intellectual property control. - http://www.salon.com/2013/04/09/elsevier_all_your_data_belongs_to_us/
Corporate greed that legally steals from people.
Anything you post online, can be legally stolen and used for profit by people with money, even if a site's TOS and Privacy policy state otherwise. One of the biggest offenders of this is Facebook but it does not stop there.
In this case, research and papers originally written and distributed for free was acquired by Elsevier, who will turn around and legally copyright that material as theirs then sell it for profit.
I understand such things. I had my own research, which I worked long and hard on, legally stolen from me a few years ago. Never again.
