╌>

Supreme Court Watch - Another 1st Amendment Challenge - Spirit Air, et al v Dept of Trans.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  polly-cooper  •  13 years ago  •  7 comments

Supreme Court Watch - Another 1st Amendment Challenge - Spirit Air, et al v Dept of Trans.

At issue here is whether the Dept of Transportation may regulate whether airlines may advertise the Government Tax portion of airline tickets. The DOT says that if an airline does this (Spirit's website breaks down the cost of the ticket and the "government's portion") then the consumer is confused as to the price of the ticket. Oh yes, we're all that stupid.

From Spirit's brief to the SCOTUS:

The Government has not been shy about seeking to impose even criminal penalties on those who engage in truthful non-misleading speech (my emphasis) that the government nonetheless perceives as deceptive...the root of the government's theory is that it has a relatively free hand to regulate truthful non-misleading speech it deems to have the potential for misleading consumers.

A regulation that restricts truthful speech about the tax burdens borne by consumers would be constitutionally dubious in any industry, but it is intolerable in an industry Congress has expressly chosen to deregulate.

It seems that the Government doesn't want you to know how much taxes you are really paying. I believe that a "win" for the Airlines, in this case, is a "win" for the American Citizens.

http://sblog.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/No.-12-656-Reply-Brief.pdf


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

The government's attempt to regulate truthful free speech is abhorrent.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Actually I once sat down pencil in hand and roughly calculated all the taxes that I pay in a given year to the State, Municipality and the Feds. I will never perform that exercise again, all I accomplished was self aggravation.

I would only ask: Whatever became of the notion of truth in advertising? But in their defense Boudicea, sadly there are many that would be confused as to the ticket price.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Not so much, luther. The website is absolutely positively clear. There are 3 columns. First is price of fare. The second is "government's cut" The third is total cost of ticket. If you are THAT stupid, there is no hope for you.

I know what you mean about the truth in advertising thing. We bitch and moan about what we perceive as dishonesty but why in the hell is the government regulating what is without doubt the TRUTHFUL advertising because it makes them look bad?

The problem is you've got a ticket that's $14 (actual example in the case) and government fees and taxes are $28. Does that make the airline look bad or the government?

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Hate to be a cynic, but I feel that leaves many of our citizens somewhat hopeless.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

And yet the SCOTUS appears to have questioned whether the DC court of appeals is right. The problem I have with this is a) The DoT never said Spirit didn't comply with their rules - even the one which said the taxes and fees had to be in a smaller font than the total price.

This case is not about false advertising, it is about whether the DOT can regulate TRUTHFUL advertising - which on its face seems ridiculous. Doesn't it?

And did you read the brief I linked in the article? Spirit is calling this regulation of POLITICAL speech. That's going to have a massive impact if the Court decides it is

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

I know, right? Of course, the FTA is trying to do the same with hotel rooms.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

No surprise here.

 
 

Who is online







125 visitors