Dem Party official makes students 'stomp on Jesus'
A synopsis of the lesson plan in question, obtained by Fox News, goes like this:
Have the students write the name JESUS in big letters on a piece of paper Ask the students to stand up and put the paper on the floor in front of them with the name facing up. Ask the students to think about it for a moment. After a brief period of silence instruct them to step on the paper. Most will hesitate. Ask why they cant step on the paper. Discuss the importance of symbols in culture.
It turns out, the stomp-on-Jesus professor, Poole, also has a prominent position in local politics. As Bizpacreview reports, Poole is vice-chairman of the Palm Beach County Democratic Party.
http://www.wnd.com/2013/03/dem-party-official-makes-students-stomp-on-jesus/

I think that, in order to prove he is not a religious bigot, he should also have the students write "Mohammed" on a piece of paper and stomp on it. Let's see how well THAT "tolerance teaching" works out for him.
Though I myself am areligious, I have great respect for all true believers. The choice of any religious icon would be a poor one indeed, the professor could have come up with many alternatives rather than adding fuel to the simmering religious fires. Not a very wise teacher in my opinion.
I agree. I hope people realize the sarcasm in the above comment.
I dont think that lesson would work for anyone except people of the Islamic faith. The lesson is symbolism... people walk all over symbols they dont understand all the time... because they dont understand them or know what they mean.
Just because the symbol he used is so polarizing, this lesson will be questioned.
This is a lesson in empathy as well. People should know that stomping all over something that someone else holds dear isnt exactly a way to get favorable reaction.
I think this is a very strong lesson actually. More people should be shown the reality of what desicration of something they hold in strong regard means... ACTUALLY MEANS... and what it makes them feel and why...
Ifstudents were to exercise reflection on their own actions and how those actions impacted society, they would be better matured. A lot of poor decisions come from being unable to internalize the outcome of a given action.
I beg to differ. I think nearly every American knows who Mohammad is by now. But you make a point. Did the lesson, the way it was taught, work for any Muslims that were in the class?
Perhaps he should have found out the religion of all the students to make sure he was teaching them ALL a lesson Hmmm?
It wouldnt hold the same weight for sure 96WS6. The better lesson would probably be to write your god of choice... or your mothers name... or some other name that you hold in high esteem...
"More people should be shown the reality of what desicration of something they hold in strong regard means... ACTUALLY MEANS... and what it makes them feel and why..."
Again I say perhaps he should have made sure he was actually teaching the ENTIRE CLASS a lesson...
The reason he did not is because if there was a Muslim in his class and he asked them to write Mohammad's name on the paper he would be putting his life in danger.
Case in point: Why not try to teach "diversity" and "tolerance" to those that need it most?
BTW the real problem here is that the asshole suspended the student that refused to do it!
The choice of Jesus would be appropriate given a certain makeup and population. But I agree, that the symbol of choice should have been "tricked" out of the students by asking them to put something they really believe in and hold dear on the paper instead of a generic term applied to everyone.
The real problem I have with the whole thing is that the asshole suspended the student that refused to do it. I hope he gets fired over it.
I agree. This guy know what he was doing and should be fired, see post below:
The student who cannot participate in this exercise is unable to fit himself into a position of having his beliefs challenged.
Since the course is Intercultural Communication, that isnt the best situation to put such a person in. If he is unable to see his religion desicrated in a controlled fashion in which HE is the one doing it without examining his own feelings or becoming defensive... he obviously cant handle someone from another culture doing it (whether intentional or not).
While I dont think suspension is the best course, I do thinkthe student should be thinking about whether or not the class or course of study is really for him.
if urine was involved it may have been "art" worth subsidizing with tax dollars.
I agree, however, I was unable to find what class this was or if it is a required class. Point is that maybe the student did not have the choice of an alternative course of study.
Oh PLEASE,
You act like FOX made this crap up or something.... You obviously don't like FOX so pick another...
Attacking the source just because you don't like the facts is pitiful.
Most communication courses are to supply a humanities credit. Most students pick elective courses based on what fits in their schedule.
If he picked this course based on his major requirements, he should really rethink the major.
If he picked this course for his schedule, he can always find another course to fit the requirements for electives.
I dont think they would suspend the student simply for voicing an opposing opinion. If he was doing it in a non-constructive way (threats, disrupting class, or causing undue stress to other students participating), he perhaps deserves to be suspended.
I dont think there are enough details in this news blurb to answer the questions surrounding the situation in order to judge the professor at fault or not.
I think it is inappropriate that the professor used any religious reference in the lesson. There are a lot of other ways he could have done it. Some that you mentioned yourself.
I think religion represents a low hanging fruit for this exercise and nothing should be off limits when discussing things like society taboos and symbolism. It's kind of the point of the course(in my mind) to challenge such things.
But I realize that my way of thinking isnt the way everyone else does.
I do think the headlines are both sensational and misleading though. The political aspect has nothing to do with this teaching method.
if only it had been a greenpeace flag, then there would be congressional hearings and jail time for sure
I have some difficulty in believingthe studentmade his reluctance known in a constructive manner to be suspended from class for just a refusal to do the assignment.
It is possible that the professor is a maurading lunatic with a control complex, that when faced with a person who refuses to do an assignment, lunged at him and physically removed him from class, then suspended him from it indefinitely.
It is equally possible the student, when faced with something he was unwilling to compromise on, lunged at the professor and berated him, the institution and the entire class for allowing the desicration to occur.
Bottom line is, I dont know what happened... but given that the class was for intercultural communication... and that people step on each other's symbols, taboos and social norms through living and breathing in a different culture... it makes sense to challenge students with their beliefs to start a dialogue on how what they do without thinking could really affect someone else.
As for being 20 and having a solid sense of self, obviously the student in question is not strong enough in their own belief system to challenge it without taking personal offense. I can admire that passion, but in a class that is structured toward multiculture communication, it isnt a good space for it.
The letters J, E, S, and U are not holy... nor is a piece of paper... when combining them, how does it suddenly become holy and beyond reproach? That is the entire lesson of symbolism. And for the student to take it personally shows that they cannot disconnect themselvesor see the world empathetically because their own bias keeps them rooted in their singular perception of their version of right/wrong.
Well there is always at least one asinine, troll-like comment in every discussion isn't there? Thanks for keeping up the perfect track record!
To continually burn other people's symbols in effigy is quite different than challenging your own symbolism with your own foot. For one thing, you are burning someone else's symbols... for another you are taking the control away from those who value the symbol.
Like I said before, the choice on Jesus alone is not constructive. It was also probably based on the fact it is low hanging fruit and that the student population was most likely judeo/christian in makeup.
But the exercise remains the same. Your control over your own symbol and the destruction of it is much different than telecasting your control over someone elses symbol and destroying it.
Why continually bring up the high reactionism of Muslems in defense of this student? Do you want him to be as highly religiously reactive? It doesnt make sense to me to keep usingMuslems as the refuting point.
If it were a Muslem student, and the professor required everyone to step on Mohommed's name... and he threatened the professor or was suspended... would you be as put out by the story? A bigger question is, would we even hear about the story to begin with?
Maybe the saddest answer is yes, I could see the headline... Rep party official makes student 'stomp on Mohommed'.
It reads the same way to me no matter which way it reads though... sensational drivel over political party...loosely connected with a professor who has a student refusing to do something he doesnt believe in... in some manner that is so inconsistent with social acceptance that he is suspended as a result of it.
Possibly...
Do you really think that most people actually don't know that?
I could be wrong, but IMO when someone desecrates something that some people revere, they are usually aware of that! In fact, that's usually the reason why they do it!
Perhaps he could have made the point better by not desecrating a religious symbol. For example, he could have had them burn American flags.
OK-- but what if were the letters M-O-H-A-M-M-E-D? Would you say that they are not holy? (Or would that be different?)
What if it had been a cartoon-- such as this one?
"Jesus and Mo"
Well here is an article saying the FL governor is getting involved so I guess it really happened. Although you will undoubtedly say the governor is mistaken or lying.
...
I am sure the "Charlotte observer" is somehow connected to FOX...at least in your mind.
Here is another article with a video of the FAU's Senior Vice President of Student affairs apologizing for the dip shit professor but I am sure this is not factual enough for you either.
...
I guess if it is not on MSNBC you think it is not real news right?
BTW the teacher has not made a statement...probably because he is a spineless asshat as implied by the article, so if that is the side of the story you want to hear you will probably have to call him.
I bet if you tried to enter a picture of Mohammad in piss there would be "content control" faster than you could possibly imagine.
Needmorecoffee
You made it sound like you didn't even believe the event occurred. I offered more proof that it did.